This book is a major undertaking that surveys most of the documented history of the city of Banias from antiquity through the second half of the 20th century. Known in antiquity as Paneion, Paneas, Caesarea Paneas, or Caesarea Philippi, Banias is situated on the slopes of Mount Hermon at the springs of the Banias River, a tributary of the Jordan. Wilson suggests that originally it was a site protected by Ba

al and his son Aliyan, the god of sources. Sometime after the conquest of Alexander the Great, the Canaanite god merged with the Greek god Pan, and it served as a local center for pilgrimage and worship. A change in this pastoral ambiance occurred in 200 B.C., when the Seleucid king, Antiochus III, conquered the entire southern Levant from the Ptolemies.
In 20–19 B.C., Herod the Great erected a temple, according to Josephus “at the sources of the Jordan; the place is called Paneion” and “near the place called Paneion” (p. 10), and dedicated it to the worship of his patron, Augustus, and perhaps also to the goddess Roma. The temple of Augusteum was one of the earliest prototypes of a Roman imperial cult temple. Wilson's presumption that Herod settled this place with Jews and built a palace for himself to reinforce his economy and quell the Iturean insurgences has neither archaeological nor historical foundations.
Approximately 17 years later, presumably a year after his ascension to power, Philip Herod, son of Herod the Great, expanded the project, founding a city near the Augusteum named Caesarea Paneas, known in the New Testament as Caesarea Philippi. Today, after decades of thorough excavations by four different teams, much about the city and the specific location of the Augusteum remain a mystery. In the 1970s, Ehud Netzer suggested the remains of a structure overlooking the cave from the west and built in a technique known as opus reticulatum, the hallmark of Herodian structures. In the early 1990s, Zvi Uri Ma

oz proposed remains of a 1st-century structure at the entrance of the cave. Wilson and Vasilous Tzaferis suggested locating the temple below the remains of a large basilica 250 meters southwest of the cave; more recently Andrew Overman proposed the remains of a temple located a few kilometers south of the cave. Netzer's suggestion seems most reasonable, because he places the temple on the promontory lining up above the main street of the city, which would accord with the aesthetic ideals of the 1st-century A.D. Roman town planning. Yet, Wilson places equal weight on all contending sites without taking a definitive position.
As a result of the Herodian endeavor, Caesarea Paneas/Philippi became a center of the Roman imperial cult, and this played a major role in the life of the city for the next generations. In this cult Augustus became the “prince of peace” reigning over the Pax Romana, and his wife Livia (later known also as Julia) was identified with the Greco–Roman goddesses, Keres/Demeter/Proserpina/Persephone. She was worshiped as the goddess of revival, prosperity, bounty, and fruit bearing. Wilson fails to see the that coins minted at the city during the time of Philip (4 B.C.–33 A.D.) and Agrippa I (37–44 A.D.), such as the one showing a hand holding ears of grain and the legend “fruit bearing” (carpophoros) propagated the symbols of the imperial cult. Countering recent scholarship, he asserts that it “may be a reference to the prosperity of the capital city and of the kingdom in general” and that “it further strengthens the theory that the city was founded in 3 BC” (p. 20).
Wilson also dismisses the common interpretation that a coin minted by Philip dating to 30 A.D. that bears the attribute “founder” indicates the foundation of Bethsaida and surmises instead that Philip must have founded Caesarea Philippi twice. His treatment of the subject is selective, speculative, and unacceptable to most scholars.
Chapters 3 and 4 deal with the Roman period during the 2nd to the 4th centuries A.D. when the city reached its “golden age of pagan Banias” (p. 43). In chapter 5, “Jews and Christians in Pagan Banias,” Wilson deals with the visit of Jesus. Peculiarly, this is found under the title “Christians in Banias” (p. 78) instead of Jews in Banias. His conclusion that “the district of Banias (and perhaps the city itself) appears to have been a major center in the development of Christianity—its structure, its theology, and its literature” (p. 83)—is highly exaggerated.
In chapters 6 and 7, dealing with Byzantine Banias, Wilson devotes a long discussion to the mystery of a “statue of Christ” that was visible at Banias and perhaps is correct in assuming that it might have been the Roman free-standing statue of Hadrian that was wrongly interpreted as depicting Jesus and the woman cured of the issue of blood. The statue, however, disappeared in the Byzantine period, and it is doubtful whether it had any historical impact.
Chapters 8 to 11 survey a long history from the Arab conquest to the end of World War I. Wilson recounts stories of individuals associated with Banias and outlines the general political history of the Middle East. After the Ottoman conquest in the 16th century, the town rapidly declined into negligence and poverty. European travelers who started to arrive at Banias in the 19th century preferred to pitch their camps outside the pitiful village. Wilson mostly reads documents in translation and refers to secondary works, not all of which are scholarly.
The epilogue surveys the site from the British conquest to the 1967 Six Day War, during which villagers fled and their poor dwellings were razed to the ground. Banias is today a national park within which his (and Tzaferis') team operated.
Wilson works in the old style of a city historian, writing merely about the political history of the city. He employs only literary documents and makes surprisingly little use of the vast archaeological data that was compiled on the city. However, archaeologists have long ceased to be merely reporters of architectural remains; they now consider data from the hard sciences, including social and anthropological studies. Hopefully, the next volume will cover these issues. However, Wilson's book is written with great love and passion for Banias and its history, even if the picture is slightly distorted.
