I first read John Higham's book in an immigration history seminar in my first semester of graduate school at the University of Wisconsin. In fact, Higham visited campus that fall to present the Merle Curti lecture, named for his mentor. Higham's influence has remained significant: like many historians of immigration and ethnicity, I have often returned to his book during the course of my own teaching and research, whether on American Catholic history or U.S. immigration policy. My remarks focus on gender issues and immigration policy history in Strangers in the Land.Footnote 1
It is rather easy to note the lack of women in a 1950s monograph published two decades before the field of women's history began its ascent. However, analyzing their very absence from Higham's narrative offers a barometer of the tremendous growth since the 1980s of women's history, including studies of immigrant women. Women make a few appearances in Strangers in the Land. They are featured as Progressive Era reformers (Frances Kellor, Jane Addams, Josephine Roche), as immigrant authors (poet Emma Lazarus and Mary Antin), and as nativist socialites (specifically, Mrs. Astor and Mrs. E.E. Harriman). Mrs. Astor embodied the Gilded Age for Higham; Mrs. Harriman helped to finance eugenicist groups. Women are briefly mentioned in the context of female counterparts to male-dominated nativist groups (for example, Daughters of America). Much of the lack of scholarship on gender and nineteenth-century nativism evident in Higham's account was addressed later. Women active in the Woman's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU), for example, could easily be incorporated into a narrative on anti-Catholicism of the nineteenth century, and Nancy McLean and Kathleen Blee provided a fuller understanding of women in the Klan.Footnote 2
The final group of women that Higham mentions figure as female victims: Mary Phagan, whose death resulted in the lynching of Leo Frank, and, very briefly, the female victims in the Belgian raids in World War I that spurred negative media images of Germans, and by extension German Americans, in the propaganda efforts that preceded the U.S. entry into World War I. Those women, therefore, provided the motivation for men to intervene either as vigilantes or members of the Allied Forces. Except for Kellor, Higham discusses individual women in passing. He acknowledges a few native-born women and writers as social activists, but immigrant women are not envisioned as agents of their own experiences. As was common in pre-1970s historiography, women lacked the agency to decide to immigrate, to participate in the work force, to mobilize politically, or even to shape their communities. In contrast, men are active: they appear as legislators and government officials, immigrant laborers, labor leaders, elites, eugenicists, writers, and nativists. In fact, Higham does not discuss Emma Goldman, though hers emerged as one of the most famous deportation cases following the Palmer Raids and the ensuing Red Scare, which receives a fair amount of coverage in Strangers in the Land.Footnote 3
To me, the most interesting aspect of recent discussion of women's roles in immigration history—including studies of attitudes toward immigrants and the move to restrictionism—is the manner in which definitions of nation and citizenship are gendered, especially in the larger context of late nineteenth-century expansionism. Maternalism was inextricably linked to definitions of citizenship for women, whether through the activities of female reformers or through the notion that immigrant women were the predominant transmitters of culture to their children. Since Virginia Yans-McLaughlin, immigration historians have often discussed tensions between the cultural values of immigrants and reformers, with child-rearing practices as a particular flashpoint.Footnote 4
My own research and that of other historians working at the intersection of gender, migration, and the state has focused on family dependency, culture, sexuality, and poverty. The 1875 Page Law, and later the 1910 Mann Act, embodied concerns that prostitution posed an external threat, imported by immigrant women from China and subsequently Europe. Immigrant women were automatically subject to their husband's citizenship status until the Cable Act of 1922, which introduced other challenges for women. With a few exceptions, after 1875 Chinese women could immigrate only as wives. Prior to the 1930s, the Likely-to-Become-a Public-Charge provision tended to exclude women who arrived without husbands or fathers. Candace Bredbrenner, Martha Gardner, and other scholars have examined such issues in detail, providing information on how immigration policies have shaped women's experiences unavailable to Higham and his contemporaries.Footnote 5
Most of Higham's immigration policy discussion centers on the 1920s national origins legislation that culminated in the Johnson-Reed Act of 1924. He focuses on congressional debates, eugenics, and the perspective of labor unions and leaders, including Samuel Gompers. His discussion of national origins legislation in the 1920s remains one of the best in the field. Higham further emphasizes the rise of eugenics and its significant role in shaping immigration policy in the 1920s. Alexandra Stern, Peter D'Agostino, and several other historians returned to this topic in the 1990s and 2000s. A gendered approach to restrictionism and eugenics is also vital to understanding definitions of citizenship and immigration policy. My own research has found that women who gave birth outside of marriage were subject to deportation and were sometimes institutionalized as “feeble-minded.” The highly influential anthropological works of Cesare Lombroso, an Italian criminologist and eugenicist, categorized prostitutes and other women who violated bourgeois norms as hypersexualized and dangerous.Footnote 6
In Higham's work, one can detect the origins of later discussions of how empire building fueled immigration restriction. As he states, “Not all jingoes were nativists and not all nativists were jingoes, but both the aggressive psychology of the one and the defensive reaction of the other provided instinctive rallying points for a society dubious of its capacity to compose its conflicts.” In fact, as with much of Higham's book, a few of his paragraphs anticipated and influenced an entire historiographical strand within immigration history. For example, in Barbarian Virtues, Matthew Jacobson takes up Higham's argument by analyzing the relationship between U.S. expansionism in the Philippines, Puerto Rico, Cuba, and elsewhere and the justification for exclusion and restriction based on race. Both efforts relied on ideologies of inferiority and subjugation. Historians including Kristin Hoganson, Ann Laura Stoler, and others have demonstrated the vital role of women in U.S. expansionism. Many scholars have written about how female missionaries, teachers, nurses, and others had complex reasons for working in the Philippines and elsewhere.Footnote 7
Another striking issue that emerged from my recent re-reading of Strangers is the lack of immigrant perspectives or voices; this is in part because Higham classifies his approach as one of intellectual history. Nineteenth-century intellectuals and writers are cosmopolitans who are enlightened about the effect of immigration on American life. Melville and Whitman, he notes, “glorified the fusion of a mixed, and developing people.” Emerson, he concedes, remained less convinced of that benefit.Footnote 8
In what Higham characterizes as the “Confident Nineties,” democratic humanists such as Jane Addams also served as exceptions to pervasive nativism, but he does not assess the social settlement movement uncritically. Higham notes that progressives focused on non-controversial and in many ways unimportant cultural issues and “immigrant gifts,” such as folk dancing, music, and handicrafts. “It was all very genteel and uplifting, and very far removed from the rough, sweaty, painful adjustments that converted Europeans into Americans.” From Allen F. Davis onwards, social historians, immigration historians, and women's historians have explored the relationships between settlement houses, reformers, and immigrants with regard to issues of assimilation, cultural pluralism, and acculturation. Higham hints at the complexity of those interactions.Footnote 9
Higham makes deft use of irony throughout the book, such as in his apocryphal anecdote about a Bohemian woman whose sons were not available during door-to-door Americanization efforts because they were serving in the army or otherwise demonstrating their assimilation and patriotism. Although U.S. historians have been returning to the readable narrative and a broader approach to a subject than was standard in the 1980s and early 1990s, no contemporary historian would dare to launch a monograph with the following sentence: “From the Garden of Eden to 1984, no age or society seems wholly free from unfavorable opinions on outsiders.”Footnote 10
In his afterward to the second edition, Higham discusses his critique of nationalism and the influence of Merle Curti, his pacifist mentor at Wisconsin. He characterizes his book as representing a break with Charles Beard and others in the Progressivist school, who ignored race and ethnicity. He identified with the younger historians of the 1940s who wished to explain “the depth of racial and national antipathies satisfactorily.” Group rights and civil liberties, this newer generation believed, needed to be woven into the Progressivist historical framework that emphasized class and economic differences. He cites C. Vann Woodward as an example of one of his contemporaries who addressed such matters.Footnote 11
The new social history that fully emerged a generation after Higham published his book incorporated race into discussions of immigration policy, nativism, and eugenics to a much greater degree. By the beginning of the 2010s, racial definitions were central to any understanding of immigration, whether from Asia, Europe, Mexico, or elsewhere. Mae Ngai's book, Impossible Subjects, offered a fine example of that trend. Despite major historiographical shifts in the field of immigration history over the next fifty years, Higham's book continued to shape the field both by what it emphasized and what it was silent about. The book raised tantalizing, but undeveloped, points on numerous matters while providing an invaluable outline of the development of immigration policy. Moreover, his book offered an exemplary narrative, readable and accessible to a wide audience, while his analysis remains relevant to twenty-first century readers seeking to understand American anti-immigrant activism in a national, as well as global, context.Footnote 12
