On April 9, 1915, the fiftieth anniversary of General Lee's surrender at Appomattox, The Birth of a Nation opened in Boston.Footnote 1 Audience members were “prepared for the unusual” the moment they entered the Tremont Theatre. After “a young man in evening dress and a silk hat” took tickets, “two young women in flounced hoop skirts and with long curls … ma[d]e a sort of graceful minuet bow, and hand[ed] you a program.”Footnote 2 While “soldiers ‘on guard’ in the Civil War uniforms of the North and South” flanked the aisles, another costumed young woman “escort[ed] you to your seat.”Footnote 3 As the film projector flickered to life, a title card issued an important caveat to the audience: “This is an historical presentation of the Civil War and Reconstruction period and is not meant to reflect in any way upon any race or people of today.” D. W. Griffith did not write this title card; rather, the National Board of Censorship of Motion Pictures (NBC) inserted it to fend off protestors and signal its commitment to filmmakers’ First Amendment rights.
The NBC was a New York City-based organization that emerged out of a Progressive campaign to protect motion pictures from government intervention. Founded in 1909 as a committee of the People's Institute, the NBC “act[ed] in an advisory capacity toward directors” who did not have an “appreciation of the medium they are working in,” while “trying to be encouraging to those who [did].”Footnote 4 Early architects of the NBC program included social reformer John Collier, who maintained that movies were “drama, book, newspaper and oration; they are art. They are free speech.” As such, “it would be unfortunate if they were deprived of the essential liberty which has always been held to belong to the vehicles of public discussion.”Footnote 5
In response to the Supreme Court's February 1915 decision in Mutual v. Ohio, which denied motion pictures First Amendment protections, the NBC launched a nationwide campaign to obviate the need for government censorship. Before the creation of the Hays Office, the NBC conducted prerelease review of approximately 95 percent of motion pictures exhibited in the United States, using volunteer “model” audiences guided by a “Standards” document. The “Standards” prohibited controversial material, such as obscenity and animal cruelty, but also warned against “treatment of a race” that was “unduly libelous.” These topics were to be avoided because “the question of censorship” too often arose in response.Footnote 6 As NBR Advisory Secretary Orrin Cocks explained, “some films” were suitable “for the whole United States,” and others were “worthy to be circulated in some sections only.”Footnote 7 To that end, the NBC developed the “City Plan,” a model ordinance for motion picture regulation, which required a municipal official to check local exhibitors’ bookings against the NBC's Bulletin of approved films. In 1909, Boston became the first city to adopt the “City Plan,” putting the License Commissioner in charge. NBC Executive Secretary W. D. McGuire boasted, “In Boston, no picture which has not been passed by the National Board can be shown at all.”Footnote 8
For weeks prior to the Boston debut of The Birth of a Nation, the local branch of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) and the National Equal Rights League (NERL) had been lobbying License Commissioner John M. Casey to prevent its exhibition on the grounds that it was “a libel on the race.” William Monroe Trotter, editor of the Boston Guardian and president of the NERL, characterized it as “an incentive to great racial hatred.”Footnote 9 On April 5, 1915, Casey contacted W. D. McGuire for guidance: though The Birth of a Nation had been passed by the NBC, Casey was receiving “protests … from all classes of people,” including a number of city councilors and “some of the best lawyers (white).”Footnote 10 He confessed that the film had “stirred up the greatest opposition it has ever been my lot to encounter,” and warned that that State House was debating censorship.Footnote 11
McGuire responded, explaining that The Birth of a Nation had passed three Review Committee screenings in January 1915. Griffith had cooperated throughout the process, removing some “scenes where a colored fellow was chasing a woman and … frothing at the mouth”; cutting down the “big fight in the saloon”; and revising offensive title cards. McGuire did not share the text of those eliminated cards, which read: “Having profited by the trade and having no use for slaves themselves, the traders of the 17th century became the abolitionists of the 19th century,” and “Pious Puritans blessed the traffic.”Footnote 12 The NBC's management of the film was designed to prevent influential white audiences from clamoring for censorship, not to protect black audiences from “libelous” portrayals. McGuire conceded that “some scenes … may be considered distasteful to colored people,” but because it was “a historical presentation,” it was “hardly just to condemn it entirely.”Footnote 13 After all, the NBC's “Standards” clearly stated that the organization could not be held “responsible for the historical, geographical, or scientific accuracy of films.”Footnote 14 McGuire concluded by dismissing the NAACP as an “Association [that] believes in intermarriage of the races” as part of its “propaganda.”Footnote 15
Boston Mayor James Michael Curley could not afford to be as dismissive toward the NAACP, as Irish Democrats in Boston relied on black voters. On April 8, 1915, Curley held a public hearing after Trotter and “many colored citizens” warned that the film would “incite race hatred,” reflecting contemporary beliefs in the mimetic power of film.Footnote 16 Curley asked Griffith to further shorten the chase scene, and eliminate title cards he deemed “unfair to the colored citizenship.” He claimed this would ensure that “the fullest possible measure of justice” would be “accorded the colored citizenship of Boston.”Footnote 17
However, the print of The Birth of a Nation that screened on April 9 had not been edited according to Curley's specifications. The manager claimed he did not have enough time to complete such a big job; therefore, he exhibited the NBC-approved print on Saturday, and promised to make Mayor Curley's cuts on Sunday.Footnote 18 But the damage had been done; the offensive content had been exhibited.Footnote 19
For months before release, “the colored population of Boston had vainly protested against the play,” and on April 17, 1915, they “gave free vent to their feelings.”Footnote 20 Inside the Tremont, audience members threw rotten eggs and “exploded stinkpots,” while more “disturbances” occurred outside.Footnote 21 The box office manager, fearful that Trotter planned to “fill the house with negroes” who would “destroy the films and stop the play,” called the police.Footnote 22 The Boston Globe declared that, “as a racial demonstration, probably nothing like it has been seen in Boston since before the Civil War.”Footnote 23 Despite the protest, the film continued to run in Boston, with “crowds throng[ing] the matinee and night performances.”Footnote 24
Massachusetts's legislators, with the support of the NERL and NAACP, quickly created the Boston Board of Censors.Footnote 25 The new three-member board was empowered to “revoke or suspend” licenses for public entertainments.Footnote 26 Griffith inveighed against the legislation, claiming that “the negroes who are promoting the intermarriage of blacks and whites in this country” had influenced legislators, employing “underhanded and un-American methods” that “threatened the freedom of the stage and the press.”Footnote 27 Finally, he reminded his readers that The Birth of a Nation had earned “the sanction of the National Board of Censors.”Footnote 28
The controversy created a rift within the NBC; John Collier, Mary White Ovington, and other Progressive members sympathetic to the NAACP's efforts quit in protest. In early 1916, shortly after the Federal Motion Picture Commission concluded its hearings, the NBC changed its name to National Board of Review of Motion Pictures (NBR) to distinguish itself from the expanding pro-censorship movement. Soon thereafter, donations from Griffith's production companies allowed the NBR to create a “Speakers Bureau,” which dispatched lobbyists to fight against censorship legislation nationwide.Footnote 29 For example, when the blasphemous motion picture A Mormon Maid was released in 1917, Griffith enlisted the NBR to prevent its circulation in Utah, Wyoming, and Arizona. As one of Griffith's colleagues asked McGuire, “Don't you think it would be a good idea to have one of your crack representatives there on the ground to head off any censorship agitation?”Footnote 30 After a visit from an NBR speaker, Salt Lake City adopted the City Plan instead of censorship legislation.
Protests against The Birth of a Nation yielded an ambivalent legacy, with civil liberties emerging as a priority over civil rights. The NBR continued to fight for motion pictures’ First Amendment protections. For instance, in 1917, New York City's Friends of Irish Freedom sought an injunction against Whom the Gods Destroy, a film they decried as a “historic lie.” “Much like Birth of a Nation, which offended the negroes,” the NBR could not “take adverse action” on this film just because “it might prove offensive to loyal Irishmen.” McGuire confided to Casey that, despite his “sympathies with the Irish movement,” he would not “condemn the picture which under the principles of American freedom of expression should be allowed to circulate.”Footnote 31 McGuire also supported black filmmaker Oscar Micheaux's right to freedom of expression, yet never intervened on his behalf when Southern cities barred his films. Those cities employed the NBR's City Plan, which emerged as an important mechanism for elite white Southerners to establish local, white supremacist systems of motion picture regulation. By 1918, over eighty U.S. cities, including Memphis, Dallas, Atlanta, and the entire state of Florida, had adopted the City Plan instead of statutory censorship. This localized censorship would persist into the 1960s.Footnote 32
