Who and what is taken seriously in political analysis? Political scientists ask this question regularly, but they ask it in different languages—what level of analysis should this study focus on? What variables are important to analyze or control for in order to obtain an explanation? Where should the focus of research effort be? What are the most pressing problems to engage? Cynthia Enloe’s phrasing, though, is not an accident—she has been asking the question in the language of who and what are being taken seriously for more than a decade (e.g., The Curious Feminist: Searching for Women in a New Age of Empire, 2004). Asking about what is being “taken seriously” brings to the surface normative content that remains in the “traditional” way of asking these questions but is pushed beneath purportedly objective analyses with purportedly stable answers.
It’s not just that—in global politics and the study thereof, women are often not focused on, or considered an unimportant variable. According to Enloe, it is that women, femininity, sex, and gender are not being taken seriously. Enloe has demonstrated in many of her works (e.g.: Nimo’s War, Emma’s War: Making Feminist Sense of the Iraq War, 2011) that those who fail to recognize, or take seriously, women and gender in politics, are doing so not only at their normative peril, but at the peril of the comprehensiveness of their accounts of global politics.
Enloe is not advocating that the solution is to “add” women where they are absent, or to listen to women about women. In fact, as Enloe says early in the book, “simply being a woman is no guarantee that you will take women seriously” (p. 1). Rather than some over-simple notion of inclusion, Enloe explains, “to be taken seriously means to be listened to, to be carefully responded to, to have one’s ideas and actions thoughtfully weighed. It means that what one does or thinks matters—that is, that significant consequences come from it” (p. 5).
Seriously! Makes the case that “the trap—the dangerous temptation—here is to adopt other people’s patriarchal criteria for what is worthy of serious attention as our own criteria” (p. 15) and therefore continue with a tradition of either not taking women seriously or only taking women seriously instrumentally. Enloe argues for a feminist approach: “At the very core feminism is the conviction that women matter for their own sakes” independent of their value of any man, or the ways that they are instrumentalized in global, social, and political life (p. 15). Suggesting that the price of instrumentalizing the argument that women matter is too high, Enloe argues for an explanatory approach rather than an instrumental one (p. 16). Along these lines, Enloe suggests that it is important to take women, gender, and even feminism seriously—not only for its own sake but because “if feminist questions and feminist finding are dismissed as not serious—then the results can be inadequate explanations, flawed policies, failed efforts, and perpetuated injustices” (p. 7). In Seriously! Enloe foregrounds the sphere of political economy, with a focus on the 2008 financial crisis and its many contexts and aftermaths. Enloe makes the argument that accounts of crises that ignore the feminization of risk aversion among high-powered bankers, the trivialization of women’s political economies, and the profitability of patriarchy do so at their own peril, and as a result become at best partial and at worst inaccurate accounts.
Enloe demonstrates how the economic and political subordination of women (p. 110) is often used as a barometer of normality, where “women’s return to domesticated dependency is often taken as proof—as in the United States of the late 1940s and currently in Egypt – that a reassuring normalcy is being restored after the violence, after the turmoil” (p. 12). It is the very abnormalcy of these times that make them interesting to Enloe. She sees contemporary global politics as an unsettled space, both generally and in terms of gender relations. Enloe argues that the space where the “war on women” and the “war on terror” coincide is one where gender relations are in flux (p. 109). Enloe contends that “patriarchy cannot survive amid the current destabilizing changes” without patriarchy’s supporters finding incentive systems that privilege masculinities over femininities and curtail women’s agency (p. 10–11). Still, Enloe’s treatment of the possible death of patriarchy is not one full of unfettered optimism. Quite the opposite: Seriously! traces histories of patriarchy-maintaining incentive structures, both in the United States and around the world. For example, in the United States during the Cold War, “the threat of a husband’s domestic violence against a wife displaying autonomy served not just the husband but also the foreign-investment-dependent state and its multinational corporate allies” (p. 44). This is just one of a number of regimes of marriage, child care, and reproduction that engage and manifest in political, social, and economic relations to sustain regimes of patriarchy by not taking women seriously.
Seriously! furthers, both empirically and theoretically, Enloe’s sustained efforts to find, and foreground, women in the global political arena (e.g., Does Khaki Become You? The Militarisation of Women’s Lives, 1983; Manuevers: The International Politics of Militarizing Women’s Lives, 2000). It is singular in the breadth and scope of the feminist analysis that it presents of the contemporary global political economy, particularly in terms of the links between patriarchy, militarism, economic inequality, and global turmoil. The book is at once accessible to audiences unfamiliar with issues of gender in global politics, and sophisticated enough to be of use to specialists in the field. True to Enloe’s usual form, the insights of the book are smart, incisive, and innovative—but follow fluidly from Enloe’s and others’ previous work on gender in global politics.
If there are critiques to be had of Seriously! they fall in two main areas. First, the combined enthusiasm with which Enloe writes and the flow across forms of writing leave some parts of Seriously! feeling repetitive in terms of the primary contentions of the book. Second, the breadth of the analysis in the book sometimes comes at the price of a limitation on the depth of the analysis—of the substance of the financial crisis (particularly its geographical scope) and of the relationships between sex, gender, and sexuality (what constitutes the category of woman?). At the same time, it would be unreasonable to expect any book to cover both all of these bases and the ones covered in Seriously! and I would not want to push Seriously! to be less accessible, less engaging, or less enthusiastically written.
At the end of the day, the lessons of Seriously! are crucially important, both to contemporary global politics and looking forward. Enloe at once captures patriarchy’s vulnerabilities—to upheaval (pp. 10–11) and to policies taking women seriously (p. 182)—and its endurance in the face of crisis, making Seriously! a powerful reminder of both the stakes of gender subordination in global politics and the sustained work that will need to go into any effort to change it.
