This book is a provocative and delicious compilation of essays on Yoruba identity and power politics. Edited by Toyin Falola and Ann Genova, Yoruba Identity and Power Politics benefits from the dedication of Falola to the study of Yoruba culture and history. The book includes a wide range of texts covering several discourses on its main theme, and features an assemblage of serious intellectuals of Yoruba history. The book engages with the need to reconstruct Yoruba history in the twenty-first century, both in response to loss of Yoruba social and political influence in Nigeria between 1960s and 1990s, and the need for native Yoruba scholars to decolonise some publications about Yoruba history and culture (p. 1).
The book is divided into three parts, viz: writing Yoruba, chiefs and tradition, and identity and modern politics. In the first part of the book, Falola and other contributors trace the history of Yoruba studies from the earliest works in the nineteenth century to the present. Engaging with dominant trends in Yoruba historiography, the contributors argue that scholarship on the Yoruba has shifted from primarily amateur histories to academically trained historians. Works like those of Samuel Ajayi Crowther and Samuel Johnson are cited as creditable projects on Yoruba history. Falola points out that early Yoruba histories primarily arose from oral traditions (itan) (p. 7), and their authors often lacked professional and scientific methodologies, suggesting that their works should be read as amateur histories. Contemporary Yoruba scholars now emphasise multi-disciplinary methodologies in the study of Yoruba history. Although the use of these in writing Yoruba history is still indispensable, Akinwunmi and Oduwobi employ the use of diverse sources of oral history such as the Ifa corpus, itan and oriki, documentary sources such as family photo albums and eyewitness accounts in their contributions in this book on early Yoruba dress and migration of the Ijebu respectively. Other sources for the writing of Yoruba histories used in this book include diaries by Adeboye (p. 74), existing Yoruba literature by Akinyele (p. 96), and archaeological evidence by Usman (p. 127). In her contribution to the first section of the book, O'Hear also emphasises the need to focus more research on previously under-researched groups such as the Okun Yoruba.
One of the most interesting aspects of this book, both in methodology and in content, is the discourse on the Yoruba chieftaincy system. The traditional chieftaincy system is described as complex and complicated. To Falola (p. 13), such complication includes the definition of terms like chief and tradition in a vague, temporal and restrictive sense. Due to this conceptual complexity it becomes difficult to attach a time dimension to tradition, especially when applied to chieftaincy in Yoruba society. In this section of the book, all the contributors agree that lack of proper definition of the ‘traditional’ in the Yoruba chieftaincy system has brought about the question of power and legitimacy in Yoruba chieftaincy. Hence, Vaughan's work examines Yoruba chieftaincy structures from the perspectives of communal identity and decolonisation (p. 177), while Adeniji (p. 192) sheds light on chieftaincy disputes in historical perspectives using an Ijebu town, Odogbolu, as a case study. He highlights the fact that the onset of colonial rule in Yorubaland caused many smaller emergent Yoruba towns, which were initially parts of the old Oyo Empire, to engage in rivalries for supremacy among one another. To Falola this eventually aggravated intra-ethnic tensions among the Yorubas. (p. 198). Relying on oral interviews and archival materials, Adeniji examines the struggle over the control of Odogbolu from its foundation in the nineteenth century until the 1980s. To Martineau (p. 205), whatever might be the historical crises suffered by the Yoruba traditional chieftaincy system, obas in Yorubaland constitute an indispensable intermediate body between the modern government and the people (p. 213). According to Falola (p. 166), chiefs and obas need to maintain a visible position in participatory functions in local government, in such a way as to enable them to be an integral part of Yoruba participation in Nigeria's modern politics.
In the last section, the book examines Yoruba contributions to the development of national politics in Nigeria. In this section, Adekunle and Afolayan examine the influence of the decolonisation process, intra-ethnic power relations, and the loss of Yoruba political power on the political struggles, which caused ethnic tension in modern Nigerian politics. Adding to the complexity, Genova investigates Nigerian political tensions about the control of its natural resources by examining the exploration of bitumen in the 1990s. While Olaniyi examines the Yoruba diasporas in northern Nigeria and their relations with northern Nigerian peoples, Abegunrin carefully analyses how the relationships between Yoruba and non-Yoruba groups were transformed by the annulment of a free and fair presidential election, which was assumed to have been won by a Yoruba man, in 1993. In Afolayan's opinion, the outcomes of the annulment included the evocation and re-invention of Yoruba socio-cultural groups to struggle for Yoruba autonomy and democracy (p. 300). In Adeyanju's view, it was also the annulment of the 1993 election that spurred the migration of many Yoruba intellectuals to Canada, where they now constitute the fourth largest migrant population from sub-Saharan Africa. Having examined the problems of political and economic crises in Nigeria and situating the problems on Yoruba identity and power politics in Nigeria, contributors in this section represent a range of different but related comments on the Nigerian national question.
On the whole, this book unquestionably provides an insightful and exciting research agenda on the Yoruba people of western Nigeria. It also makes an outstanding contribution to the understanding of Yoruba identity and power politics in Nigeria, especially in the twenty-first century. Thus, it serves as a standard reference for Africanists and all categories of students specialising on Yoruba history and politics. The above notwithstanding, the book is an uneven collection on the Yoruba formation of identity and power politics. Important Yoruba cultural attitudes and practices such as religion and belief system, arts and symbols, social networks (family, kinship, lineage and rural–urban networks), language and education are left out in the book as if they are not relevant in the construction and reconstruction of Yoruba identity and power politics in the twenty-first century.
