Mark Harrison's Contagion is an ambitious book on the history of sanitary controls and trade regulations developed in response to the spread of disease along routes of long-distance trade. The book draws on evidence that is global in coverage and that spans centuries, from the Black Death to the H1N1 flu epidemic. The chapters that address the history of sanitary controls through the early twentieth century are based on existing scholarly work and new case studies, and should be of particular interest to economic historians. The subsequent chapters extend the discussion to the present day and draw predominantly on news coverage and policy reports.
The organizing framework of the book is best described as the political economy of trade and public health policy. The central claim is that the decisions by governments to impose quarantine of goods and people, and other sanitary controls, were often politically and economically motivated. Harrison emphasizes that governments balanced the competing objectives of supporting commercial activity, maintaining foreign relations, and protecting public health when implementing sanitary regulations. Sanitary controls served as a bargaining tool in the “tit for tat” (p. 26) diplomacy of trade regulation. Port cities relaxed quarantines to gain a competitive advantage, but faced the risk of retaliatory measure such as embargoes. Governments contradicted medical expertise and rejected claims that diseases were contagious to avoid disruption to trade.
Early chapters discuss the system of quarantines and sanitary embargoes used to contain the spread of disease and regulate Mediterranean trade. Harrison begins with a summary of existing scholarship on the early medical writings about plague and contagion, as well as the emergence of protection from disease as a public good among Italian city states during the sixteenth century (chapter 1). He argues that the widespread abuse of quarantines as an instrument of foreign policy followed the deadly European plague epidemic in the 1660s, and came to be viewed as acts of aggression, leading to trade wars throughout the eighteenth century (chapter 2). Reformers and medical practitioners joined merchants in opposition to the quarantine system. The competition between imperial powers prevented a binding agreement on sanitary issues, despite a series of international conferences held in the latter half of the nineteenth century (chapter 3). The analysis of sanitary controls and trade would benefit from empirical evidence to evaluate the economic cost of disruption to trade from quarantine, relative to the human cost of mortality and the deterioration of health, and how these tradeoffs changed over time. In the absence of figures and tables, it is difficult to evaluate the magnitude of economic disruption caused by the quarantine system, as well as the effectiveness of quarantines at limiting the spread of disease.
Opportunities for the spread of disease increased with the growth of the British Empire's trade network and improvements in steam technology that drastically reduce transoceanic travel times. A case study of the English naval steamship, the Éclair, which allegedly imported yellow fever to Boa Vista, one of the Portuguese Cape Verde Islands, in 1844, illustrates how medical experts were pressured to reach “diplomatically convenient” (p. 106) conclusions to resolve disputes in favor of quarantine regulation. From the mid-1840s opposition to quarantine grew more widespread in Britain, as a progressive and humane sanitary regime was viewed to be in the national interest (chapter 4).
Poor governance and civil neglect are highlighted as contributing to the yellow fever epidemics in the American South and Latin America in the 1870s. U.S. relations with Latin American counties exemplified the relaxation of sanitary measures in the late nineteenth century. Emphasis was shifted from quarantine to surveillance, which relied on a system of disease notification and accurate sanitary intelligence (chapters 5 and 6). The move away from a rigid policy of containment was reinforced in the responses to the global plague epidemics of the 1890s as the new policy of risk management required preventative measures such as disinfection in ports of departure (Chapter 7). The focus on international epidemics and sanitary policy debates comes at the expense of a more detailed discussion of the decline in the severity and frequency of epidemics in many Western countries by the end of the nineteenth century. The role of improved sanitary systems and local public health authorities in the decline of adult mortality deserves more than a passing mention (p. 141).
The book concludes with an abbreviated discussion of a “new era in the governance of human health” (p. 230), extending from the Second World War to the present. The outbreak of Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) that began in the late-1980s led to extended bans on the import of beef, while the recent outbreaks of the H5N1 and H1N1 influenza strains led to the culling of poultry and bans on the import of pork. These examples suggest that sanitary regulations remain disruptive to trade and raise questions about the ability and willingness of governments to protect public health (chapters 8 and 9). While the examples show that the abuse of sanitary regulations has continued to the present, their similarity to the historical system of quarantine regulations should not be overstated, given that the institutional setting, and knowledge about disease and sanitary practices are vastly different from much of the historical periods dealt with earlier in the book.
In sum, Contagion is an accessible and wide-ranging volume that demonstrates how conflicts over sanitary regulations have disrupted trade across centuries in many different contexts. Harrison shows that the quarantine system represented not only a public health measure, but also a regulatory tool of foreign policy and international trade negotiations. The book is recommended to economic historians with interests in trade and public health.
