White power music presents a complex subject within critical scholarship for its many avenues of inquiry. Adding to a decade of research describing the contemporary white power music scene, Nancy Love contributes an engaging theoretical expanse to consider music's role in building a transnational white community. Love seeks to unpack the cultural politics of both white supremacy and hegemonic liberalism to explore the visceral expressive power of music that defines (and defends) hatred for non-Aryan peoples.Footnote 1 That Love notes an increasing reference to hate music within media reports of racially motivated violence suggests a prophetic timeliness to this field of research.Footnote 2
Love quickly discloses her relationship to her subject matter by listing the interdisciplinary threads of analysis she brings to the research. To be sure, her work fits into the category of critical theory, although readers should bring substantive knowledge of cultural studies, critical race theory, democratic theory, feminist theory, musical aesthetics, and popular music studies in order to grasp fully the nuanced integration of these analytical lenses. Undergirding the author's intellectual prowess is her own aesthetic engagement with music as an amateur musician. Finally, she duly acknowledges the inflammatory nature of both facts and ideas under examination, ever mindful of their potential to trigger painful flashbacks for readers who have been traumatized by hate crimes. This musical territory will never be neutral ground, nor should we seek to shield ourselves behind any discourse of musical objectivity resistant to the notion that music can (and has been) re-contextualized into a weapon.
In five short chapters, Love moves from context to analysis by way of case studies examining white power musicians and their cohort of supporters. Chapter 1, “Mobilizing White Power: Music Culture, and Politics,” casts an intersectional dialogue with contemporary theorists in the abovementioned fields, setting the framework for the rest of the book. Her theoretical foundation necessarily engages multiple disciplines in order to address the particularly virulent mindset of fascism that has intensified in the United States and elsewhere since September 11, 2001. Love, however, asserts that the brutal intensity of fascist agendas in white power music today is largely unsurprising if one considers the cumulative effect of ongoing inequities and social fragmentation within democratic capitalism. A review of the tenets of fascism (summarized in the first and second chapters), as they have informed current musical expressions of hatred, confirms music's galvanizing force among white supremacist groups as credibly normative. This force, she notes, has long been part of coalition building within liberal social reform movements; thus, its role in building coalitions among advocates of white supremacy also deserves critical examination.
In dialogue with an impressively diverse array of theorists, notably Jurgen Habermas and his contemporaries (Iris Young, Sheldon Wolin, Gregg Miller), Love nevertheless selects judiciously where each school of thoughts can serve her—and where they fall short. Democratic theorists, for example, overlook the linguistic and affective facets of music's role in shaping community. Susan Sontag's controversial theories on fascist aesthetics serve Love only minimally, toward nuancing distinctions between the nationalistic Nazi political aesthetic, current far Right and Left political platforms, and the strains of an emerging fascism that sounds—literally—an organized resistance against a globalized neoliberal worldview. Adorno, of course, figures prominently into Love's analysis of cultural commodification and mass cultural production of music. To this familiar territory of discourse she inserts more contemporary intersectional theorists, notably Pia Lara and Tricia Rose. In eschewing a singular methodology, Love seems to underscore her depiction of white power music as inhabiting multiple sites.
Each of the ensuing three chapters illustrates, in Love's words “a different facet of white supremacy, a different genre of white power music, and a different aspect of the white power music scene” (125). Her tripartite plan of presentation begins with a discussion of theoretical, sociological, and historical underpinnings of the specific facet of white supremacy, followed by a description of a particular musical genre and its leading musicians. She ostensibly proceeds in this manner in order to connect practice to theory, effecting richly thick readings of music scenes within the white power movement. To close each of these chapters, Love presents positive “alternative scenarios” of response in play within society, assuring readers that hatred has not yet consumed the entirety of human civilization. She returns to these alternate scenarios in Chapter 5, encouraging an embrace of their transformative power as positive exemplars that not only thrive but also heal societal fissures sown by hatred.
Chapter 2, “Playing with Hate: Racist Skinheads, Skrewdriver, and Liberal Tolerance,” reviews contemporary white power music as a recruitment tool for white working poor in Britain. Love's focus is the punk subculture and musician Ian Stuart, founder of the well-known Skrewdriver and White Diamond punk bands. The rhetoric of white victimization by liberal governments permeates lyrics that invert white poverty into martyrdom, re-energizing sentiments of nationalism that valorize masculine heroism. Punk rock's guttural timbres, repetitive formal structures, and physically cathartic actions can mobilize collective anger when carefully facilitated through the production of recordings and concert events. This skinhead punk music reflects the backfire of imperialism—as meted out by both Britain and the United States—in its transfer of totalitarianism into the hands of disenfranchised.
Love creates a cohesive sense to the chapters by grounding each one's discrete focus points (genre, aspect of white power, music scene) in a recurring theme of failure within democratic liberalism. Specifically, in failing to address the “unacknowledged aspect of their political history and national” (62), liberal democracies have perpetuated or re-inscribed systems of privilege without offering fair (or feasible) ways of mitigating the economic shifts within the labor force caused by changing demographics, technologies, or resources. The notion of “imagined communities” creates an appealing utopian vision of a whites-only society, not unlike the vision of white settlers who believed it their birthright to move westward and “settle” the wild territories of North America.
Chapter 3, “Imagining a White Nation: Neo-Nazi Folk, Family Values, and Prussian Blue,” casts the unexamined liberal democratic idea—the “nuclear family”—as a grotesquely caricatured ideology within the white power movement. Love rightly references gendered and racialized tropes within commercially popular music of the United States, toward suggesting their generative material for white power music's objectification of women and people of color. As intensified through a white supremacist lens, the subjugation of female bodies reaches a gruesome pitch of sexual politics in the music of Prussian Blue. The group originated as a duo of twin teenagers, Lamb and Lynx Gaede, who were groomed to perform at neo-Nazi festivals. With added instruments, they recorded songs celebrating whiteness and the traditional white family as the ideological blueprint for the master race as rulers of the world. Love, while noting that the Gaede sisters have since distanced themselves from the white power movement, nevertheless draws out aspects of their biography to expose the idolatry of the nuclear family as wholly constructed to privilege Anglophile social hierarchy.
Chapter 4, “Building a Church: Rahowa, Heavy Metal, and Racial Ecology” describes a chilling collusion of spirituality with music within the white power movement. Love traces the development of the World Church of the Creator (a.k.a. Creativity) as a secular religion devoted entirely to the worship of whiteness. Like any deity-based religion, Creativity promotes the tenets of white supremacy as a legitimate theology, taught and ritualized through music. The musical liturgy for Creativity is the heavy metal/Goth/electronica music of Rahowa–an acronym for Racial Holy War. Religious justification of war and violence to preserve the white race ably partners with the music of Rahowa, which valorizes explicitly violent words and actions as spiritually righteous. Noting centuries of holy wars across the globe as similarly marked by music, Love again encourages reflection upon the means by which a dominant culture has excluded, subjugated, and punished non-conformists.
Love's grasp of the relationship between white power music and the broader social fabric likely compelled her toward writing this book and toward exhorting others to follow the threads of her reasoning in search of viable resolutions. Her ideas for moving forward in resolution can be found in her descriptions of individuals who got out of the white power scene and also in the closing “alternative scenarios” that conclude each of the three middle chapters. These she develops further in her closing chapter.
Chapter 5, “Recycling White Trash: Aesthetics, Music, and Democracy,” returns to the closing scenarios presented at the ends of the previous three chapters to suggest a way out of white power. Love mentions a recovery organization, Life After Hate, as tending to the rehabilitation of people who once belonged to white power groups. The counteractive power of “positive exemplars” (127) have always existed, but Love specifically pairs them with the chapter themes—the empathy of W. E. B. Du Bois for southern whites, the Obama family dynamics, and the Indigenous wisdom of Steven Newcomb. The accounts of former white supremacists describe profound experiences of reversal which further underscore Love's desire to transform western liberal democracies beyond their current oppositional politics. One wonders whether a specific kind of music or music scene would be most effective.
Love's epilogue poses thoughtful points for reflecting upon the cultivation of hatred through music. Resisting a simplistic binary applied to either moral or political judgement of the white power movement, she also urges a more careful evaluation of musical aesthetics beyond its common binaries of high and low, good and bad, toward a more reasoned query into the agency of creators/producers and listeners alike. Her careful and thorough research encourages us to re-evaluate our environments of access and privilege, discerning the complicit construction and maintenance of cultural hegemony that would either exploit or disregard the totality of human experience. If music can empower those seeking community, then it also expresses that community's most valuable (even sacred) articles of connectivity. That so many have raised their voices in songs of hatred should give us pause to consider what, in their collective experience, has injured them so to be moved to violence in this way.
