The study published in this book was submitted as part of the requirements for the degree of Master (doctorandus) of Islamic Studies at the University of Leiden, the Netherlands. I note this because it is given as an explanation for the scope of the book by the author, who promises more volumes on other aspects of Bahai political theology (p. 7). The subject of this book is presented as “the first chapter of what would be a postmodern Bahai political theology on the theme of organic unity” (p. 8). The author affirms his belief not only in the continuity of the Bahai faith but also in a continual need for reformulation and translation into the terminology of a changing world (pp. 6–7). The author says that he is writing “primarily for the Bahais. However, a Bahai theology can hardly be exclusive, because Bahai scriptural resources include the Bible and the Qurءan” (pp. 8–9). He continues to say that “any political theology is in one sense at least universal, since it begins with the world. People of all faiths and none [sic] live within one world: pluralistic and fragmented, but paradoxically the same world” (p. 9). I was not able to find the author's explanation of how the universality of “any” political theology follows from its being about the world.
In the rest of his introduction, the author presents his personal views and various aspects of his thesis about postmodernism, globalization, individualization, pluralism, and relativism, as well as justification for prioritizing the issue of church and state and how Bahaullah has resolved this ancient and topical question (pp. 28–31).
After a descriptive overview of religion and politics in Islamic history, the author presents his own thesis in terms of a trilogy of Islamic, Christian, and Jewish political theologies. The bulk of the book, however, is devoted to a review of Bahai writings on church and state in primary and secondary sources, including quoted translations of large Bahai texts.
Although one can appreciate the importance of grounding the mediation of the relationship between religion and the state in theological terms for believers, this book does not provide a good or helpful model of how that can be done. One major problem is that this is more of an excessively long master's dissertation than an integrated book. Another major problem is that the claim of universality of the subject is not matched by an effort to include non-Bahai readers in the conversation. Even for Bahai, I suspect, views are presented in “take it or leave it” terms, with little attempt to be persuasive or analytical. At best, this book can provide a range of resources on Bahai beliefs and doctrine but is not a scholarly discussion accessible to a wider readership.
