Amanda Röntgen-Maier (née Carolina Amanda Erika Maier, 1853–1894) is among the many women composers whose lives and works are garnering increasing interest from both researchers and performers. Born in Landskrona, Sweden, she was the first woman to graduate as a Director of Music from the Royal Academy in Stockholm. She was clearly exceptionally talented: this was considered the Academy's most difficult exam, and she passed with the highest possible marks in violin, piano, organ, composition, counterpoint, and music history and aesthetics.
Maier was a formidable multi-instrumentalist who could well have had a career playing the organ, but it was the violin that she chose as her principal instrument. Before her marriage in 1880, she had an illustrious career as a violinist and composer. She took on three tours between 1876 and 1880 with the soprano Louise Pyk, pianist Augusta Kiellander and bass-baritone Wilhelm Lundvik, including a performance for King Oscar II in Malmö in 1876. Maier was hailed in the press as one of Sweden's most exceptional musical talents, and the reviews of her concerts frequently mentioned the fact that she was the Academy's first female Director. Nya Dagligt Allehanda’s preview of Maier's 1873 graduation concert, for example, named her ‘one of the conservatory's most remarkable students’ (‘en bland konservatoriets utmärktaste elever’).Footnote 1 She frequently performed her own music, and not only did the press recognize her as a composer, but some of her works were published during her lifetime.
In 1880 she married Julius Röntgen, the son of her music teacher in Leipzig, and she stopped performing so frequently in public. Nonetheless she continued to compose with her husband, and to perform in their private salons, which had a guest list including Edvard and Nina Grieg, Ethel Smyth, Johannes Brahms, Clara Schumann and Joseph Joachim. Maier continued to make music at a professional level in her own home until her untimely death from ill health in 1894, and she taught both her sons, who went on to become professional musicians.
Thanks to the combined efforts of Maier's family, researchers, and institutions including Swedish Musical Heritage, the Music and Theatre Library in Sweden, and dB Productions, Maier's music is increasingly available for both performance and research. Cataloguing all her known compositions is an ongoing process, the most recent result of which was the discovery of her Piano Trio in 2016 by her great-grandson, Reiner Thiadens. Previously thought to be lost, the score of the Trio is now available online via Swedish Musical Heritage in a critical edition by the cellist Klas Gagge,Footnote 2 and it was recorded in 2018 by dB Productions.Footnote 3
The dB Productions label has been crucial for bringing Maier's music to new listeners, producing the world premiere recordings of many of her works. Together, the three CDs under review here (all world premiere recordings of Maier's works, except for the Violin Sonata) give a comprehensive introduction to both Maier's compositions and her musical world. The extensive illustrated liner notes deserve a special mention, as they provide invaluable contextualization for her works.
Amanda and Julius (dB Productions 185) comprises sets of piano works by both Maier and her husband, Röntgen. The CD acts as a musical document of their relationship, which on its own is an extremely valuable enterprise. All of the correspondence between Maier and Röntgen indicates that they were deeply in love, and that they were integral to each other's musical lives. The first time they met was at the Röntgen family home, where they performed each other's works. Julius's diary reveals that as their friendship developed they worked together on compositions – they jointly revised her piano trio in 1874, for example.Footnote 4 After their marriage they jointly organized soirées at their home, where Maier continued to perform.Footnote 5 Given how closely integrated their music-making was, their relationship is vital for understanding Maier's life.
The CD provides a suite by Röntgen entitled Julklapp! (‘Christmas present!’), which he composed for Maier as her Christmas present in 1875. The suite is as light as one might expect from the title (with some heavy Chopin influences), and Bengt Forsberg performs it with a deftness of touch that renders the work as a charming insight into the couple's relationship. More exciting is the jointly composed Zweigespräche suite of 1883, which has five pieces composed by Maier (nos. 1, 3, 4, 9 and 10), and five by Röntgen. Perhaps one of the most remarkable things to note about this suite is how very similar their compositional styles were, even though they wrote these pieces independently. Forsberg does justice to the considerable emotive range that these pieces cover, with particular highlights being no. 3 ‘Allegro energico’ and no. 8 ‘Prestissimo’ – both of which have a touch of Chopin's études about them.
To bill the music on this CD as a joint enterprise between the couple is a little misleading, however. The majority of the pieces on the disk are by Röntgen, while the inclusions by Maier are student piano exercises, produced in 1869 during her tuition at the Stockholm Academy. They're labelled Preludes, and it's fascinating to hear the harmonic directions Maier was going in even at this early stage, but it's very clear that they're not fully worked pieces – each is only 12 bars long. Providing recordings of them is immensely valuable for those interested in understanding the kind of compositional teaching that she had, but they aren't substantial on their own. The liner notes acknowledge this: ‘They might not go down in music history, but it is very interesting to hear how Amanda is already experimenting with harmonies’. The notes continue to explain that the Preludes contain marks from her teacher designating them as either ‘good’ or ‘excellent’, but that ‘her teacher's opinion of what was only “good” and what was “excellent” doesn't always correspond with our opinion, which could be because Amanda did not quite follow the rules and harmonic ideas of the time’.Footnote 6 It's difficult to evaluate this assertion, however, as it's nowhere noted which of the exercises were labelled as ‘good’ and which ‘excellent’. If the primary intention in recording these exercises was to provide insight into Maier's teaching, it would have been very helpful to have this noted. Overall, this CD is interesting as a document of Maier and Röntgen's relationship – and that on its own is an extremely valuable enterprise – but it feels like it does Maier a disservice to place her student exercises on the same platform as Röntgen's opus-numbered works, like Necken's Polska op. 11.
Volumes 1 (dB Productions 174) and 2 (dB Productions 182) of Maier's complete works are another matter. These really demonstrate Maier's formidable compositional talent. Volume 1 opens with her Violin Concerto, which in its current form is known as a single movement: whether Maier retracted the second and third movements deliberately or whether they have simply been lost is currently unknown. The work did at one point have three movements, as Maier's diary entries refer to three movements, and she clearly performed the concerto in its entirety, with reviews mentioning three movements. The technical difficulty of many of the pieces on these disks bears testament to how accomplished a player Maier must have been, as she frequently performed her own works. The Violin Concerto is no exception, offering a virtuoso showcase for the soloist. Gregory Maytan delivers a convincing performance (particularly in the cadenza) and is superbly supported by the Helsinki Symphony Orchestra under the baton of Andreas Stoehr. Particularly in the second subject, the concerto bears the influence of both Felix Mendelssohn (whose Violin Concerto Maier regularly performed) and Beethoven (whose Violin Concerto Maier was studying while she composed her own).
The Swedish Tunes and Dances are the only pieces on these disks that were jointly composed with Röntgen. This is a fun collection that grew on me after several listenings, but these are very much performance pieces that benefit from being heard live. A lot of their appeal comes from their virtuosity and the interaction between violinist and pianist (here Gregory Maytan and Ann-Sofi Klingberg), so one doesn't get the most out of them on record. The fifth piece of the set – Andante, Allegro con fuoco, Andante – stands out as the most compositionally interesting number. As the longest of the set, it could easily be an independent violin fantasy.
Maier's Six Pieces for Violin and Piano started life as nine pieces before they were published by Breitkopf & Härtel in 1879, and all nine are provided here. I'm very glad that these were included, as they contain some of the most enjoyable writing of the set. The sixth piece – ‘Schneller – wenn es geht’ – is a demanding romp for both violinist and pianist (Cecilia Zilliachus and Bengt Forsberg), which is beautifully complemented by the more introspective no. 7, ‘Sehr ruhig’. The six pieces published by Breitkopf were well received in Maier's lifetime – even if praise was given begrudgingly by some (in this case, the Allgemeine Musikalische Zeitung):
We give also Miss – or Mrs? – Maier's pianist/violinistic talent a high mark, yes, we even say: it could very well have come from a man – the talent, that is. Thanks to the solidity of the compositions they make a good impression. Skillfully created and extremely beautifully invented they don't suffer from sentimentality either, a mistake that composing ladies easily make. We could say a great deal more about this in every sense talented lady, without worrying that it would go to her head.Footnote 7
This wasn't the first time that Maier's reception had been shaped by her gender: a Swedish review of her 1876 performance of Mendelssohn's Violin Concerto is representative of the tone of writing that criticized her playing for not being ‘masculine’ enough. The concerto is ‘a test of strength’, the reviewer wrote, ‘which Maier withstood with honour, even if her tone did not always have the full strength that one requires of a male artist’ (‘ett kraftprof, hvari m:ll Maier med heder bestod, om ock hennes ton icke alltid egde de fulla styrka, man fordrar af en manlig artist’).Footnote 8
A surprising delight is Sabina Bisholt's performance of the Four Songs (1878, to texts by Carl-David af Wirsén). Insofar as Maier is known as a composer, it is for her violin music, not her songs – but these unpublished pieces are a treasure. It's a shame that she only wrote four songs in total – or, at least, that only four are currently known. At times they sound similar to songs by Grieg and Sibelius. Erik Nilsson speculates that these songs might have been written with Maier's close friend Louise Pyk (the aforementioned soprano) in mind, which might account for their more operatic moments.Footnote 9
The highlight of both discs is the Violin Sonata in B minor (1873, pub. 1878). This is a much more sombre work altogether than the Violin Concerto, and it shows Maier at her compositional best. It's harmonically inventive and melodically creative, and it is overall more comparable to Brahms's and Robert Schumann's offerings in the genre than to Beethoven's or Mendelssohn's. This sonata is the subject of Maier's most-quoted letter. When her work was reviewed for publication by the Musikaliska Konstföreningen (The Swedish Art Music Society), Franz Hiller suggested some changes to the slow movement. Maier responded to Albert Rubenson (the second reviewer – the third was Niels Gade), writing,
Of course I will not let the opinion of Dr. Hiller go unnoticed – but also that it would not be easy for me to change. … I have … often played the sonata and even found that the movement Mr. Hiller mentioned has made an impression on the audience … . My wish would be that it remains in its old condition. I don't want it in any way to seem obnoxious of me, it is certainly sincere that I don't know how I would change it.Footnote 10
This letter demonstrates both how self-assured Maier was as a composer, and how diplomatic she could be in her correspondence. Maier got her way, and the piece was published without alteration. Thank goodness it was, because the final version is superb and is played here with nuance and sensitivity by Zilliacus and Forsberg.
Collectively, these CDs are invaluable in bringing Maier's music to broader attention. They provide superb interpretations from both established and emerging talents, accompanied by well-researched, informative and illustrated liner notes.
