Until the last quarter of the eighteenth century the ocean was in the West considered an abyss which contained the debris from the Flood, a remnant of God's punishment of the sins of humans. The ocean and beaches symbolized all that was considered undesirable and disorderly in the world. That perception changed in the nineteenth century, when oceanography was concocted out of diverse assemblages of knowledges, instruments and persons. The Machine in Neptune's Garden: Historical Perspectives on Technology and the Marine Environment is a collection of ten essays which show in technical terms how scientific research on the ocean has developed and advanced its theories and methods since that time. The essays explore a range of topics, from the late nineteenth-century development of gauging science in Britain, through the use of radioactivity as an oceanographic tool in the US, to the origin of ocean drilling, the development of fisheries acoustics in Norway and the fate of dreams of ocean dwellings for oceanography in the 1960s. Although the volume centres on technology and highlights its importance for oceanography, the authors do not view technology merely at a descriptive level or treat it as a ‘black box’, without history, inner workings or internal structure. Rather, oceanographic technology and technological development are revealed here as culture in the sense that such field devices are situated in a nexus of assumptions, habits, practices and modes of representation extending beyond instrument-centred definitions of technology.
In her fascinating book Fathoming the Ocean, Helen M. Rozwadowski, co-editor of The Machine in Neptune's Garden, further explores the formation and development of scientific deep-sea exploration in the nineteenth century. In six chapters and an epilogue, she introduces the experiential, cultural, social and global dimensions to the changes that made deep-sea science into a frontier scientific practice. In Chapter 1 she discusses the popular imagination of sea voyages in the nineteenth century and its connection with maritime literature. These travels and narratives, she shows, contributed to the new conceptualization of the ocean. Chapter 2 shifts the inquiry to the motivations of both scientists and national governments in seeking achievements in the field of deep-sea exploration. The next two chapters examine the evolution of sounding and dredging methodology, with attention to the preoccupations of its developers, including the fundamental questions of how deep the ocean actually is and if any life exists in its dark and pressured fathoms. Finally, in Chapters 5 and 6 Rozwadowski discusses national interests in the commissioning of expeditions, as well as aspects of life at sea, including social hierarchy and spatial and gastronomic constraints.
The field of deep-sea exploration comes thus to be seen as the culmination of questions, practices and ocean investigations of many different sectors and kinds. Ocean exploration by seafaring nations such as the United States and Britain helped to define the ocean as an unclaimed territory. Thanks to observations, dredging, mapping and naming by both amateurs and prospective scientists, that territory was transformed into a frontier that was ripe for scientific exploitation. Rozwadowski develops the important point that relatively unknown expeditions made important contributions to the establishment of oceanography as a field. Her case studies include the North Pacific Exploring Expedition in 1853, which solicited no official narratives, and the 1872–6 Challenger Expedition, which amassed a record-breaking collection and published its findings in over fifty volumes. It is easily forgotten that lasting impressions of scientific work are not just channelled through public accounts, but are also adumbrated in the personal communications of scientists, as well as in their engagement and practices with people in other fields. For instance, Rozwadowski writes about the fascinating change deep-sea scientists made within the political culture of ships. Not only were scientists often ‘considered as unlucky a shipmate as a cat or a corpse’ (p. 191), but, once onboard, they entered a highly stratified culture with a rigid pecking order and practical knowledge systems of experienced seamen that often ridiculed the ‘strange’ behaviour and requests of scientists.
Rozwadowski shows that behind the transformation she tracks in perceptions of the ocean lies a complex fusion of the working knowledge of seamen and whalers, the popular writings of ocean explorers, the leisure activities of the upper classes in Europe, commercial interests in laying telegraph cable, and national ambitions in exploring the last frontier on the globe. Her book amounts to a persuasive case for the claim she makes, here and in her article in The Machine in Neptune's Garden (on schemes for ocean dwelling in the 1960s), that historical research about the ocean and about ocean researchers is of vital importance for those seeking to comprehend the current environmental crisis, as historical understanding provides us with a necessary reflexive perspective and understanding of theories, methods, technology and the ocean environment. Both volumes are therefore significant steps in raising awareness of the importance of historicizing environmental research, including ocean research, and deserve a wide readership.
