Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T20:56:06.449Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Effect of modulation on the onset of Rayleigh–Bénard convection in superposed fluid and porous layers

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 October 2025

Tanya Rastogi
Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics, Malaviya National Institute of Technology , Jaipur 302017, Rajasthan, India
Om P. Suthar*
Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics, Malaviya National Institute of Technology , Jaipur 302017, Rajasthan, India
*
Corresponding author: Om P. Suthar, ompsuthar.maths@mnit.ac.in

Abstract

The present article investigates the stability of Rayleigh–Bénard convection in a composite system consisting of a horizontal fluid layer overlying a fluid-saturated Darcy porous layer subjected to a time-periodic temperature distribution. The bottom surface is heated periodically with time, whereas a Biot number-dependent thermal boundary condition represents the heat transfer at the upper surface. The Beavers–Joseph–Saffman–Jones condition describes the ‘slip’ at the interface of the domains, and the Lions interface condition governs the normal force balance, incorporating a dynamic pressure term. The Chebyshev tau method and Fourier analysis are utilised to obtain linear instability bounds, which are compared with strong global and asymptotic limits derived from the nonlinear analysis using the energy method. Four deliberately chosen configurations of superposed fluid- and porous-layer systems are investigated. Two configurations validate the analysis through the limiting cases of the classical Darcy–Bénard and Rayleigh–Bénard systems obtained by setting the fluid-to-porous depth ratio $(\hat {d})$ to zero and infinity, respectively. The other two configurations involve layers with equal depths $(\hat {d} =1)$ and a shallow fluid layer overlying a porous layer $(\hat {d} \sim 0.1)$. For these cases, modulation substantially influences the onset of convection. In the last case, the linear theory points out that modulation parameters can control the dominant convective mode (fluid/porous). Furthermore, unlike the previously reported studies, the nonlinear stability bounds are found to be significantly lower than the linear instability bounds, indicating the possibility of subcritical instabilities in the presence of modulation. The region of subcritical instabilities increases with modulation amplitude.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic diagram of the SFPL system.

Figure 1

Table 1.Critical Rayleigh number for the fluid domain and the porous domain (note that $\alpha = 0.1, \hat {\kappa } = 0.1, \sqrt {Da} = 0.002, \textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7, \phi = 0.3, Bi = 10^6$).

Figure 2

Figure 2.(a) Values of ${\textit{Ra}}_{f_c}$ and $k_{f_c}$ vs $\epsilon _{\!f}$ (solid, harmonic; dash-dotted, subharmonic) and (b) $ {\textit{Ra}}_{f_c}$ vs $\omega _{\!f}$. Note that $\alpha = 0.1$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.1$, $\sqrt {Da} = 0.002$, $Bi = 10^6$, $G_m = 1$, $\hat {d} = 10^6$, $\omega _{\!f} = 20$, $\epsilon _{\!f} = 0.4$, with $\textit{Pr}_{\!f}$ values shown on the panels.

Figure 3

Figure 3.(a) Values of ${\textit{Ra}}_{m_c}$ and $k_{m_c}$ vs $\epsilon _m$ (solid, harmonic; dash-dotted, subharmonic) and (b) ${\textit{Ra}}_{m_c}$ vs $\omega _m$. Note that $\alpha = 0.1$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.1$, $\sqrt {Da} = 0.002$, $Bi = 10^3$, $\phi = 0.3$, $G_m = 1$, $ \textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $\hat {d}= 10^{-6}$.

Figure 4

Table 2.Comparison of critical Rayleigh number for porous layer (note that $\alpha = 0.1, \hat {\kappa } = 0.7, \sqrt {Da} = 0.002, Bi = 10^4, \textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7, G_m = 10, \epsilon _m = 0)$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.(a) Values of ${\textit{Ra}}_{f_c}$ and $k_{f_c}$ vs $\epsilon _{\!f}$ (solid, harmonic; dash-dotted, subharmonic), (b) ${\textit{Ra}}_{f_c}$ vs $\omega _{\!f}$, (c) and (d) represent the streamlines and perturbation temperature in the $(x,z)$ plane at the onset of convection for $\epsilon _{\!f} = 6.84$ (harmonic flow) and $\epsilon _{\!f} = 6.85$ (subharmonic flow), respectively. Note that $\alpha = 0.1$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.1$, $\sqrt {Da} = 0.002$, ${Bi} = 10^3$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $\phi = 0.3$, $G_m = 1$, $\omega _{\!f}=20$, $\hat {d} = 1$.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Three-dimensional surface plot in the $\epsilon _{\!f} - \omega _{\!f} - {\textit{Ra}}_{f_c}$ space with contour plots in the ($\epsilon _{\!f},\omega _{\!f}$)-plane for $\hat {d}=1$ (blue, harmonic; red, subharmonic). Note that $\alpha = 0.1$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.1$, $\sqrt {Da} = 0.002$, ${Bi} = 10^3$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $\phi = 0.3$, $G_m = 1$.

Figure 7

Table 3.Critical Rayleigh number ${\textit{Ra}}_{f_{c}}$ with critical wavenumber $k_{f_{c}}$ when $\phi = 0.3$, $\omega _{\!f} = 20$, $\hat {d} = 1$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $G_m = 1$, $\sqrt {Da} = 0.002$. The $Ra_{f_c}(k_{f_c})$ values with SH represent subharmonic instability mode.

Figure 8

Figure 6.Variation of ${\textit{Ra}}_{f_{c}}$ with $\epsilon _{\!f}$ for different values of (a) Biot numbers, (b) ratio of thermal diffusivities (solid, harmonic; dash-dotted, subharmonic), (c) Prandtl numbers, (d) BJ constants. Fixed values of the parameters are $\omega _{\!f} = 20$, $\alpha = 0.1$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.1,$$\sqrt {Da} = 0.002$, ${Bi} = 10^3$, $\phi = 0.3$, $\hat {d} =1$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $G_m = 1$.

Figure 9

Figure 7.(a) Variations in ${\textit{Ra}}_{m_c}$ and $k_{m_c}$ with variation in $\epsilon _m$ (solid, porous mode; dotted, fluid mode), (b) and (c) represent the streamlines and perturbation temperature at the onset of convection with $\hat {d} = 0.10$ for $\epsilon _m = 1$ (porous mode), and $\epsilon _m = 2$ (fluid mode), respectively. Note that $\alpha = 0.1$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.7$, $\sqrt {Da} = 0.002$, $Bi = 10^3$, $\phi = 0.3$, $G_m = 1$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$.

Figure 10

Table 4.Rayleigh number (${\textit{Ra}}_{m}$) and wavenumber ($k_{m}$) for porous layer with $\omega _m = 20$, $\alpha = 0.1$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $\sqrt {{Da}} = 0.002$, ${Bi} = 10^3$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.7$, $G_m = 1$, $\phi = 0.3$.

Figure 11

Table 5.Critical modulation amplitude ${\epsilon _m}_c$ and corresponding $Ra_{m_c} (k_{m_c})$ for various SFPL systems with $\omega _m = 20$, ${Bi} = 10^5$. (Values with SH represent subharmonic instability mode.)

Figure 12

Figure 8.Variation of critical Rayleigh number ${\textit{Ra}}_{m_{c}}$ with modulation amplitude $\epsilon _m$ for different values of (a) Biot numbers, (b) ratio of thermal diffusivities, (c) ratio of specific heats, (d) modulation frequencies. Fixed values of the parameters are $\hat {d} =0.1$, ${Bi} = 10^3$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.7$, $G_m = 1$, $\omega _m = 20$, $\alpha = 0.1$, $\sqrt {Da} = 0.002$, $\phi = 0.3$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$.

Figure 13

Table 6.Validation of results of the energy method. Note that $ \alpha = 0.1$, $\hat {\kappa }= 0.7$, $\sqrt {{Da}} = 0.002$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $G_m = 1$, ${Bi} = 10^6,$$\phi = 0.3$.

Figure 14

Figure 9.Variation in (a) ${\textit{Ra}}_{f_c}$, and (b) $k_{f_c}$ with variation in $\epsilon _{\!f}$ for $\hat {d} = 1$. Note that $\omega _{\!f}=20$, $\alpha = 0.1$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.1$, $\sqrt {{Da}} = 0.002$, ${Bi} = 10^3$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $\phi = 0.3$, $G_m = 1$.

Figure 15

Figure 10.Variation in (a) ${\textit{Ra}}_{m_c}$, and (b) $k_{m_c}$ with variation in $\epsilon _m$ for $\hat {d} = 0.1$. Note that $\omega _m=20$, $\alpha = 0.1$, $\hat {\kappa } = 0.7$, $\sqrt {{Da}} = 0.002$, ${Bi} = 10^3$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $\phi = 0.3$, $G_m = 1$.

Figure 16

Table 7.Critical Rayleigh number (wavenumber) for linear, asymptotic and strong global stability when $\alpha = 0.1$, $\textit{Pr}_{\!f} = 7$, $\sqrt {{Da}} = 0.002$, ${Bi} = 10^3, G_m = 1, \phi = 0.3$. Values with SH represent subharmonic instability mode.