The composer Jan Hugo (Vaclav) Voříšek remains something of a shadowy figure in music history.Footnote 1 Sometimes he appears as a predecessor to Schubert in the development of the genre of the romantic lyric piano piece, and elsewhere he is taken to be a kind of pre-Smetana figure within the larger historical movement of Czech musical nationalism.Footnote 2 Mostly, however, his music is not performed regularly in concerts.
Despite this, Voříšek has been remarkably well served on recordings. As early as 1972 the Czech pianist Rudolf Firkusny, a staunch advocate for Czech piano music, included Voříšek in his anthology of Czech piano music (Vox CDX 5058, digitally re-released in 1992), and the complete piano music was recorded by Radoslav Kvapil for Supraphon in 1974–75 (re-released on CD in 2003). Since then there have been a number of CDs devoted not just to Voříšek’s piano music, but also to his chamber music and to his single symphony, the Symphony in D major op. 24.
In addition to the quality of the music, other factors – stemming largely from the vagaries of history and politics – underlie Voříšek’s twentieth-century resurgence. Although the name Voříšek is clearly of Czech origin, the composer lived in a world in which almost everything connected to the arts and to intellectual sophistication functioned in the German language. Voříšek’s education in Prague at Charles University was in German, as indeed were his brief lessons in composition with Václav Jan Tomášek. In 1813, at the age of 22, he moved to Vienna, where he remained for the rest of his short life. He died in 1825 of consumption at the age of 34. During his life in Vienna, his name was spelled (as was common for the time) the German way: Worzischek. Professionally, Voříšek was Austrian-Bohemian, as were a great many composers of Czech heritage from the time, and for much of his reception he has been treated simply as Viennese. But following the communist takeover of the Czech government in 1948, there was a consolidation of music publishing activities in the country and a concerted push (already started earlier) to make available the scores of significant figures in pre-Smetana Czech music. This included Voříšek, who was treated for the first time as a Czech (not Austrian) composer. It was Czech musicologists who produced the first modern scores of Voříšek’s music, symbolically positioning his Impromptus op. 7 as the first volume in the then developing Musica Antiqua Bohemica series.Footnote 3 Eventually, all of Voříšek’s piano music was published in this series, which is now distributed by Bärenreiter. To no surprise, the composer’s name is now widely reprinted in the original Czech spelling.
However, in a fundamental way, Voříšek is most naturally understood as a Viennese musician, who flourished during his time there (1815–25) as a pianist, composer and, ultimately, court organist. Somewhat like Czerny (with whom he shared both his Czech heritage and birth year (1791)), Voříšek was strongly influenced by the young Beethoven. And throughout his short career it was Beethoven – not his younger contemporary Schubert, whom he likely never met – that was his musical point of reference. Much of Voříšek’s music has about it the musical fingerprints not just of the post-Classical style, but specifically of early Beethoven, whose rhythmic dynamism and pianistic idiom Voříšek evidently admired.
Released by the label Grand Piano, which specializes in new or undiscovered piano repertoire, this three-disk set of Voříšek’s complete piano music features the performances of Biljana Urban, a Dutch pianist. Compared with previous recordings, this new one has the benefit of modern recording techniques. Miked fairly closely, yet with a certain spaciousness, the sound quality is in the same general class as more famous, established labels. The first disk is devoted to the music contained in a slender volume of Voříšek’s piano music published by Henle in 1971, edited by Dana Zahn. The other two disks use the Supraphon editions mentioned above: the second disk is devoted to the miscellaneous pieces contained in volume 52 of the Musica Antiqua Bohemica series, and the third disk presents the 12 Rhapsodies op. 1, published as volumes 78 and 79.
In her performance of the Impromptus op. 7 (Voříšek’s best-known piano pieces), Urban strives to achieve the composer’s delicate, light pastoral moods. Whereas some performers treat Voříšek as a proto-Romantic, Urban’s performance is more in the vein of early Haydn, Mozart, and early Beethoven. By contrast, in his two-CD set of the most important examples of Voříšek’s piano music (Collins 14772 and 14582, 1993), Arthur Pizarro’s Voříšek is more in line with Schubert’s musical idiom. For my taste, I prefer Pizarro’s performances of these fragrant miniatures, not only for his superior keyboard technique, but also for the diaphanous quality of the piano sound and the more sprightly tempos. But this is only a point of personal preference and is in no way intended as a veiled criticism of the new recording, which is admirable in many respects. There are other performances to consider. Kvapil, who recorded these pieces twice, once in the mid-1970s and again in 1993 (Unicorn-Kanchana DPK 9145), shows a fine understanding of Voříšek’s music, but in the latter recording he was not blessed with a very attractive Steinway piano, and there is a harsh element to the recorded sound. If one can listen past the piano sound (not terrible, just not sonically compelling), one will encounter performances that are remarkably poised, both musically and technically, and are hard to surpass. At this point in time, however, not very many copies of Kvapil’s complete recording of Voříšek’s piano music are available for general sale, so interested readers will most likely need to choose from Pizarro or the newer recording by Urban.Footnote 4
Two of Voříšek’s most important piano compositions (in terms of length and substance) are his two-movement Fantasie in C major op. 12 and his Piano Sonata in B-flat minor op. 20, dubbed ‘sonata quasi una fantasia’ after Beethoven. Whereas the Fantasie is indebted to Hummel in its musical language, pianistic figuration, and formal scope, the sonata is modelled after Beethoven’s early Beethoven piano sonatas, especially opp. 2, 10 and 14.Footnote 5 This stylistic relationship is most apparent in both composers’ predilections for chordal second themes and for octave-doubled melodies supported by rapid left-hand triplet figurations. Pizzaro’s recordings of these works are slightly more sonorous than Urban’s, and his virtuosity and technical precision are absolutely top-notch.
But Urban’s second CD, devoted to Voříšek’s miscellaneous pieces, has much less competition. The least recorded of the composer’s works, they provide a compendium of what many a young aspiring composer might have written in Vienna, if the objective were to publish and to sell music. None of these pieces – from the Theme and Variations in B-flat major op. 19 to the salon-style pieces with fashionable French titles (‘Le Désir’ op. 3 and ‘Le Plasir’ op. 4) – is technically demanding. Urban’s account of these pieces is stylish and graceful, eminently suited to the idiom of the music, and the Romantic moments are sensitively rendered in the context of a prevailing post-Classical style. These pieces include the attractive Eclogue in C major and the Impromptu in F major, evidently the first pieces in a never-completed sequel to the first set of impromptus.Footnote 6
Urban’s final disc is devoted entirely to Voříšek’s 12 Rhapsodies op. 1. Far more virtuosic in their character, and broadly modelled upon Voříšek’s teacher’s works of the same name, the Rhapsodies constitute roughly one-third of Voříšek’s total piano music in performance time, clocking in at just under an hour.Footnote 7 Here, as with the Sonata and the Impromptus, Urban faces stiff competition from Pizarro, whose superior technical capabilities lends a brilliance and élan to the performances not fully matched by the new set. Viewed as a whole, however, anyone wishing to have performances of the complete piano music of Voříšek will be well served by these new recordings, which are solid in their technical and interpretive execution and benefit from good sound quality. The booklet notes by Alan Swanson, extensive and well considered, are also a distinct asset. That said, the earlier two-CD set on the Collins label by Arthur Pizarro remains unmatched.
