In the closing paragraphs of the book, the authors say Understanding Social Welfare Movements has shown the continuing relevance of social movements to struggles over welfare historically, theoretically and empirically. To be sure, they do an impressive job of showing how the post-World War II ‘golden age’ of the welfare state, which provided the terrain for the emergence of ‘new social (welfare) movements’, was the outcome of hard-fought-for historical struggles over civil rights and social justice. It is important, I think, we remember that, when in an era of international terrorism and global neoliberalism, we often witness the flouting of many liberal democratic principles.
One gets a definite sense of the history from coverage on Chartism and the Great Unrest of 1910–14 (Chapter 1) as well as poor peoples’ movements against the Poor Laws and the food riots (Chapter 2); struggles, that is, for material improvements or what the authors term, somewhat quaintly, the ‘politics of the belly’ (p. 7). While there were ‘moments of madness’ (e.g. pp. 92–3), one also has a sense that the accomplishments of historical social movements were born of gradual reform and concession. Social movement successes were the result of class struggle and, intriguingly, a precursor to ‘third way’ politics. Hence, the reforms of Conservative and Labour governments during the inter-war years – from the Maternity and Child Welfare Act in 1918 to the Unemployment Act in 1934 – were ‘piecemeal reflections’ (p. 31) of what Harold Macmillan characterised in 1938 as a ‘paternal socialism’ of the ‘middle way’ (p. 105).
Part Two of the book is organised around what the Beveridge Report 1942 considered the ‘five evils’ of disease, want, squalor, ignorance and idleness. Thus, the chapters in this part include: ‘movements of the unemployed’, ‘the women's health movement’, ‘urban social movements’ and ‘social movements and the making of modern education’. The focus is on Britain and there are omissions, as the authors concede. Specifically, they do not consider, in any depth, movements around mental health or disability (pp. 12–13).
Part Three of the book considers contemporary social movements and social welfare. Accordingly, it broadens out the idea of social welfare to consider ‘new welfare movements’, which ‘operate in and around an already established welfare state system to preserve, extend, deepen and improve service delivery’ (p. 10). The authors look at lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered (LGBT) activism, anti-racist movements, eco-welfare movements and, finally, global social justice movements. Three of these chapters offer up-to-date accounts of developments in Britain, including LGBT activists’ fight to secure civil partnership legislation, an examination of the 2001 North of England race riots, and anti-road protests and the greening of social welfare policy. However, the final substantive chapter of the book deals with bigger (global) issues.
Arguably, the global justice movement (which is, in actuality, what Naomi Klein calls, ‘a movement of many movements’, p. 235) is the new social welfare movement par excellence. In the Introduction, the authors say, ‘when neoliberal antipathy to state welfare has been central to government social policy making, these movements have mobilised to defend the very principle of social welfare itself’ (pp. 10–11). Given the target of global justice protestors ‘has been the key institutions that form the backbone of the neoliberal political project’ (p. 233), it is important, and I agree, the correct target be identified not as globalisation, ‘but neoliberal globalisation as a particular phase in the development of global capitalism, which, among other dimensions, offers a celebration of the untrammelled market, which prioritises the profit-making activities and objectives of corporations and business, promotes free trade and argues for minimum state intervention in economic activity’ (pp. 232–3).
This begs the perennial question as to novelty. While the authors invoke theory throughout the book, one rarely has the feeling that social movement theory is integral to the analysis. Various social movement theories are addressed in Chapter 3 and indeed theory is applied at various junctures as and when the authors see fit. Concepts such as ‘master frame’, ‘submerged networks’, ‘repertoire of contention’ and ‘political opportunity structure’ are used. However, there is little theorisation of social welfare movements. The closest the book comes to that is by reference to the debate over ‘old’ and ‘new’ movements.
The authors set this up in the Introduction stating: ‘It is a key aim of this book to redress both the simplistic division of old and new social movements through the prism of social welfare and the absence of social movements in much social policy’ (p. 7). And, in the final paragraph of the book, they again say the case studies they have presented aid our understanding of the ‘dialectics of mobilisation’ (p. 257). However, while post-material interests (i.e. ideas, values and recognition) ‘are important grounds for mobilising around the claims of entitlement that citizenship embodies . . . Social welfare movements are always related to concrete struggles over immediate demands for resources in one form or another’ (p. 257). Though this hardly adds to previous thinking about the intersections between social movements, welfare and social policy, surely newness lies beyond the issues and the nature of contemporary struggles? Surely it is to be found in the context of neoliberalism, which, as the authors rightly claim, constitutes a fundamental attack on the notion of social welfare?
