French enthusiasm for the Republic and its champions notwithstanding, Rome could not simply have ceased to function as a site of historical, political and aesthetic reference in the Romantic period. That it may have seemed so is due to Richard Jenkyns, Frank Turner and their successors, and their powerful narrative of the dominance of Hellenism in the nineteenth century. Consequently Jonathan Sachs's contribution to OUP's Classical Presences series issues a salutary challenge to look again at the complexity of Romantic reception.
The book has four main themes, the most important being its case for an ‘internally differentiated classicism’: a classicism in which Rome (Republican Rome in particular) plays a vigorous supporting rôle in the British literary imagination from the French Revolution to the First Reform Bill. The argument is not, however, for continuity with eighteenth-century neoclassicism, but a distinctive Romantic classicism founded in a new preoccupation with history and a turn from exemplarity to historicism. S.'s second proposition is that Rome is reconceptualized in line with this emergent historicism, and his third that Romantic versions of Rome themselves allow us to observe the reconceptualization of history itself. Both claims support his fourth theme; that to contribute to the struggle over the Roman Republican past is to enter the political arena and engage in the period's ‘culture wars’, ‘contesting political modernity’.
William Godwin, radical, philosopher and novelist, is the presiding genius of the first section. Ch. 1 contrasts the unexpectedly old-fashioned exemplarity of his Republican heroes, deployed as ‘transhistorical models of virtue’, with the tension in Edmund Burke's manipulation of the Roman legacy in the Reflections (where the relevance of, e.g., Burke's Ciceronian self-projection is undermined by his historicist emphasis on the unique development of the British constitution). In the second chapter Godwin's unpublished defence of the novel as an alternative form of history and an ‘agent of social change’ is the foundation for treatments of novels by Hays, Inchbald and Holcroft. Responding, S. suggests, to contemporary criticism of the corrupting influence of their genre, these authors represent it as a pedagogical alternative to classics which uses a ‘Plutarchan [character-based] mode’ of exemplarity to inculcate the civic virtue and public-mindedness of Republican models without their concomitant bellicosity and imperialism.
The second section — on poetry — opens with a chapter which stands slightly outside the main trajectory of the book, in that Byron's concern with Rome (explored here in his defence of Pope and in Childe Harold, Canto IV) relates to the Empire rather than the Republic and focuses principally on contemporary literary politics, Romantic poetics, canon formation and literary survival. Indeed, S.'s claim that Byron measures literature against a timeless classical standard is arguably (interestingly?) in tension with the larger case for Romantic historicism. But with Shelley, in the following chapter, S. is able to trace, across a number of tracts and poems, an evolving response to Rome generated by the interplay between Shelley's politics and contemporary events, as the poet came to see Rome as ‘more apposite to the case of England’. This chapter makes the greatest contribution to the case for a new politicized historicism.
The third section — the most compelling — opens with a lucid account of the contrasting political investments of the Romes represented in competing productions of Coriolanus (starring Kemble and Kean) in the period from 1789–1820 before examining their distorted reflection in the peculiar tensions of the otherwise radical Hazlitt's admiration for Kemble's ‘conservative’ interpretation. The second chapter documents a ‘Roman revival’ — a resurgence of plays on Roman themes — from 1817–30, detecting in John Howard Payne's Brutus (1818), James Sheridan Knowles' Caius Gracchus (1823) and George Croly's unstaged Catiline, a shared determination to play down the insurrectionary aspects of plots that could certainly have leant themselves to radical readings and a common reluctance to concede ‘the people’ a valid rôle in politics or in effecting political change.
The central thesis of Rome's continuing relevance as a cultural resource is entirely convincing, as is the claim that in invoking Republican Rome authors' political aspirations and agendas were expressed and pursued. But there is room for agnosticism about how neatly this dovetails with a new historicism. Byron, I have already suggested, has a distinctly anti-historicist strain, and the plays S. discusses arguably deploy an exemplarity that would not have been out of place in the eighteenth century. With the exception of the chapters on the novelists and Shelley, the historicism of these Romantic Romes (as distinct from the extent to which they are shaped by contemporary preoccupations) is not always apparent, and the reader may, in retrospect, become less confident that neoclassical Romes were consistently less historically and politically engaged. Indeed, as S.'s first chapter itself suggests, any transition is perhaps likely to have been confused and confusing.
But this is more than offset by the real value of several of S.'s subsidiary themes. It becomes clear, for instance, that the defeat of Napoleon profoundly affects the terms of the debate expressed in competing appropriations of Republican history. There are intriguing glimpses of the extent to which literature in English is already achieving ‘classic’ status and challenging the cultural authority of ancient texts. The chapter on the novel and the section on drama point to levels of reception (mediated/unmediated; public/private) and the puzzle of the popularity of ‘conservative’ receptions in seemingly ‘democratic’ spaces. So, though written mainly in response to, and perhaps principally for scholars of Romantic literature, the book makes an impressive contribution to Reception Studies and will be helpful even for historians of the ‘Revolution Controversy’.
