In the face of record-high levels of polarization and record-low levels of productivity, this edited volume takes seriously the potentially deleterious impact of partisan polarization, and the sometimes uncomfortable questions about the asymmetry of polarization or the fit between “responsible parties” and our constitutional system (p. xxv). Ultimately, this book does much of what the editors aim to achieve—synthesizing our understanding of polarization across a diverse set of literature, and bringing new data to bear on the contemporary partisan conflicts (p. 4).
As such, this book has much to offer, both for research-oriented scholars and for teachers. Hitting on a range of questions about the causes and consequences of polarization, as well as articles that focus on the mass public, federal and state institutions, and the media, this volume covers a broader range of research than other edited volumes on this topic (e.g., Nathaniel Persily, Solutions to Political Polarization in America, 2015). It also brings new data to bear and addresses more recent developments than earlier volumes (e.g., Pietro S. Nivola and David W. Brady, Red and Blue Nation? Vol. 1 and Vol. 2, 2006, 2008). The range of topics makes this book an excellent resource for researchers wanting a better sense of the state of field and could be successfully incorporated as a teaching resource as well. The topics are broad and the material is easily accessible to a wide audience, which is bolstered further by bullet points about key insights at the beginning of each chapter.
An additional strength is the extent to which this volume addresses competing views within the field. For instance, arguments for growing mass polarization (Chapter 1) are balanced against arguments for sorting rather than polarization (Chapter 5), and the focus on the “mass public” extends to connections between positions and affective polarization (Chapters 1 and 5), the role of activists (Chapter 3), and individual personality differences (Chapter 4). We see a similar range of arguments regarding the media (Chapters 12, 13, 14 and 15) that touch on questions of selective exposure, the impact of partisan (and mainstream) media, the amount of media coverage of elections, and the routes by which the media can influence both mass and elite polarization. By including these various viewpoints, the readers better understand the debates within the field.
Inquiries into the extent of asymmetric polarization, with Republicans moving further right than Democrats moving left, reveals competing evidence as well. On the one hand, evidence points to similar changes in the ideological coherence of activists in each party (Chapter 3), a mix of symmetric and asymmetric polarization (from both parties) at the state level (Chapter 9), and a fairly symmetric shift in contribution patterns and the resulting CF scores (Chapter 16). On the other hand, partisan warfare in the Senate is more frequent among Republicans than Democrats (at least when Republicans were the minority) (Chapter 7), and NOMINATE scores from roll call voting reveal asymmetric polarization (Chapter 16). While there is no single answer to the question of whether polarization is asymmetric, since the answer depends on what type of polarization one considers and where you look, this book does a good job of laying out the positivist evidence for/against this question.
There are several chapters that also offer new takes on long-standing questions. For example, scholars have explored many routes to studying the impact of redistricting on polarization, often finding little impact of gerrymandering or differences in whether states use the legislature or commissions to draw boundaries. Chapter 2 takes a more nuanced approach, both to whether we can separate polarization into either intra-district divergence or redistricting effects, and to how commissions may affect the level of polarization. Whereas some commissions have an explicit goal of creating competitive districts, others do not. When combined with state geography, this suggests that redistricting has the potential to make a difference in the level of polarization, but only in a subset of states.
Given the potential importance of this book as a resource for researchers and for teachers, it is important to make note of the gender breakdown of the contributing authors. Out of 31 contributing scholars, only 3 are women. While the field of American politics, and legislative studies in particular, continues to have a gender imbalance in membership, it is not as stark as the numbers here would indicate (less than 10% female). As recent research shows, gender imbalances in citations (Daniel Maliniak, Ryan Powers, and Barbara F. Walter, “The Gender Citation Gap in International Relations” in International Organization, 2013) and in the construction of syllabi (Jeff D. Colgan, “Gender Bias in IR Graduate Education? New evidence from syllabi” in PS: Politics and Political Science, forthcoming) have important ramifications for the trajectory of our field and the success of underrepresented scholars. It is worrisome that a book that could easily be viewed as a “go to” guide for the state of the literature perpetuates this gender imbalance. Some efforts to note the expertise of female political scientists has been made in recent years (e.g., http://womenalsoknowstuff.com) but it is important that those working on edited volumes, conference organizers, and others pay attention to the gender balance (as well as race/ethnicity, among other underrepresented groups) when highlighting experts in the field.
Despite the notable strengths and contributions of this volume, it suffers from some of the common weaknesses of edited volumes as well. For instance, relatively few chapters offer new arguments or analyses that are not present in other published works of the contributing authors. There are, of course, some exceptions where chapters here appear to offer new arguments or original analyses (e.g., Chapter 11 on the policy consequences of polarization in the American states, and Chapter 12 on partisan media in the 2012 election cycle). A second weakness is that even when chapters address competing viewpoints on a topic (e.g., mass polarization or the role of the media), the chapters are rarely in conversation with each other, directly addressing the arguments and evidence of the other authors in this particular volume. Rather, each addresses past work in this vein, which sometimes leaves the authors speaking past each other rather than being in conversation with one another.
