Making Do in Damascus is a new contribution to scholarship on gender in the Middle East and to the sparse literature on contemporary Syrian society. Written in an engaging style, the book introduces the reader to dozens of mainly Sunni Muslim Damascene women who negotiate personal choices involving marriage, education, and employment amidst social, economic, and political constraints. This portrayal is based on ethnographic research conducted over two decades for which the author effortlessly moved throughout Damascus, from posh neighborhoods to working-class quarters, and visited Palestinian refugee camps in the suburbs. The author explains how women of different socioeconomic backgrounds navigate the expectations of family and society when negotiating personal matters and how they resort to cultural and religious frames of reference as well as draw on the economic and social resources at their disposal to make their choices. Extrapolating from the life choices of this diverse group of women, Gallagher comments broadly on socioeconomic inequalities and opportunities in Damascus and their impact on the construction of gender.
The purpose of Gallagher's research was to challenge prevailing trends in the scholarship of gender “that have come to emphasize the interpersonal construction of gender over larger social and economic forces that shape its range and expression” (p. xiv). According to the author, Syria, with its combination of authoritarianism, a struggling economy, and conservative social traditions, was an ideal site to examine women's agency under macrosocial constraints (p. 6). Between 1992 and 2011, Gallagher made ten visits to Syria for a period of one to four months each, which allowed her to observe economic and political transformations in the country over time (p. 16). In Chapter 2, Gallagher summarizes the social, economic, and political conditions in Syria going back to antiquity, though she focuses on shifts that occurred during the al-Asad era beginning in 1970 and especially during the power transfer from Hafiz al-Asad to his son Bashar in 2000. Although the push to integrate Syria into the global economy in the early 1990s led to some economic and political openness, Gallagher notes that this did not translate into any significant change in the status and role of women, especially since economic liberalization and short-lived political reforms did not yield sustainable economic or social gains for the majority of Syrians prior to the civil war in 2011 (pp. 292–97).
Gallagher situates her work within the scholarship on gender, family, religion, and labor, which is reflected in her robust bibliography, but she never makes her contribution to this literature clear. Many of the chapters on education, family, marriage, and employment lack in-depth analysis or comparisons with other parts of the Middle East. For example, in Chapter 6 on women's employment opportunities, there is no real engagement with the literature mentioned in the bibliography on women and labor in Egypt and Turkey. The reader is left to infer what a case study on the condition of women in Damascus contributes to the field at large. Moreover, there is a glaring omission of the rich scholarship on kinship, including marriage between first cousins as well as relations between mothers- and daughters-in-law and between siblings, which is the staple of ethnographic research in the Middle East and uppermost in the minds of several women interviewed in Making Do in Damascus. In addition, there is no mention of recent scholarship on masculinity and patriarchy under authoritarian regimes, even as the women introduced throughout the book grappled with domineering fathers, husbands, and brothers. Finally, although the author stresses the influence of religion on women's life choices (p. 56), the seminal work by Saba Mahmood on religion, gender, and agency is missing from the author's discussion.
Religion proves problematic in Making Do in Damascus partly because it comes across as monolithic and ahistorical, uninfluenced by local sociopolitical and economic contexts and unaltered from the early to last days of fieldwork. The conservative Sunni women who are the main subject of the author's research come to stand for society both past and present. Moreover, the author explicates neither the relationship between Sunnis and other Muslim sects in Damascus nor how Sunni women construct their religious identity to make a distinction between themselves and other Muslim and non-Muslim women. Furthermore, there is no indication of how these women's religiosity may have evolved over the course of two decades. As a result, Gallagher's depiction of religion does not deviate from common representations and misperceptions of Islam and women in the Arab world. For instance, in Chapter 5 on Syrian family law, she concludes with a discussion of temporary marriage that gives the impression that this practice is institutionalized in the legal framework of the state without making clear whether this is actually the case (pp. 161–62). In fact, the author does not even note that temporary marriage is highly controversial in both mainstream Sunni and Shiʿi Islam.
Although one of Gallagher's purposes in writing this book was to dispel stereotypes of Arab women (p. xiv), she unwittingly upholds many misconceptions that have become commonplace in Western countries. For example, she makes the choice to tell us a story in the preface about a border guard who questions whether Gallagher has the permission of her husband to travel, but she neither includes details of the encounter nor indicates what promoted the guard to ask the question in the first place (p. xiii). Gallagher then introduces us to women who are pressured into marriage, fear their husbands, and have domineering brothers. These are supplemented by stories of honor killing, forced veiling, rape, and incidents of domestic violence, some of which are anecdotal but have a prime focus in the text. Therefore, one of the shortcomings of Gallagher's book is that it reiterates many of the common perceptions of women in the Arab world rather than provide analysis and contextualization.
Although Gallagher has spent almost two decades documenting the lives of women, she seems to have accepted as common practice the cultural ideal related to her by these women rather than consider how both men and women constantly challenge ideal social norms in their daily lives. For instance, the support among the Sunni majority for arranged and semiarranged marriages as the “preferred ideal” (p. 112) does not take into account economic conditions and changing practices among the youth, especially with the spread of new technology. The impact of technology on social and political change is the topic of Chapter 7, but Gallagher restricts her discussion to the fax machine, satellite television, and the internet, neglecting the more fundamental social transformations made possible by cell phones. Data from government sources that the author compiled in a table on the use of technology shows that cell phone users far outnumbered fax or internet users, with the former numbering more than 11 million in 2011 (almost half of the population) and increasing fourfold since 2004 (p. 251). Mobile devices were ubiquitous in Damascus in the 2000s and became increasingly more accessible to individuals of different classes, means, and/or education than faxes, satellites, or the internet. Their social and economic impact on individuals and families were visible to visitors to Damascus during the first decade of the 2000s.
In sum, Making Do in Damascus will be a familiar read to students working on Syria or gender and family in the Middle East. Yet with its lucid writing style, it could be useful for undergraduate courses on comparative gender practices around the world.
