Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T14:28:11.566Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Can weakly nonlinear theory explain Faraday wave patterns near onset?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 July 2015

A. C. Skeldon*
Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics, University of Surrey, Guildford, Surrey GU2 7XH, UK
A. M. Rucklidge
Affiliation:
Department of Applied Mathematics, School of Mathematics, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: a.skeldon@surrey.ac.uk

Abstract

The Faraday problem is an important pattern-forming system that provides some middle ground between systems where the initial instability involves just a single mode, and in which complexity then results from mode interactions or secondary bifurcations, and cases where a system is highly turbulent and many spatial and temporal modes are excited. It has been a rich source of novel patterns and of theoretical work aimed at understanding how and why such patterns occur. Yet it is particularly challenging to tie theory to experiment: the experiments are difficult to perform; the parameter regime of interest (large box, moderate viscosity) along with the technical difficulties of solving the free-boundary Navier–Stokes equations make numerical solution of the problem hard; and the fact that the instabilities result in an entire circle of unstable wavevectors presents considerable theoretical difficulties. In principle, weakly nonlinear theory should be able to predict which patterns are stable near pattern onset. In this paper we present the first quantitative comparison between weakly nonlinear theory of the full Navier–Stokes equations and (previously published) experimental results for the Faraday problem with multiple-frequency forcing. We confirm that three-wave interactions sit at the heart of why complex patterns are stabilised, but also highlight some discrepancies between theory and experiment. These suggest the need for further experimental and theoretical work to fully investigate the issues of pattern bistability and the role of bicritical/tricritical points in determining bifurcation structure.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2015 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketch of a cross-section through the layer of fluid.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Typical tongues and linear stability region for the unpatterned state computed using the method of Besson et al. (1996). Parameters as for Kudrolli et al. (1998): the (dimensional) excitation is $\tilde{f}(\tilde{t})=\tilde{a}_{6}\cos 6\tilde{{\it\omega}}\tilde{t}+\tilde{a}_{7}\cos (7\tilde{{\it\omega}}\tilde{t}+{\it\phi}_{7})$, where $\tilde{a}_{6}=\tilde{a}\cos {\it\chi}$, $\tilde{a}_{7}=\tilde{a}\sin {\it\chi}$, ${\it\phi}_{7}=20^{\circ }$, $\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=16.44~\text{Hz}$, $\tilde{{\it\sigma}}=20.6~\text{dyn}~\text{cm}^{-1}$, $\tilde{{\it\nu}}=0.20~\text{cm}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $\tilde{{\it\varrho}}=0.95~\text{g}~\text{cm}^{-3}$, $\tilde{h}=0.3~\text{cm}$. Note that the structure inherited from the Mathieu equation is seen by the fact that the minimum of each tongue occurs at half-integer multiples of the drive frequency. In (a) ${\it\chi}=0^{\circ }$, the forcing reduces to $\tilde{f}(\tilde{t})=\tilde{a}_{6}\cos 6\tilde{{\it\omega}}\tilde{t}$, with a forcing frequency of $6\tilde{{\it\omega}}$. The largest tongue has a minimum for wavenumber of approximately $15~\text{cm}^{-1}$ for a forcing amplitude $\tilde{a}$ of approximately $7.5\tilde{g}$ and corresponds to a mode of frequency $6\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$. In (c), ${\it\chi}=90^{\circ }$ the forcing reduces to $\tilde{f}(\tilde{t})=\tilde{a}_{7}\cos 7\tilde{{\it\omega}}\tilde{t}$ with a forcing frequency of $7\tilde{{\it\omega}}$ leading to a primary instability mode with frequency $7\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$. In the case of (b), ${\it\chi}=63^{\circ }$, the presence of both $6\tilde{{\it\omega}}$ and $7\tilde{{\it\omega}}$ components in the forcing frequency mean that the drive has periodicity $2{\rm\pi}/\tilde{{\it\omega}}$ and is therefore of frequency $\tilde{{\it\omega}}$. This leads to tongues at $m\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2,\dots ,m=1,2,\dots$ . The first five tongues that are visible from left to right correspond to: $\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2,4\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2,5\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2,6\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2,7\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$. The largest tongues correspond to the $6\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ and the $7\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ modes and are driven by the two main frequency components of the drive. There are tongues corresponding to modes with frequency $2\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ and $3\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ but these occur off the top of the region shown. This particular value of ${\it\chi}$ is close to the ‘bicritical’ point where both harmonic modes with frequency $6\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ and subharmonic modes with frequency $7\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ onset simultaneously. It is close to this bicritical point that many of the exotic patterns are observed. (d) Bifurcation set showing the position of the tongue minimum that marks the instability of the unpatterned state, as a function of $\tilde{a}_{6}$ and $\tilde{a}_{7}$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Comparison of the experimentally measured transition from unpatterned to patterned state with numerically calculated linear stability curves using the method of Besson et al. (1996). For each of the numerical calculations, three different values for the viscosity are used. (a,b) Numerical curves overlaid on figure 12 of Edwards & Fauve (1994). Adapted with permission from Edwards & Fauve (1994). Copyrighted by the Journal of Fluid Mechanics. $\tilde{{\it\sigma}}=65~\text{dyn}~\text{cm}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\nu}}=1.00\pm 0.05~\text{cm}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\varrho}}=1.22~\text{g}~\text{cm}^{-3}$; $\tilde{h}=0.29~\text{cm}$; $\tilde{a}_{j},~j=\{4,5\}$; ${\it\phi}_{4}=0$; ${\it\phi}_{5}=75^{\circ }$; $\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=14.6~\text{Hz}$. (c) Numerical curves overlaid on figure 6(a) of Kudrolli et al. (1998) reprinted from Physica D, Vol 123, A. Kudrolli, B. Pier and J. P. Gollub, ‘Superlattice patterns in surface waves’, pp. 99–111, Copyright (1998), with permission from Elsevier. $\tilde{{\it\sigma}}=20.6~\text{dyn}~\text{cm}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\nu}}=0.20\pm 0.01~\text{cm}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\varrho}}=0.95~\text{g}~\text{cm}^{-3}$; $\tilde{h}=0.3~\text{cm}$; $\tilde{a}_{j},j=\{4,5\}$; ${\it\phi}_{4}=0$; ${\it\phi}_{5}=16^{\circ }$; $\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=22~\text{Hz}$. (d) Numerical curves overlaid on figure 2 of Epstein & Fineberg (2006). Adapted with permission from Epstein & Fineberg (2006). Copyrighted by the American Physical Society. $\tilde{{\it\sigma}}=20.6~\text{dyn}~\text{cm}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\nu}}=0.180\pm 0.009~\text{cm}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\varrho}}=0.949~\text{g}~\text{cm}^{-3}$; $\tilde{h}=0.3~\text{cm}$; $\tilde{a}_{j},j=\{6,7\}$; ${\it\phi}_{j}=0^{\circ }$; $\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=14~\text{Hz}$. (e, f) Numerical curves overlaid on figures 1 and 3(a) of Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Adapted with permission from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Copyrighted by the American Physical Society. $\tilde{{\it\sigma}}=20.6~\text{dyn}~\text{cm}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\nu}}=0.20\pm 0.01~\text{cm}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\varrho}}=0.95~\text{g}~\text{m}^{-3}$; $\tilde{{\it\varrho}}=0.95~\text{g}~\text{cm}^{-3}$; $\tilde{h}=0.65~\text{cm}$; $\tilde{a}_{j},j=\{4,5\}$; ${\it\phi}_{4}=0$; ${\it\phi}_{5}=16^{\circ }$; $\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=20~\text{Hz}$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Possible spatial three-wave resonant interactions defined such that $\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{1}}+\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{2}}=\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{3}}$. (a) $|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{1}}|=|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{2}}|=|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{3}}|$; (b) $|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{1}}|=|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{2}}|>|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{3}}|$; (c) $|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{1}}|=|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{2}}|<|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{3}}|$; (d) $|\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{1}}|\neq |\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{2}}|\neq |\boldsymbol{k}_{\mathbf{3}}|$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Linear stability curves and Floquet multipliers calculated from the finite depth Navier–Stokes equations (a,c) $\tilde{h}=0.3~\text{cm}$ (b,d) $\tilde{h}=0.2~\text{cm}$. Parameter values are taken from Epstein & Fineberg (2006) and are $\tilde{{\it\sigma}}=20.6~\text{dyn}~\text{cm}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\nu}}=0.18~\text{cm}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$; $\tilde{{\it\varrho}}=0.949~\text{g}~\text{cm}^{-3}$; $\tilde{a}_{j},j=\{6,7,2\}$, where $\tilde{a}_{6}=3.4,\tilde{a}_{7}=6.4,\tilde{a}_{2}=0.5$; ${\it\phi}_{j}=0^{\circ }$; $\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=14~\text{Hz}$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Comparison with figure 1 from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). $\tilde{a}_{j}=\{4,5\}$, $({\it\phi}_{4},{\it\phi}_{5})=(0,16^{\circ }),\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=20~\text{Hz}$. The fluid parameters are as in the caption to figure 3(e, f) with $\tilde{{\it\nu}}=0.21~\text{cm}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$. (a,b) Stability regions for different planforms. (a) Stable squares in green; unstable squares in grey; (b) stable hexagons in blue; unstable hexagons in grey. Note that for $\tilde{a}_{5}>0$, there are quadratic terms in the amplitude equations which mean that hexagons bifurcate transcritically. The unstable solutions that are produced in this transcritical bifurcation are stabilised in a saddle–node bifurcation, resulting in a small region of stable, subcritical hexagons. This region of stable subcritical hexagons is only visible on the scale of the figure close to the bicritical point. (c) ‘Most stable’ state using a Lyapunov energy argument: $+$ squares; * hexagons; ▫ quasipatterns. The theoretical results are overlaid on figure 1 from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Adapted with permission from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Copyrighted by the American Physical Society.

Figure 6

Table 1.Summary information for figures comparing weakly nonlinear analysis with the experiments of Ding & Umbanhowar (2006).

Figure 7

Figure 7.Comparison with Ding & Umbanhowar (2006) figure 3(b), $j=\{4,5,2\}$, $({\it\phi}_{4},{\it\phi}_{5},{\it\phi}_{2})=(0,16^{\circ },32^{\circ })$. (a,b) Stability regions for different planforms. (a) Stable hexagons in blue, unstable hexagons in grey; (b) stable quasipatterns in red, unstable quasipatterns in grey. Both quasipatterns and hexagons bifurcate transcritically and may be stabilised in a saddle–node bifurcation. This can result in stable subcritical quasipatterns/hexagons. (c) ‘Most stable’ planform using a Lyapunov energy argument superimposed on figure 3(b) from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Adapted with permission from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Copyrighted by the American Physical Society. * hexagons; $\Box$ quasipatterns, ● disordered states, where the coloured symbols are the theoretical results and the black symbols the experimental results. The red line is the linear instability curve for the harmonic $2\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ tongue. The black cross indicates the point at which the experiment shown in figure 9(c) was carried out.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Comparison with Ding & Umbanhowar (2006) figure 4(a). $j=\{4,5,2\}$,$\tilde{a}_{5}=5\tilde{g},({\it\phi}_{4},{\it\phi}_{5},{\it\phi}_{2})=(0,16^{\circ },32^{\circ })$. (a) and (b) Stability regions for hexagons and quasipatterns, respectively. Coloured symbols stable; grey unstable. Hexagons and quasipatterns both bifurcate from the unpatterned state at a transcritical bifurcation, where the unstable bifurcating branch changes direction at a saddle–node bifurcation. This leads to regions of stable hexagons and quasipatterns that are subcritical. (c) ‘Most stable’ planform: * hexagons; ▫ quasipatterns, overlaid on figure 4(a) from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Adapted with permission from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Copyrighted by the American Physical Society. The coloured symbols are the theoretical results and the black symbols the experimental results. The black dots indicate disordered states. Note that the linear stability boundary for the $2\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ mode is just off this diagram, and is approximately parallel to the $a_{4}$ axis through a value of $a_{2}\approx 1$. The bicritical point where the $2\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ and the $4\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ modes onset simultaneously occurs when $(\tilde{a}_{2},\tilde{a}_{4})=(1.05,3.80)\tilde{g}$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Comparison with Ding & Umbanhowar (2006) figure 4(b). Phase diagram for $j=\{4,5,2\}$ with $(\tilde{a}_{4},\tilde{a}_{5},\tilde{a}_{2})=(3.8,5.8,0.8)\tilde{g}$. (The position of this point for $({\it\phi}_{5},{\it\phi}_{2})=(16^{\circ },32^{\circ })$ is shown in figure 7c.) (a–c) Stability regions for squares, hexagons and quasipatterns, respectively. Coloured symbols stable; grey unstable. (d) ‘Most stable’ planforms: $+$ squares; * hexagons; ▫ quasipatterns. The results are overlaid on figure 4(b) of Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Adapted with permission from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Copyrighted by the American Physical Society. The cross indicates the point which corresponds to the cross in figure 7.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Comparison with Ding & Umbanhowar (2006), figure 2. $j=\{6,7\},({\it\phi}_{6},{\it\phi}_{7})=(0,40^{\circ }),\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=16.5~\text{Hz}$. (a,b) Stability regions for rectangles and hexagons. Coloured symbols stable; grey unstable. (c) ‘Most stable’ planform: $+$ rectangles; * hexagons, overlaid on figure 2 of Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Adapted with permission from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Copyrighted by the American Physical Society.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Comparison with Ding & Umbanhowar (2006), figure 6(a). $j=\{6,7,2\},\tilde{a}_{7}=7\tilde{g},({\it\phi}_{6},{\it\phi}_{7},{\it\phi}_{2})=(0,40^{\circ },80^{\circ }),\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=16.5~\text{Hz}$. (a–c) Stability regions for rectangles, hexagons and superlattice patterns, respectively. Coloured symbols stable; grey unstable. (d) ‘Most stable’ planforms superimposed on figure 6(a) from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Adapted with permission from Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). Copyrighted by the American Physical Society. The same symbol styles are used for both experiments and theory (▵ superlattice; * hexagons; $+$ rectangles; ● disordered states). Coloured symbols represent theoretical results and black symbols are the experimental results.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Comparison with Ding & Umbanhowar (2006), figure 6(b). Phase diagram for $j=\{6,7,2\},(\tilde{a}_{6},\tilde{a}_{7},\tilde{a}_{2})=(5.2,7.8,0.6)\tilde{g},\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2{\rm\pi}=16.5~\text{Hz}$. (a–c) Stability regions for rectangles, hexagons and superlattice patterns, respectively. Coloured symbols stable; grey unstable. (d) ‘Most stable’ planform, superimposed on figure 6(b), Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). ▵ Superlattice; * hexagons; $+$ rectangles. Coloured symbols represent theoretical results and black symbols are the experimental results. Note that in (d) hexagons are rarely the ‘most stable’ planform: whenever hexagons are stable, rectangles usually are too. Although the Lyapunov energy for hexagons is often similar to that for rectangles, rectangles nearly always have the lowest value.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Linear stability curves and Floquet multipliers for $j=\{4,5\}$ and $j=\{4,5,2\}$ excitation using parameter values as in Ding & Umbanhowar (2006). (a,b) Linear stability curves for $\tilde{f}(\tilde{t})=\tilde{a}(\cos {\it\chi}\cos 4\tilde{{\it\omega}}\tilde{t}+\sin {\it\chi}\cos 5\tilde{{\it\omega}}\tilde{t})$, where (a) has ${\it\chi}=0$ and (b) has ${\it\chi}=63^{\circ }$. (c) The corresponding Floquet multipliers, where the solid line is for ${\it\chi}=0$ and the dashed line is for ${\it\chi}=63^{\circ }$. The Floquet multipliers are calculated for $\tilde{a}$ fixed at the value for the minimum of the $4{\it\omega}/2$ tongue. So, for ${\it\chi}=0,\tilde{a}=4.35\tilde{g}$, for ${\it\chi}=63^{\circ },\tilde{a}=7.19\tilde{g}$. (d,e) Linear stability curves for $\tilde{f}(\tilde{t})=\tilde{a}(\cos {\it\chi}\cos 4\tilde{{\it\omega}}\tilde{t}+\sin {\it\chi}\cos 5\tilde{{\it\omega}}\tilde{t}+\hat{a}_{2}\cos 2\tilde{{\it\omega}}\tilde{t})$ where (d) has ${\it\chi}=0$,$\tilde{a}_{2}=\tilde{a}\hat{a}_{2}=0.8g$ and (e) has ${\it\chi}=62^{\circ },\tilde{a}_{2}=\tilde{a}\hat{a}_{2}=0.8\tilde{g}$. (f) The corresponding Floquet multipliers where the solid line is for case (d), where $\tilde{a}_{5}=0$, and the dashed line is for (e), where $\tilde{a}_{5}\neq 0$. The Floquet multipliers are calculated for $\tilde{a}$ fixed at the value for the minimum of the $4\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ tongue. So, for ${\it\chi}=0,\tilde{a}=4.40\tilde{g}$, for ${\it\chi}=63^{\circ },\tilde{a}=7.27\tilde{g}$.

Figure 14

Figure 14.The value of $b_{res}$ for $j=\{4,5\}$ (crosses) and for $j=\{4,5,2\}$ (dots) for increasing $\tilde{a}_{5}$. The solid lines are proportional to ${\tilde{a}_{5}}^{2}$. Parameter values as in Ding & Umbanhowar (2006) but with $\tilde{{\it\nu}}=0.21~\text{cm}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Surfaces for the onset of modes with frequencies $4\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2,5\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$ and $2\tilde{{\it\omega}}/2$. Parameter values as in Ding & Umbanhowar (2006) but with $\tilde{{\it\nu}}=0.21~\text{cm}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$.