To provide an understanding of women and poverty in twenty-first-century America, Paula vW Dáil draws on structured interviews of a sample of poor women and descriptions of the primary social-service policies that impact their lives. Resonating throughout this book is the author's respect for the women who shared their “damned hard” lives with her. Dáil holds that these poor women stand for all poor women, although her sample is not random. Moreover, denied access to Asian and Hispanic communities, she was only able to interview Caucasian and African American women. One assumes that the sample size is fourteen, the number of women whose lives are briefly described early in the book and whose experiences Dáil later alludes to in discussing women's crime, health care, educational achievement and working lives. The women are from Wisconsin, which is also a reference point for most issues raised in the book. It is not a particularly poor state, but Milwaukee, the fourth-poorest city of its size in the country, is “a typically poor urban area of the U.S.” (233). Wisconsin, moreover, “provides a good example of both effective and ineffective poverty policies” (233).
It is understandable that Dáil would discuss the derivation and size of the official US poverty standard, for it is used to count the poor and to determine eligibility for a number of social welfare programs. However, one would expect her to have pointed out some effects of this very low absolute standard. Using it to determine eligibility and to count the poor denies benefits to many needy persons and minimizes the problem, thereby tending to reduce public concern about it. Based on the lower European relative standard of less than 50 percent of median income, the Luxembourg Income Study reported a US poverty rate of 17.3 percent in 2004, compared to the US official rate of 12.7 percent – a difference of between 37 and 50 million people.
Dáil regards poverty as a condition that “occurs when certain groups of individuals cannot compete for an equal share of available profits or resources”; it is “the result of a free-enterprise, profit-motive capitalist economic system” (9). Thus poverty is both an individualistic and systemic phenomenon. Dáil calls attention to the “newly poor” who “played by the proven rules of success,” gaining the resources they needed to compete effectively (28). Their plight illustrates the fact that employability or ability to compete successfully is closely related to employment opportunity. What if poor women become better educated and skilled, acquiring middle-class characteristics that economist Isabel Sawhill, an expert cited by Dáil, says they need in order to be more competitive? Unless jobs increased, that would only heighten competition for existing resources. Dáil proposes direct job creation by government as a possible solution to poverty – raising, but not subsequently answering, an important question: “Who would lose out … if our poverty problems were resolved through widespread guaranteed employment opportunities and fair wages?” (11).
Dáil adheres to Carol Gilligan's theory that women are more “relational” and more likely to take on caring roles than men but does not cite research relating this theory to poor men and women. According to Dáil, poor men, “like most males,” are more autonomous and psychologically more able than poor women to absent themselves from family responsibilities they find untenable. As Dáil notes elsewhere in the book, public assistance policy, until 1996, encouraged poor men's absence by denying aid to two-parent families. Further, rising unemployment among black males has been related by sociologist William Julius Wilson and associates to their failure to assume family roles and to increased single parenthood. These environmental conditions need to be taken into account in understanding the behavior of poor men for whom the description “autonomous” seems misplaced. In what would seem to contradict theory concerning poor women's caring behavior, Dáil cites a Milwaukee school superintendent's observation that today's poor women are not caring for their children but rather leaving it to their mothers, nor, according to another source, are they helping each other. Dáil does not address these seeming contradictions or relate them to her sample. In another unresolved contradiction, girls, owing to family roles, are said to be less motivated to become educated, but Dáil subsequently reports that poor women are pulling ahead of male counterparts in educational achievement.
Drawing on the experiences of women in her sample and years of poverty research, Dáil incisively evaluates a wide array of social programs. However, she omits the largest US antipoverty program for poor families, the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC). A refundable tax credit, the EITC goes mainly to workers whose incomes are too low to pay federal income taxes. It is essentially public assistance, most of which is counted as a direct expenditure in the federal budget. Administered through the Internal Revenue Service rather than a welfare agency, it escapes the stigma of welfare. In addition to the federal EITC, many states have EITCs, including Wisconsin.
Dáil decries the large amount government spends on the poor with rather poor results. Yet progress against poverty demands not only better policies but larger expenditures on such programs as subsidized child care and housing, neither of which is available to all who meet eligibility criteria. Initial costs of job creation on a scale to eliminate poverty would be large, although, in the long run, it would save money by substantially reducing many problems associated with unemployment. A focus on employment would obviate a problem claimed by some experts Dáil cites: that the welfare state reduces individual responsibility. Full employment policies were, if anything, more important than generous welfare benefits in those Nordic countries that nearly abolished poverty.
