The intersection between politics and popular culture has received critical attention from scholars, most famously in Edward Said's analysis of the ways in which aspects of imperialism permeate through novels by Kipling, Austen, Conrad, and other Victorian literary giants. Whereas Said was “concerned more with the impact of high culture and the influence of academia on European and American foreign policy” (p. 11), Reeva Spector Simon turns her attention in Spies and Holy Wars to British and American crime novels, from early 20th-century James Bond predecessors such as Richard Hannay to Tom Clancy thrillers, all of which are examples of popular culture that have not received the same academic scrutiny as more literary “orientalist” texts.
Simon traces the ways in which crime novels have been used to depict the threat of a “jihad,” a term whose linguistic ambiguity reflects the nature of Simon's project. In a footnote, the author clarifies that although “Muslims use the term ‘jihad’ to mean ‘to exert an effort’ both in a moral sense and also in defense of the Islamic community,” she uses it in a way that “connotes the Western perception of ‘holy war’” (p. 127). This duality, the separation between how Muslims see themselves and how “Westerners” perceive them speaks to the post-Saidian thrust of Spies and Holy Wars, which implicitly recognizes the categories “Islam” and “West,” just as Said did. Like much of Said's work, Spies and Holy Wars is concerned with how the “West” sees “Islam” and, by extension, itself.
The protagonists of both British and American crime novels evolved as political realities shifted throughout the 20th century. Israeli heroes, for example, reflected the masculinity that American heroes in the post-Vietnam era could not assert in fiction. The 1970s Israeli hero faded into a supporting role by the turn of the century. Arab, Iranian, Afghan, and other Middle Eastern villains also saw their roles shift as historical events unfolded. The “Levantine” was perceived as a suspicious character in earlier British novels that romanticized the purity of the Bedouin, the “noble” Arab savage. Later crime fiction switched these roles: the “pure Arab” became a source of danger, while the Westernized Arab occupied a role that brings to mind Homi Bhaba's phrase: “white, but not quite” (p. 40). British novels initially depicted Muslims as susceptible to control by other, more advanced entities, as in A. J. Quinell's The Mahdi. Following the oil embargo of 1973, the Islamic Revolution, and the Iranian hostage crisis, Muslims began to be perceived and represented as potential threats increasingly capable of carrying out evil.
Simon tracks these and other shifts with admirable precision and breadth. Spies and Holy Wars catalogues no less than 800 crime novels that span the 20th century, as well as 21st-century fiction attempting to dramatize and draw on the terrorist attacks of 9/11. The drawback of such an expansive approach is, predictably, a lack of depth. Simon adeptly observes the general trends that can be observed in crime novels set in the Middle East over a certain period. Often throughout Spies and Holy Wars, however, Simon touches on an intriguing thread and then moves on. For example, she hints at the ways in which Winston Churchill invoked the ethos of the British spy to convey the “nobility of espionage in war” (p. 71) and to the fact that J. Edgar Hoover, Allen Dulles, and Richard Helms utilized crime novels and spy thrillers to publicize for the FBI and CIA, respectively, but she does not further investigate these issues. Simon remarks instead: “whether all popular culture has been part and parcel of imperial design or a convergence of political and commercial interests I leave for readers to decide” (p. 12).
Simon discusses Nelson DeMille's The Lion's Game (2000), which features a Libyan terrorist named Asʾad Khalil, whom the protagonist, an American policeman, begrudgingly admires. The source of this admiration is the fact that Khalil is a sort of “lone horseman,” which an Arab American working for the NYPD associates with the rugged individualism of the American West. Although this villain is deplorable, certain traits he embodies are meant to spur the American protagonist John Corey into realizing and personifying the “national ethos.” Simon offers valuable insight into the ways in which the interaction between hero and villain, especially during the duel at the climax of the novel, underlines questions about multiculturalism. One angle she does not address is DeMille's apparent reference to Asʾad AbuKhalil, a professor of political science at California State University, Stanislaus. This apparent reference to AbuKhalil is interesting for two reasons: academic institutions are the object of Said's critique in his classic Orientalism, so it is intriguing to note an instance of orientalist popular fiction demonizing a member of academia. In addition, and perhaps more important, Professor AbuKhalil has been consistently vocal about his anti-Zionist positions. What is the significance of such a representation as it relates to academia, Zionism, and American foreign policy?
In spite of the fact that these and other questions remain beyond the scope of Reeva Spector Simon's Spies and Holy Wars, the book remains an intriguing, accessible examination of an area that remains somewhat understudied. Simon's probing of the concept of the “national ethos,” which many of the protagonists of British and American crime novels represent, could be very useful in the study of nationalism. She should be commended for her extensive, nuanced documentation of a body of work that spans over a century.
