The castles of the Nizārī Ismā‘īlis (often known as the “Assassins”) in Iran first came to the attention of Orientalist scholars in the 1830s as the result of visits by two intrepid British officers, Monteith and Shiel. Their accounts were published only a few decades after the beginnings of the modern historical study of the Ismā‘īli sect by Antoine Silvestre de Sacy and Joseph von Hammer-Purgstall. By the end of the nineteenth century the inscriptions of the Ismā‘īli castles of Syria had been published by Max van Berchem. While the historical evolution and religious beliefs of the different branches of Ismā‘īli Islam have received considerable scholarly attention during the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, the castles of the Nizārīs in Syria and Iran have languished in relative obscurity. Aside from the author of the book under review, there exist few notable studies including those by Freya Stark and Wladimir Ivanow on the castles of Iran and by John Phillips on the castles in Syria.
The reasons for the neglect of these impressive castles are not difficult to find. Many structures, and particularly those in Iran are in remote locations that require the use of off-road vehicles, and even mountaineering equipment to visit. The condition of the castles varies from the relatively complete remains of Qal'at Maṣyāf in Syria to others that are now little more than mounds of rubble. In the cases of the Iranian castles, much of the damage can be attributed to the deliberate effort of the Mongol armies to eradicate the military presence of the Nizārī Ismā‘īlis from their newly conquered territories. Natural processes of erosion over the centuries have only added to the ruinous state of once great military installations such as Alamut and Lamasar. In this context, Peter Willey deserves considerable gratitude for the pioneering research he has undertaken over the course of more than four decades. While his first book on this subject, The Castles of the Assassins (London, 1963) concentrates upon the principal castles in the mountainous region between Qazvin and the Caspian Sea, the present publication seeks to present a synthetic account of Ismā‘īli military architecture of Syria and Iran.
The Eagle's Nest is divided into two main parts: the first outlining the history of the Ismā‘īlis and of the Nizārī Ismā‘īli polities of the Middle East up to the Mongol conquest of Alamut; and the second assessing the surviving castles in regions of Iran, Syria, and Pakistan. The appendices comprise a list of the expeditions led by the author, a gazetteer of the Ismā‘īli castles, a discussion of the pottery from Ismā‘īli sites (by Rosalind Haddon), and a catalogue of Ismā‘īli coins of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries (by Hussein Hamdan and Aram Vardanyan). The historical Chapters (1–5) present a generally favourable account of the political, cultural, and military achievements of the Nizārī Ismā‘īlis. Since Willey makes no claims to be an historian, and the chapters are, with the exception of some rather romantic historical reconstructions and occasional factual errors, competently assembled using the modern scholarship on the history of the Ismā‘īlis, there is no need to offer further comment in this review.
The discussion of the military architecture itself is the most significant part of the book. Here the author brings together the results of many field seasons conducted, in the case of Iran, both before and after the Islamic revolution. The castles of Iran comprise the majority of this second part (Chapters 7–12), and are organised by region, with an introductory section (Chapter 6) dealing with strategic considerations. In Chapter 6 Willey identifies a crucial aspect of the great Nizārī Ismā‘īli castles of Iran. Contrasting these with the typical design of the Crusader fortified citadel, he notes that the Iranian castles occupy the entirety of the summit of a mountain, dividing this area into self-contained zones with a citadel located at the uppermost section. Certainly, he makes a powerful argument for the greater sophistication of the military engineering of the Nizārī Ismā‘īli castles, though he perhaps underestimates the challenges faced by the designers of the fortifications of the Crusaders states. Engaged in a colonial enterprise that required castles to control both land and trade routes, the Frankish engineers did not have the luxury of placing their structures on high mountain tops within inaccessible valleys. That said, it is difficult not to be impressed by both the scale and the complexity of castles like Alamut, Lamasar, Samiran, Gerdkuh, and Qa'in. One of the most interesting features brought out in Willey's discussion is the network of canals and cisterns that supplied many of these sites with water. Another important contribution of this book is that it establishes the number of major castles and their geographical distribution in Iran (see Map 2 on p. 33). In comparison, the two chapters devoted to Syria are rather brief, and only Qaliat Maṣyāf is given a ground plan to complement the written descriptions.
Two problems should be noted with the Eagle's Nest. First, the illustrations are inadequate to support the architectural analysis offered in the second part of the book. Leaving aside the commendable ground plans, the photographs and reconstruction drawings are of variable quality and usefulness to the reader. Willey rightly observes that the castles should not be seen in isolation, but should be understood as networks of installations that take advantage of the natural terrain. In this, he would have strengthened his argument with detailed maps (or satellite photographs) of the key valleys showing the placement of the fortresses and secondary installations. Second, on far too many occasions the text drifts from its central focus on architectural analysis and considerations of military strategy. The frequent digressions about travel arrangements, acquaintances of the author, and people encountered during the fieldwork leave the book in an uncertain middle ground between architectural history and personal travelogue. This is particularly apparent in the pages dealing with the castles of Syria (Chapters 13–14) and Badakhshan and Hunza (i.e. regions of Afghanistan and Pakistan, Chapter 15). Given that Chapter 15 discusses only one castle, Baltit, and had almost nothing to say about its defensive features, I struggled to understand why this section had been included in the book.
In conclusion, this book contributes to our knowledge of the military architecture of the Nizārī Ismā‘īlis. One hopes that this work, and Willey's other publications, will help to broaden the study of Middle Eastern castles that, until relatively recently, had been dominated by a rather narrow focus on the activities of the Crusaders in Greater Syria. This positive assessment must be balanced, however, against the limitations of the Eagle's Nest as a publication. The book would have benefited from rigorous editing to remove those elements that depart from the subject of military architecture and its historical context. This would have allowed more space for the detailed analysis of the defensive architecture of individual structures. Willey argues that the castles of the Nizārī Ismā‘īlis in Iran should be considered as superior to the greatest achievements of the Crusaders. While his judgement may prove to be correct, this book does not make the case as persuasively as it could have done.
