From the 1720s until the 1820s Istanbul served as the philanthropic nerve center for Jewish philanthropy on behalf of the Jewish community in Palestine. Emissaries would be dispatched from the Holy Land in search of donations, with Istanbul's Jewish elite serving as coordinator, overseer, and transfer agent of the funds collected. These Palestinian Jews, the titular Emissaries from the Holy Land of Matthias B. Lehmann's book, were typically rabbis or scholars representing the needy Jewish population and its institutions in the four so-called “holy cities” of Hebron, Jerusalem, Safed, and Tiberias. The Istanbul committee, a group of Sephardic lay Jewish leaders known as the Pekidei Kushta, or “Istanbul Officials,” also represented the Jewish community of Palestine before the Ottoman authorities. The emissaries from the Holy Land followed carefully designated routes in their fundraising and frequently spent extended periods of time on the road away from home. They performed a variety of historical functions in their peregrinations: they conveyed news of local conditions in the Land of Israel to distant Jewish communities; they disseminated information to the Diaspora on new intellectual currents in Palestine, such as the mystical traditions of Safed; they helped forge a sense of Jewish solidarity by conveying news of one community to the next in the far-flung and highly mobile Sephardic Diaspora. The familial and commercial networks that united widely dispersed Sephardic communities were reinforced by the periodic visits of frequently colorful and learned emissaries from the Holy Land. Their visits were a source of excitement to widely scattered communities and also served to break down the isolation of communities in remote rural areas of Morocco, Central Asia, Yemen, and the Caribbean. Although their routes frequently crisscrossed and traversed the Ashkenazic Diaspora, the focus of Lehmann's study is the Sephardic world, a world whose documentation was expressed most frequently in Ladino (Judeo-Spanish) and Hebrew.
Lehmann begins his innovative study by briefly describing the origins and evolution of the institution of the Palestinian emissary in rabbinic times. During the Middle Ages, Cairo served as the hub of charity collection for Palestine. With the expulsion of the Jews from Spain and Portugal in 1492 and 1497 and the Ottoman conquest of Palestine in 1516, Jewish settlement in the eastern Mediterranean quickened. The organization of fundraising for the Holy Land moved to Venice, the major surviving European Sephardic community in the 16th century, and to Livorno, Amsterdam and, finally, Istanbul. Other important Sephardic centers of charitable giving included Hamburg and London.
The emissaries kept ledgers and diaries, some of which, like those of Rabbi Joseph David Azulai, (HIDA) or Joseph Sapir and David de-Beit Hillel, have provided historians with important economic and demographic data. They recorded monetary pledges, details of donations, and personal travel expenses. Some of the diaries noted delightful details of adventures and misadventures experienced. These ledgers, supplemented by travel accounts, archival sources in Hebrew, Ladino, and Italian, and correspondence to and from Istanbul provide the building blocks for Lehmann's discerning and careful analysis.
Lehmann does not romanticize the emissaries or sentimentalize the various bonds that united (and divided) the Sephardic diaspora in the 18th century. Some of those emissaries who showed up unannounced, armed with letters of introduction and personal endorsements, were genuine scholars. Others, he acknowledges, were less learned, and some even provoked local scandals. While visitors from Palestine ignited the imagination and caused local excitement, not all of them were received cordially. Lehmann draws attention to the social and economic tensions that divided various Jewries concerning assistance to Palestine, also citing the occasional slights and snubs that some of the emissaries experienced. He does not hesitate to mention the occasional venality of some of the Palestinian representatives. At the same time, he appreciates that theirs was a difficult job, often thrusting them into unfriendly neighborhoods where they were drawn into petty local controversies and often experienced mistreatment by non-Jewish populations.
Lehmann skillfully utilizes a richly varied body of primary sources to create his finely grained analysis. He extracts institutional history from local detail and paints individual portraits of largely unknown figures from his many sources. Unlike the classic bio-bibliography of Abraham Yaʾari (Sheluhe Erets Yisraʾel [Emissaries of the Land of Israel], [Jerusalem: n.p., 1951]), which occasionally reads like a telephone directory, Lehmann succeeds in personalizing and individualizing a remote but generally pious and learned group of individual travelers, embedding them within a broader geographic and temporal world. If the precepts of “pidyon shevuyim” (the ransoming of captives) and support of Jewish learning and domicile in the Land of Israel were compelling, the reality of collecting funds to support these traditional imperatives was more sober. Emissaries often met rejection by local communities: their reports of plagues, earthquakes, hunger, and marauders in Palestine did not always open the wallets of wealthy Sephardic merchants in Hamburg, Amsterdam, Curacao, or London. Nevertheless, they persisted. At the same time, some of the emissaries were remarkably receptive to new ideas and novel phenomena they encountered in their travels, such as zoos, public gardens, and emerging technologies. Some even engaged in discussions with Christian theologians whom they met en route. Lehmann is sensitive to the many subtle signs of change in traditional Jewish life that Mediterranean Jewry experienced during this period, building upon and reinforcing his prior scholarship on the continuities between the premodern and modern eras in the Ottoman Jewish community.
Lehmann tells his story of institutional development and change well. While his analysis is replete with local information, he sees beyond the welter of details to suggest connections among local Jewish communities and global institutional forces of change. His thesis regarding the creation of a pan-Sephardic “nation” as a precursor to the emergence of Zionism is intriguing, albeit one that he does not spell out or develop as fully as the reader might like. Nor does he expand sufficiently upon his suggestion that the Palestinian emissary prefigured the emergence of 19th-century international Jewish organizations of mutual assistance and national rebirth such as the Alliance Israélite Universelle, with the emissary playing a pivotal role in alerting Jews to the land of Israel as a site of practical concern. Perhaps this reader is asking for more than could be contained in such a significant book. In sum, Emissaries from the Holy Land is an important study that supplements Lehmann's prior scholarship on the transformations of Ottoman Jewry during the 19th century and situates Sephardic Studies squarely within contemporary discussions of diaspora history and the modernization of Jewish society and culture.
