Histories of the environment usually conceptualize ‘the environment’ as a new object of concern, needing new forms of knowledge to be made about it. These tend to locate its origin in the mid-twentieth century – with growing concerns about the human relationship with its surroundings from landscape destruction, the risk from synthetic chemicals or total planet irradiation. This book, however, adopts a different stance. Surroundings seeks to historicize the idea of environment beyond this, revealing the multiplicity of environments that figure in the history of environmental thought. Through descriptive vignettes, Surroundings illuminates a diversity in human thought and understanding that is concerned with ideas of the/an environment(s), in a myriad of distinct yet interrelated ways, over the past two centuries. Moreover, the reader is directed towards how, as a concept, the idea of environment has never erected hard, rigid definitional boundaries but instead has emerged in particular cultural-political contexts and been used for specific epistemic and normative aims – that, throughout its existence, has been generative and transformative in how we understand the world, living organisms and their surroundings.
The book begins in the early 1800s in the French port of Lorient, where the boat Géographe is docked and ready to reveal the treasures of its voyage – sketches, plants, animals and other artefacts – in new collections for the Muséum d'histoire naturelle, Paris. This was a time when the museum space was an important site of knowledge making, used by naturalists to aid an understanding of the natural order through varying forms of organization and classification of, and experimentation with, the collections. From this, many ideas were being cultivated that centred around an interrogation of the relationships between organisms and their surroundings to best understand how and why things differed in the natural order. We then move to another use of ‘environment’ – one that is used to reify racial and imperial hierarchical structures in the expansion and activity of empire building. Through this, we explore the role surroundings played in the (dis)ordering of the natural world. The ‘environment’ then takes a social turn – as we move to Chicago and the settlement movement – and we learn how the concept of a ‘social environment’ extended previous ideas of organisms and surroundings, by viewing populations like an organism. This way of understanding society led to a range of investigations through survey techniques, in the nascent field of sociology, to determine the material effects of a social environment on social order. Then, as sociology became institutionalized in university departments, the city, as a social environment, itself became a site of study.
The city was now understood not as a separate externalized domain but as an extension of residents. What mattered were ideas and perceptions of the social forces and actors surrounding them – contingent on the context – shifting from material matters like sanitation and domestic concerns to interests in the exchanges of knowledge and ideas in modern societies as a mutually constitutive part of residents and their surrounding environments. We are then taken through the world wars and how the management of resources and the use of scientific experts in this led to broader transformations in understanding the world as a set of systems. The natural world was no longer either organisms or their surroundings, instead, they were a set of functionally integrated and organized relational systems, which, Benson notes, enabled the technocentric and managerial approaches to solving environmental crises common today.
The last two cases are the usual ground. Surroundings explores the evolution of risk and consumer culture in the US that enabled writers like Rachel Carson to foreground the new invisible risk to human health from the products of post-war acceleration. From this, the rhetoric of ‘the environment’ – a singular unifying environment – surfaced to galvanize the minds of many and stimulate the environmental movement, joined together by the shared threat to all humans from damaging to their total surroundings in unknown, unhealthy and dangerous ways. The uneven geographies of environmental risk soon came to the fore – as the idea of humans sharing an equal threat soon dissolved but that of ‘the environment’ now stuck and was embedded in institutional and political structures and became useful in capturing and mobilizing support and circulating environmental knowledge. Lastly, the emergence of climate change in environmental discourse came about through, again, a shared danger to the human species – that would emerge from possible global warming. However, through ineffective political and institutional spaces, international climate governance was becoming increasingly recognized as something that may not work efficiently under a global heading due to too diverse aims and commitments needed for agreement between diverse parties with uneven stakes. The environment in this sense was not fit for purpose as it was too broad to make meaningful association with, and too general to include the local specificities and nuance of, the tangible effects of climate degradation.
Throughout, Surroundings illustrates the multiplicity of ‘environments’ and how each particular collective of environmental thought or ‘environmentalism’ is situated cultural, political and social contexts that need to be understood in order to truly understand the diversity of the particular epistemic and normative aims that each use of ‘environment’ possesses. What we can take away is that ‘environment’ is a fluid term and can be reconceptualized for more fruitful purposes that are not centred around the dichotomy between natural and social worlds. If so, then what may be the future of ‘the environment’? Benson poses some intriguing concluding ideas – critical zones, indigenous communities and space/place, environmental humanities and arts – whilst also touching upon the wider applicability of the environment in this new era we may or may not be in, ‘the Anthropocene’. The feasibility of these solutions is up to the readers to decide, but what becomes clear through Surroundings is that the history of the environment needs to be one that explores the histories and constitutions, diversities and exclusions, space and interrelations, and responsibilities and affects, of the multiplicity of the idea and use of the/an ‘environment’. Surroundings begins this and is a must-read for anyone working or studying in science studies and with a keen interest in environmental ideas or knowledge.
