Sarah Wiliarty's book could not be more timely. It is published as women members of the German Christian Democratic Party are deeply split over two crucial women's policy issues that Wiliarty examines in her work: 1) conservative work–family policies and 2) the institution of quotas to counteract persistent underrepresentation of women. The book also comes at a time when German Chancellor Angela Merkel's image oscillates between European austerity queen and domestic political indecisiveness. How could Germany, a country that has long based its economic success and civic culture on a traditionally conservative male breadwinner model, elect a woman chancellor in the first place? And how could the CDU, the right-center Christian conservative party, bring women into a party that for the majority of the twentieth century defended the “stay at home” mom within a Kinder, Kirche, Kueche (“children, church, kitchen”) scheme? The author offers compelling and theoretically well-grounded answers to both of these puzzles.
The question at the center of Wiliarty's exploration is how the German CDU has responded to new demands from their women constituents and members since the 1960s. Conventional feminist wisdom has it that policy innovation for gender equality is much more likely in and with left-leaning parties in power. Yet Germany has had CDU governments for the majority of electoral periods since 1949. This is where Wiliarty's close-up examination of CDU positions in three different policy arenas comes in. She investigates work–family policy, abortion policy, and participation policy during different phases of German politics, starting with the Grand Coalition government of 1966 to 1969 and ending with Chancellor Helmut Kohl's loss of power in 1998. The last two chapters of the book are devoted to Merkel's ascent in the CDU and to comparisons with Christian Democratic Parties in Austria, the Netherlands, and Italy.
The theoretical backdrop of Wiliary's analysis, laid out in the first two chapters, is conventional party theories. The author stipulates that neither theories based on ideology or spatial voting nor traditional catch-all party theories can explain the CDU's response to changing demands from women over time (p. 24 f.). Even though Catholic conservative values are still at the core of CDU identity, they do not explain the policy changes that the party carried through when faced with a much more diverse female electorate in the 1980s.
The “essentialist Christian party” theory would predict that the CDU “will not respond to new demands from women with any serious adjustment (although the party may respond symbolically)” (p. 25). Yet the CDU in fact underwent massive changes in its incorporation of more women-friendly positions. By contrast, spatial voting theories would assume that CDU policy would be influenced primarily by changing voting preferences and by the actions of other parties. Thus, Green and Social Democratic Parties' more active promotion of women-friendly policies, combined with an active women's movement, might have corralled the CDU into more activism for gender equality. Again, Wiliarty shows that this explanation falls short, primarily because the complexities of a multiparty system with coalition partners in power make it impossible to predict whether a party will adapt to shifting voter preferences by moving to the left or to the right. Finally, Wiliarty debunks established theories of party organization as predictors of CDU positions on gender, and in particular the notion that the CDU is a traditional “catch-all party” with the effect of demobilizing its membership. Catch-all party theory would “predict that the CDU would issue statements on women's policies that are so vague they are hard to disagree with, while simultaneously demobilizing membership in an effort to dampen any tensions with membership over these issues” (p. 33). Wiliarty shows that the opposite happened: The CDU did not issue vague statements on women's issues and did not demobilize its members, but instead allowed the subgroup Frauen Union (Women's Union) to strongly advocate for women-friendly policies.
The Frauen Union becomes the centerpiece of Wiliarty's argument, and she introduces the “corporatist catch-all party” (p. 40) as an adequate frame to analyze the voice of the Frauen Union within the party structure. In a corporatist catch-all party, it is the internal power balance and the negotiated positions of different groups within the party that drive policy agendas. Like other internal subgroups of the CDU, such as the Laender party organizations or the Protestant, youth, or workers' groups, the Frauen Union attempted to acquire a powerful bargaining position in order to push for its goals. With the CDU leadership balancing “a range of societal interest groups” within the party, it has managed to award strong representation to women. An important contribution to the field of institutional gender politics is Wiliarty's analysis of the emergence of the CDU Frauen Union between 1969 and 1982. Embedded in the ascent of the women's movement and the starting institutionalization of women's policy agencies is a narrative about the politicization of women during this time. In the CDU from 1969 to 1980, “overall membership increased by 129 percent, while female membership increased by 266 percent” (p. 85), thus bringing the percentage of women in the party to 21. This increase in membership strengthened the position of the Frauen Union internally. By fostering coalitions with the equally powerful Youth Union and the Social Committee, the Frauen Union was able to shape progressive work–family and participation policies for women. On the abortion issue, by contrast, the internal division among these central groups was too large to channel joint policy positions (p. 108).
The period between 1982 and 1989 circumscribes the heyday of Frauen Union influence. As the CDU returned to government in 1982, it found existing work–family policies thoroughly shaped by Social Democratic principles and in particular by the “vision to make pregnancy and birth compatible with employment” (p. 113). The Frauen Union renegotiated these policies to reflect a commitment to the view that raising children is work. By the same token, the Frauen Union and its allies stymied abortion-reform efforts from the right wing of the party and countered the establishment of quotas in other parties by establishing stronger party language on inclusion of women on committees and in higher-ranking positions. Yet with German unification and new alliances forming within the CDU, the Frauen Union's power waned. Wiliarty shows how the loss of internal power in the 1990s accounted for limited success in all three policy arenas under investigation and ultimately left the internal organization divided and marginalized. This is not without irony, since it was in 1991 that Merkel's career took off with her appointment as minister for women and youth under Chancellor Kohl. Even though Merkel, as an Eastern Protestant woman, is seen by Wiliarty as an almost perfect representative of the corporatist catch-all party, she also shows the way that Merkel carefully insisted on distancing herself from any particular alliance or label (p. 164).
In sum, Wiliarty's study, by refocusing attention away from mere ideological or functional arguments for party positions and toward inner-party conflicts and coalitions, adds substantially to our understanding of party politics as well as gender politics in Germany. It is instructive that the corporatist catch-all party concept not only holds up for the author's time frame but can also explain the present intraparty conflicts about work–family policies and quotas. One empirical arena of knowledge is underutilized, however, and that is the Frauen Union itself. What kind of institutional structure has it given itself over the decades? How does it generate its positions? How does it mobilize support from members and beyond? How do Frauen Union rank-and file-members interpret the distance of Chancellor Merkel from women's issues? We hope that these questions will be addressed in Wiliarty's next project.
