Since the publication of Joanne Pope Melish's work, Disowning Slavery (Reference Melish1998) at the turn of the century, scholars have increasingly pushed to deconstruct the myth of the free north. In the past 2 years alone, The 1619 Project has encouraged critical discussions regarding the narratives of enslavement; and universities, towns, and other institutions across the United States and the United Kingdom have acknowledged their historical relationships to slavery and the Atlantic slave trade. Marc Howard Ross' recent work, Slavery in the North, provides an important and powerful contribution to these discussions. In it, Ross explores how and why the history of 250 years of Northern enslavement disappeared from the wider public's collective memory and the recent efforts to recover what was collectively forgotten.
Ross begins by defining the two concepts central to his work, collective memory and collective forgetting. Collective memories are tied to “emotionally salient events or persons in the past that have particular relevance to how a group understands itself and the challenges it faces in the present and future” (p. 33). These memories are socially constructed and persist through a variety of interactions, most importantly rituals or celebrations, shared narratives, and objects or artifacts in “the commemorative and public landscapes” (p. 31). Ross contends these practices serve to both recognize and reinforce a collective memory. For example, holiday rituals, such as barbequing on the Fourth of July, not only commemorate a particular event, but also reinforce an individual or group's emotional and historical connections to a specific identity. Consequently, the absence, whether unintentional or intentional, of these critical components contributes to the process of collectively forgetting.
Ross then moves to a discussion of why and how forgetting took place. Skillfully synthesizing a wealth of secondary sources focusing on topics such as gradual abolition, slavery, or sectional debates leading up to the Civil War, he simultaneously discredits popular misconceptions regarding the role of slavery throughout the North and deconstructs previous reasoning for the nations' collective amnesia, ranging from explanations about the economic insignificance of slavery in the North to more pervasive assumptions that spawned from nineteenth century narratives about the moral superiority of northern abolitionists. Although these reasons might explain the lack of Northerners' awareness of the history of enslavement in the region, they do not address the question of how or why 250 years of human bondage could be forgotten.
It is here that his work in political psychology really shines through. Ross methodically discusses six plausible explanations for why the north, and the nation more generally, forgot about the history of northern enslavement. He asserts powerful incentives rooted in emotions such as fear, guilt, shame, and anger encouraged the unconscious and intentional erasure of memories of northern slaveholding. Most importantly, these dynamics contributed to the alteration or reframing of narratives of slavery in the north and the destruction or modification of sites associated with memory. For example, enslaved men and women in the north were often recast as “servants,” despite little or no change in their status as human chattel. In any case, Ross argues, “Collective forgetting of complicated, emotionally powerful events such as Northern slavery rarely occurs in a simple way or for a single reason” (p. 237). As is the route to memory recovery.
The book is organized into two unequal parts, the first focusing on the historical and theoretical frameworks for his analysis, while the second examines the diverse and complex processes of memory rediscovery, recognition, and memorialization through four specific case studies. Although it is only in the past 25 years, increased efforts have been made to include African Americans and the history of enslavement in the northern society's public and commemorative landscape. Through the site of the President's House and Independence Mall in PA, the African Burial Ground in NY, and the erection of other public and commemorative sites of slavery throughout the North, Ross examines the relationship between the dynamics of popular participation and collective memory recovery. As each case study demonstrates, the process of memory recovery is fraught with conflicts and tension. Through interviews, public meetings, and at times his own personal experiences, Ross demonstrates how different communities and organizations clash over issues of inclusion, identity, the legacies of enslavement, and how best to memorialize rediscovered memory. Consequently, it is through the process of rediscovering and re-evoking emotional power, narratives about a site, a visible presence, ceremonies and rituals, that collective memories are recovered, preserved, and transmitted for future generations.
However, Ross does not quite carry this trajectory forward and the relationship between memory recovery, memory retention, and younger generations raises new questions. Although the last chapter focuses on issues related to overcoming collective forgetting and the recent changes to museum exhibits or historical locations throughout the north, in many cases, the classroom is the first time an individual learns about the history of slavery. Despite continuing changes in the national education standards, public schools continue to struggle over how to teach slavery. Using Ross' framework, this would only serve to further entrench collective forgetting. So the question remains, how are individuals from the younger/future generations navigating the interplay between memory recovery and collective forgetting if educational institutions reinforce memory attrition?
This concern aside, Ross' work will no doubt encourage subsequent studies on the phenomena of collective forgetting and memory rediscovery. The interdisciplinary approach and brilliant use of case studies make this work accessible for both scholarly and public audiences. Moreover, scholars from a vast array of disciplines engaging in topics of slavery, identity, and race in the United States will find aspects of this work useful. Although a decade in the making, Marc Howard Ross' Slavery in the North is a timely and profound addition to the existing literature, and to current discussions on the history of enslavement in the North and the broader United States.
