It is refreshing to find a volume designed to draw together historians of science, instrument historians and museum curators to explore common ground in the relevance and importance of scientific instruments to their disciplines. The editors of this volume describe the conference which gave rise to it as having focused on the instrument-user's ‘intermediate role between the historians of science and the historians of scientific instruments’ (p. 9). That role was explored by way of three different topics: status of instruments, location and organization, and innovation. And it is these three categories that form the major divisions of the book. Of the thirty-two talks presented, twenty-seven have been included, giving a clear idea of the scope and variety of the papers at the conference. It is impossible here to discuss all of them – what follows aims simply to illustrate the broad tenor.
Status can be connected to scientific instruments in many ways. Frans van Lunteren's discussion of the Dutch standard metre shows how an instrument became an essential part in elevating the status of the institution where it was held. Those instruments held in a Kunstkammer or Kunstschrank – as discussed in three papers by Karsten Gaulke, Sven Hauske, and Sven Dupré and Michael Korey – raised the status of some owners/users while receiving status in turn from ownership by royalty or aristocracy. Equally, instruments may gain status from their use in particular laboratories (Alexander von Lünen's paper on J. S. Haldane) or from their presence in observatories (Bjørn Ragnvald Pettersen on Norway's harbour observatories, Francoise Le Guet Tully and Jean Davoigneau on the observatory at Nice).
As for location, the environment of an instrument is often essential to its operation, and some instruments are required only in particular places. Whether it is the schoolroom (Lissa Roberts on problems with scaled-down steam engines for teaching), the garden (Björn Brüsch on theodolites and levels in gardening) or the Western Isles of Scotland (Alison Morrison-Low on the development of Scottish lighthouses), location can have a major impact on the ways in which an instrument is designed and employed. Sometimes a location becomes an instrument in its own right, as in the case of the Leiden anatomical theatre (as portrayed in Tim Huisman's paper). Environment also encompasses the organizations funding research and developing new instruments – a point exemplified here by the British navy in the case of the gyrocompass (Sebastian Soubiran) and Leiden University physics department in the case of the school of instrument-makers created in that city (Dirk van Delft).
The concluding papers, on innovation, are much more traditional. We encounter Fabrizio Mordente's compass (Filippo Camerota), the latitude-observation instrument named the Spiegelboog (Nicolàs de Hilster), Trembley's porte-loupe (Marc Ratcliff), the Dutch electron microscope (Marian Fournier), the analogue computer (Charles Care) and others. Along the way some interesting observations are made. Once again, the role of industry is seen, here in the development of both the electron microscope and the stroboscope (Richard Kremer). Kremer discusses how a significant number of users of the stroboscope were created by the marketing efforts of the General Radio Company. Meanwhile, Pedro Raposo writes of César Augusto de Campos Rodrigues, who viewed instruments as ‘changeable tools open to modification and improvement, as well as sources of stimuli for the conception of new mechanisms and devices’ (p. 206). It was this attitude that allowed Lisbon Observatory to remain at the forefront of observational astronomy in the later nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Of particular interest is Yaakov Zik's observation that ‘the telescope allowed Galileo to bridge the gulf between picture and scientific language, between drawing and reporting physical facts and between merely sketching the world and actually describing it’ (p. 199). This is the kind of discussion that lies at the heart of finding an answer to the title question of who needs scientific instruments.
The CD-ROM packaged with the book provides all available PowerPoint presentations from the conference. These are a welcome accompaniment to the printed papers, allowing many more high-quality images to be viewed than would have been available in the printed text. Furthermore, those files for papers that do not appear in the volume generally provide a useful indication of the subject matter of the missing presentations. In the end, however, I found that, despite the many interesting individual contributions, the proceedings as a whole did little to bring closer the history of instruments and more traditional history of science. It is unfortunate that we have no record of the numerous discussions that were undoubtedly conducted at the conference, and which may well have gone further in unpacking answers to the important question of who needs scientific instruments.
