Edward Klorman's excellent study Mozart's Music of Friends is a wide-ranging interpretation of Mozart's chamber music that draws together many strands of scholarship primarily in order to nuance our understanding of these works as they may exist in performance. Klorman offers much food for thought here, to both scholars and performers. I hope his contribution will be digested and applied especially by those who enact and appreciate Mozart's chamber music primarily within the sphere of performance. Indeed, in what follows, I write from the perspective of a performer: one who has migrated from the world of academic scholarship on Mozart specifically into the world of historically informed performance (HIP; and for whom a book such as this is of immense value), though my contextual reflections on Klorman's book are not to be read as the pursuit of a specifically HIP agenda for Mozart.
Klorman's fundamental contention is that Mozart's chamber music, like much chamber music of its time, existed at least in part as an act of sociability: music as music-making among friends. His work sensitively bridges the gap between music conceived as a representation (visually, in a score) and music as lived experience in performance – or in the act of listening – in real time. He offers numerous detailed applications of a principle that music enacts. In this respect, he draws upon writing by Nicholas Cook, who has repeatedly visited the capacity of music to be simultaneously both artefact and behaviour. A recurrent theme in Cook's writing has been the notion of the musical score as a script (rather than a prescription). The dust jacket of one of his most recent books puts it as follows: ‘Cook supplants the traditional musicological notion of music as writing, asserting instead that it is as performance that music is loved, understood, and consumed. This book reconceives music as an activity through which meaning is generated in real time.’Footnote 1 Some years earlier, Cook had argued that performance could be viewed as a generator of social meaning, drawing in his thesis upon interdisciplinary performance theory (particularly theatre studies, poetry reading and ethnomusicology). Thus:
Whereas to think of a Mozart quartet as a ‘text’ is to construe it as a half-sonic, half-ideal object reproduced in performance, to think of it as a ‘script’ is to see it as choreographing a series of real-time, social interactions between players: a series of mutual acts of listening and communal gestures that enact a particular vision of human society, the communication of which to the audience is one of the special characteristics of chamber music.Footnote 2
Later he contextualizes this thought more broadly:
Instead of seeing musical works as texts within which social structures are encoded we see them as scripts in response to which social relationships are enacted: the object of analysis is now present and self-evident in the interactions between performers, and in the acoustic trace that they leave. To call music a performing art, then, is not just to say that we perform it; it is to say that music performs meaning.Footnote 3
The recognition that ‘music performs meaning’ is (or should be) of no small consequence to a performer of this repertory. After all, performers communicate. If what we communicate is meaningless, then we are clearly failing on some level: either we fail to understand the music or we fail to enact it with a vitality that responds to the narratives that unfold within it. What we communicate of those narratives is not necessarily what we believe the composer's ‘intention’ to have been, but rather what we believe we can see within the music's encoding on the page. This follows careful study of scores, frequently in relation to other contextual information, such as the understanding of form, harmony and counterpoint; of notational systems and what they may have meant at a particular time and in a particular place; and also of instruments of the period in which the work was composed (and of the settings in which those instruments were played) for what they might tell us about the nature of the music's expressive potential. Somewhat serendipitously, our understanding of what we see in and through the musical text builds into something that may be likened to a picture that we form in our imagination (and which subtly alters over time, when we return to the performance of a particular piece again and again). Likewise serendipitous is any given rendition of that picture in performance, which may change according to circumstance (for us, at least – and perhaps for the audience). For performers, the idea that the doing of all these things (whether in our rehearsal preparations or in concert) is actually the performing of our performer identities – in other words, one kind of ‘meaning’ that music performs through our behaviours – is a natural one and something to celebrate.
An attempt to get ‘under the skin’ of the kind of relationship that we performers have with Mozart's chamber music, one that reflects the kind of discussions and debates that we have with the music and with ourselves in the forming of that picture and – perhaps – the creation of meaning, is therefore welcome – all the more so when it comes from the pen of an academic who understands Mozart's music both as a theorist and as a player. Klorman requires of us a substantial leap beyond the signifying musical text: not so much what the music is, as where it might be. For performers, it is the where that normally counts for most: music exists in the making of it (Cook's ‘choreographing a series of real-time, social interactions between players’). This implies a central place for sociability within music-making, a concept that dominates Klorman's approach to Mozart's chamber music, whether from the historical or the analytical perspective.
Exploring ‘the music of friends’
Part 1 of Klorman's exploration addresses the historical dimension of musical sociability, seen through three important historical perspectives: ‘the music of friends’, ‘chamber music and the metaphor of conversation’ and ‘private, public, and playing in the present tense’. Klorman reveals a great deal about the nature of a concert experience for Mozart and his listeners. On some occasions, it was a less formal kind of event than today's public rituals, freely flowing between different musical genres, between professionals and amateur players (sometimes side by side), and between musical performances and other forms of social activity. While such a context for music-making was rather different from the more reverential expectations of present-day concert halls, it should be noted (as Klorman does) that respectful silence of the auditors was frequently expected within these settings, for instance in the salons of Baron Gottfried van Swieten, which Klorman references (p. 11 n. 15); indeed, Mozart, according to Michael Kelly, insisted on silence while he played, breaking off if it was disturbed.Footnote 4 Each of these early contextual chapters is richly grounded in literature from the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, as well as a host of recent literature – all sensitively applied. While Klorman's prefatory note to the reader advises that his (extensive) footnotes are not necessary for a satisfactory appreciation of the main narrative text on the page, they repay close study on several levels – most notably, perhaps, for the reader who is keen to approach the writings of Baillot, Koch, Momigny, Reicha, Sulzer and a host of others in the original languages. Nuanced discussions of terminology also appear here, along with some of the nitty-gritty of interpretative action, for instance on the tendency within the Franco-Italian tradition between c.1770 and c.1830 to evaluate music primarily in melodic terms (p. 46 n. 54 records Berlioz's somewhat dismissive report of his father's evaluation of one of his early flute quartets). Fascinating use is made of iconographical evidence of chamber-music playing (supplemented further within the associated web resource), with all due caution given about regarding iconography as an ideological rather than a realistic frame of reference.
Performers should be especially attentive to a point that Klorman explores at length (principally in Chapter 3: ‘Private, Public, and Playing in the Present Tense’) regarding the contrast of the fully rehearsed public presentation of a chamber work by a professional quartet and the more serendipitous event of ‘present-tense’ reading through (basically, endeavouring to get through it without too many mistakes, purely for private enjoyment). These are, and probably always were, two extremes, and the sophistication of the spectrum of possibilities lying in between is painstakingly unpicked, revealing en route a broad historical and generic panorama, taking in early nineteenth-century public subscription concerts, the professionalization of the string quartet, generic cross references with the symphonic (late Haydn and Beethoven) and an extended and insightful reading of Carpani's 1804 essay ‘On the Performance of Instrumental Quartets’. Socially, it is possible to discern a trend whereby the amateur player (sometimes of aristocratic pedigree) tastefully withdrew to the sidelines, vicariously enjoying the intimate conversational pleasures of a chamber-music piece from a seat on the front row of his salon, rather than gamely (perhaps excruciatingly?) trying to hold his part among professionals. Carpani has much advice to offer in his account of chamber-music performance (‘the perfect execution of this genre of music is as difficult as it is rare’; ‘someone who sight-reads very well is often bad at expression’; ‘[players] will not penetrate all the meaning in all the separate sections of such good works at once’). The gist of all this is that there was an increasing need to rehearse string quartets thoroughly for the performance to be satisfactory. This was especially true of the performances of the Schuppanzigh Quartet, noted for its relationship with Beethoven. Within chamber music, musical complexity was making new and challenging demands: technically for the performers, and intellectually for the audience. There was still a conversation, but it was no longer something happening just internally among the players prima vista; this was a staged debate, whose terms of reference had been carefully studied by the participants in advance, so that the serious business metaphorically encoded within the music might be represented with all due seriousness to the auditors in a communicative ritual of serious import.
Such seriousness of purpose sometimes called for explicatory reference that invoked textual analogy. Music as a form of ‘wordless rhetoric’ is something underlying the whole of Klorman's scheme in Mozart's Music of Friends. Yet sometimes words were felt to be a necessary scaffolding to the metaphor of chamber music as erudite conversation, and an extended treatment of Momigny's famous analysis of the opening movement of Mozart's D minor Quartet, K.421, coming as the culmination of Chapter 2 (‘Chamber Music and the Metaphor of Conversation’), actually launches the crucial sense of interaction – role playing – within Klorman's model, underpinning the remainder of the book. Players as agents – and, as corollary, chamber-music playing as multiple agency – are at the core of his thesis and introduced in Chapter 4 (‘Analyzing from Within: Toward a Theory of Multiple Agency’). This chapter is devoted initially to sonata form (and subsequently metre) and is set out at length in a series of case studies including movements from the G major String Quartet, K.387, the B♭ Duo for violin and viola, K.424, the E♭ Piano Quartet, K.493, the E minor Violin and Piano Sonata, K.304, the C minor Wind Serenade, K.388, and the notoriously slippery Trio 1 from the Clarinet Quintet, K.581, in which the clarinet sits back and observes as the strings alone try to make sense of Mozart's nit-pickingly precise slurrings and dynamics – never can there have been a marking more worthy of a player's gratitude than ‘Clarinet: Tacet’ here!
The book culminates in a virtuoso exploration of Mozart's ‘Kegelstatt’ Trio for clarinet, viola (Klorman's own instrument) and piano, K.498. The ‘Kegelstatt’ is a work I have performed many times, and which I have recorded twice: once on DVD, once on CD. In the DVD (subtitled ‘An Eighteenth-Century Conversation’),Footnote 5 I attempted, with my fellow performers, Jane Booth (clarinet) and Peter Collyer (viola), to explore the piece's inner world (both in rehearsal and in performance): how it functions from the perspective of the three players involved; how its narratives grow out of dialogues happening ‘in the moment’ across the ensemble; and how each of us adapts continually to the unfolding situation, now playing a leading role, now acting as a respondent, now providing a supportive background. We also experimented in rehearsal with what happens to the narrative (on the local level of a phrase or section) if we deliberately change our idea of who is ‘leading’ at that moment (for instance, if instead of regarding some of the viola's long held notes – such as in bars 141–5 and 163–7 – as harmonic ‘filling’, we viewed these as stable focal points around which the clarinet and piano construct their lines). We contrasted the intimate scale of our gestures with the rather different approach we took in a concert presentation of the piece (also included on the DVD). Reading Klorman's similarly intensive account of the performer's ‘role-playing’ that goes on in rehearsing and presenting this trio was fascinating, and offers me food for thought in returning to the piece in future.Footnote 6
Klorman's multiple-agency model (clearly explicated in a series of extended annotated musical examples and substantial cross references within the book's associated web resource) allows a sophisticated approach to the real-time narrative qualities of Mozart's chamber music that will be of considerable value to players. Agency, for instance, is implied by the instrumental lines notated within a score (strands of texture suggestive of particular roles within a conversation: stating, responding, interrupting, nuancing, undermining, challenging, confirming), but also refers to the players who are agents bringing this musical environment to life in sound. Klorman makes an important point (pp. 128–9) relating musical drama and instrumental performance, noting that whereas the character of Don Giovanni experiences the unfolding plot without foreknowledge of the events, the singer playing the role of Don Giovanni is, naturally, fully conscious not only of his own part throughout the drama, but also of all the other roles on stage. Similarly,
The real-life violinist [in a quartet] is aware that he is reading notes off a page that has been composed in advance, but within the quartet's fictional frame the persona of the second violin engages in a present-tense exchange with the others, all of whom seem to create the piece, moment to moment, through their collective actions and interactions. (pp. 128–9)
Drawing on some recent work on agency by Fred Everett Maus and others, Klorman is able to interrogate chamber-music performance as an art whereby ‘individual real-world players [enact] sentient, fictional personas’ who invent their own parts; he views ‘each musical utterance as the volitional and (at least marginally) purposive action of a fictional persona, a role that is enacted in the real world by an instrumentalist’ (pp. 132–3). Thus he can recast an analytical concept such as a sequential progression that boldly forges the way for a modulation to the dominant as ‘the cellist boldly forges the way for a modulation to the dominant’ (p. 133), conflating real-world cellist and fictional character. The cellist within this model is regarded as simultaneously a fictional persona; a real-world instrumentalist; in a sense, the co-composer of the piece; and an analyst of the work (whose reading is expressed through the performance). Such a scheme will resonate strongly with performers, who will no doubt also be grateful to Klorman for approaching his task with the inquisitive mindset of a player actually faced with making some sense of the peculiar world some of us inhabit whereby we daily torture ourselves with a coordinated succession of physical and mental gymnastics that generally lead only to the repeated and much-prolonged frustration (certainly in playing Mozart's music) that it could nevertheless have been better done.
Some reflections and contexts
Klorman offers players of Mozart's music both a useful reminder and a theoretical framework for understanding our actions. When we perform (and listen to) Mozart's chamber music, we are simultaneously performing a complex network of interdependent roles. This is the core of Klorman's argument. Couched in language that is at once readable and erudite, it is supported by numerous extended musical examples, annotated in detail with plausible narratives through phrases and sections which performers might profitably construct and enact while rehearsing or playing. It is perhaps this aspect that will endear itself most strongly to players. It captures effectively the reality of our complex situation as chamber-music performers, within which the acuteness of our interrelations is intense. The principal challenge is perhaps that we do not all think in the same way or at the same rate. The translation of a musical thought or intention into physical activity and resulting sound does not happen identically among all four players of a string quartet, though rigorous training and years of experience certainly help in the achievement of that artificial goal of unity/uniformity so beloved of audiences. We may disagree in rehearsal on fundamental issues of tempo, character, phrase-shaping; or on more subtle issues: how to express a dot over a crotchet at the end of a phrasing slur in early Beethoven, for instance, or whether or not a subito piano – Beethoven again – is most effectively represented in our performance by a tiny delay in the arrival of that note, or whether it is best expressed through textural balance. In a process involving multiple human personalities and the inevitable arrival of disagreement, this is where the music is. Music, both in performance and in its preparation, may be seen as an act of sociability. Social conventions of its public presentation (in the West, at least) nowadays require an intervening stage of agreement among the players (usually meaning compromise, and a consequent trace of frustration) between rehearsal and performance, so that the defining characteristics of a performance (from the perspective of the audience) suggest unity of presentation, rather than simmering discontent.
When we play music (meaning here exclusively music of the Western art tradition) we engage in real-time activities requiring ultra-specific coordination, usually of physical activity in the moment. Shifting the focus from that real-time practical choreographing to the conceptual, synchronous gaze of the analyst (sacrificing music's ‘where’ for its ‘what’) is something that performers have all too often been reluctant to do, regarding deep, systematic analysis as somehow detrimental to the vital spark of the music. That reluctance is not without merit. Sadly, it is often in the knowing (by means of analysis and written report) of what something is, or purports to be, that confusion and frustration set in. Not for nothing did Plato characterize writing ambiguously as ϕάρμακον (phármakon).Footnote 7 Performers are typically as ambivalent as King Thamus regarding the benefits of analytical writing about music, instinctively responding more readily to pragmatic and flexible metaphorical constructs than to systems. Above all, we performers prefer writers to engage with those real-time choreographies that we must enact. It is to Klorman's credit that he understands (as a performer himself) the vital synergies of intellect, technical command, convention, place, space, instrumental possibilities and their creative coordination. His sensitivity to space (in the first two chapters especially) is one that impinges fundamentally on Mozart performance, most importantly perhaps in relation to gesture.
Performers on modern instruments in large public concert halls engage with the music in ways rather different from those of Mozart's day. Gestures that were originally intended to be intimate and conversational are frequently and necessarily overdone in order to project satisfactorily into that cavernous landscape beyond the edge of the stage. Not for nothing are students trained in conservatoires to exaggerate every last nuance to the nth degree for fear that, at a distance of some 30 yards or more, carefully notated dynamic shadings and phrase-endings will dissolve into blandness or inaudibility (especially if those occupying the seats are members of a competition jury). An impressive arsenal of technical and mechanical tools has developed since the early nineteenth century to allow precisely this type of exaggerated communication to take place, among them string vibrato, legato phrasing and the generally more rugged construction of instruments of all types, allowing them to send a more piercing sound right to the back of the hall. As someone professing a HIP perspective, I naturally lament the negative consequences of these changed circumstances of communication for Mozart's chamber music, though this ethical dimension is not something to be pursued here. Close inspection of Klorman's historical situation of Mozart's chamber music within a space sympathetic to its conversational effects might encourage modern performers to think more broadly about diverse styles of communication that might be applied according to different spatial opportunities, and to be less influenced by an idealized notion of ‘concert-hall sound’.
Related to this is the nature of the texts we perform. While this is not Klorman's primary concern,Footnote 8 his understanding of Mozart's chamber music as a conversational art invites readings of it as script, not prescription (to return to Cook's claims, cited earlier). Teachers, performers and critics fret endlessly and anachronistically about the use of Urtext editions and the practice of Texttreue, removing to one side two significant historical contexts:
(1) The notion of an Urtext postdates Mozart by at least a century, and was a methodology applied to the systematic notation of scores, not the individual playing parts from which performers in Mozart's day worked (and which are frequently – and, to a performer, delightfully, creatively – haphazard in matters of detail); playing parts force an experience of music that depends on musically intelligent listening;Footnote 9 scores, by contrast, regress to the merely visual.
(2) By misrepresenting the scale of Mozart's notated gestures to conform to concert-hall expectations, performers are already compromising with the text; for instance, if you begin Mozart's G minor Piano Quartet, K.478, by deliberately exaggerating (dramatizing) the contrast between the ‘tragic’ unison opening figure (for instance, as if representing a crowd declaiming a verdict of ‘Guilty’) and the ‘pleading’ response of the condemned individual, breaking off, piano, in supplication, then you are ‘interpreting’ it, for sure, in order to perform it effectively in a physical space for which it was never intended – but can we claim our actions are True? Is such a performance social interplay or conversation at all? It would never have been addressed thus in a Viennese salon of the 1780s. For one thing, the instruments of Mozart's day were far lighter in construction, better suited to intimate conversation than declamation; both the tonal mechanics of a Viennese fortepiano (such as Mozart's Walter) and the variety of (probably) pre-Tourte bows common in Vienna in the mid-1780s led naturally to a rapid decay of sound away from the initial minim G, so that even though the dynamic for the remainder of the phrase is still forte, the quality of sound on the second note will lack the intensity of that of the first. This is followed by a leap into a much higher piano register, utterly different in tone colour on a Viennese instrument from that produced in bars 1–2. So there is in-built variety that is given to this passage by the instruments themselves, which Mozart knew and understood intimately, and for which he expressly designed his music. Its linguistic character is of intimate, conversational rhetoric, in which ever so subtle shades of intensity (for instance, the dissonances on the first quavers of bars 2 and 4) were audible within the close-knit gathering and metaphorically acquired a level of micro-meaning so typical of Mozart's chamber music: intimate speech rather than a soapbox and a megaphone. It is this more intimate story that Klorman encourages us to read: ‘How chamber musicians understand and experience their musical interactions in social terms, in time, as they play [… examining] a conversation in music that is also about music’ (p. 297).
Klorman's integration of the disciplines of reading, understanding and acting this repertory reclaims a central place for performers of Mozart's music. It encourages us, as performers, to rationalize our inevitably subjective engagement with Mozart's chamber music: because this music is conversation, performers are vital. His view stands in sharp contrast to that of some previous writers, for whom performers are hardly central. A prominent example is Schoenberg, for whom Mozart's chamber music was an object of the deepest reverence. Writing generally of music in 1940, Schoenberg noted that:
Music need not be performed, any more than books need to be read aloud, for its logic is perfectly represented on the printed page; and the performer, for all his intolerable arrogance, is totally unnecessary except as his interpretations make the music understandable to an audience unfortunate enough not to be able to read it in print.Footnote 10
This does not exactly invite a conversational theory of music! Schoenberg implies that performers were usurping their function by intervening creatively, daring to make decisions on tempo, on the particular intensity of a crotchet with a tenuto marking and on the grading of a crescendo; subtly determining relative dynamic levels between the parts necessary to foreground a Hauptstimme. If they did not ‘interpret’, but instead merely played what was notated on the page, might performers have escaped Schoenberg's ire? Or would he ideally have expelled performers altogether? (Comically, one might imagine an audience fortunate enough to be able to read music in print coming together in a concert hall; taking out their scores of Schoenberg's Fourth String Quartet before a stage empty of any performers; sharing that silent experience of communally reading and wholly understanding its logic so perfectly represented on the printed page; and then going home again, their lives aesthetically enriched – and all the more so for there never having been a single note played!)
Simultaneously (and reluctantly), Schoenberg seems to be acknowledging that ‘interpretation’ from performers is, after all, necessary (because not all listeners are fortunate enough to be able to read his music straight off the score), and that his notation alone is insufficient. He was surely not the first composer to experience frustration in being caught up in that conundrum. There is no conversational element involved in Schoenberg's idealized cerebral encounter: the composer expresses the logic of his musical thought through the medium of the printed score and the reader (or audience, should the unwelcome element of a performer need to be involved) passively receives the message from on high. For all that Schoenberg likens his performerless process to an encounter with a book, that experience is unlike, say, the reading of a novel (in one's mind). Here, an essential ingredient is the capacity of our imaginations to bring alive the characters described in the text; we create narratives (of character, time and place) through the power of our memory. We are not simply passive readers but performers (of a narrative). Unintentionally, Schoenberg's remarks help bring into focus for us the artificiality of demarcating roles of composer, performer and listener along the chain of supposed communication. Historically, these categories have been subject to remarkable change. The semaphore-like hierarchy of the composer, served in turn by the performer, communicating in turn to the audience, made sense for Schoenberg and his pupils in 1940. But that did not always hold true: understanding chamber music as a performance of sociability (as Klorman proposes) reveals that fact very clearly, providing a valuable challenge to an ideological strand that is remarkably persistent.Footnote 11
To be fair, it is doubtful that Schoenberg really did not appreciate the difference between simply playing the notes and performing them. He regularly engaged in string chamber-music playing in his youth, after all. But his writings establish the primacy of the musical text, its logic (like that of a book) ‘perfectly represented on the printed page’. This approach lies behind many of his observations on the language of music, especially that of the Classical era, examples of which abound in the chapters of his Fundamentals of Musical Composition.Footnote 12 Logic is writ large here, for instance in his analysis of the Menuetto of Mozart's A major String Quartet, K.464.Footnote 13 Mozart's ‘logic’ comprises three motifs (A, B and C), each concerning the interval of a fourth and subjected variously to canonic treatment and intervallic inversion involving various intervals and time-delays, and the possibility of contrapuntal combinations among them. Schoenberg annotates the whole of the Menuetto in an extended musical example, tracing the complexity of Mozart's logic; there is scarcely a bar that is not somehow circumscribed by Schoenberg's motifs A, B or C.
Understanding these motivic interrelations and the technical procedures that underlie them naturally has great potential value to performers. For instance, a quartet of players might try to construct a narrative built on the concept of Schoenberg's motif A (bars 1–2, in unison) as statement (repeated sequentially one step higher in bars 3–4) and motif B (the descending violin 1 line in bars 5–6) as a response, cadentially supported by motif C (the rising steps in thirds in the violin 2 and viola). While C only ever appears in this cadential context, the functions of A and B vary during the movement, including acting as simultaneous counterpoints to each other, or else to themselves individually (canonically, and sometimes in intervallic inversion). A and B also migrate throughout the quartet texture, so each player can engage in this play of imagined ‘roles’, contributing, as it were, to a lively developing exchange between four personalities stating, restating and responding – the particular pitches, registers, articulations, dynamics, contrasts of texture and phrase-shaping being analogous to contrasting inflections of voice in speech.
It is telling that Schoenberg's annotated musical example includes not a single dynamic marking. The vast majority of Mozart's articulations are likewise absent: the repeated crotchets at the start of motif B, for instance, are marked with three staccato dots under a phrase slur; they later become staccato strokes without any slur (bars 21, 42, 51, 59). Mozart's quite consistent slurring of motif A into two groups each of two notes is retained by Schoenberg, however, and he also slurs the first appearance of motif C.Footnote 14 The reasons for Schoenberg's selectivity in this respect remain unclear. His motifs A and B might each be thought of as subdividing into two components (represented in Mozart's articulations), but he chose not to include Mozart's original slurrings of B even though Schoenberg himself clearly regarded that motif as comprising two components (he annotates bar 6 with a ‘motif D’ – not mentioned in his prose description on p. 142 – to which he refers subsequently in his example at bars 22–4). Probably he felt that from a pedagogical perspective his demonstration of how the Menuetto's ‘logic’ worked conceptually did not require fuller annotation of articulations.
Dynamics, however, are another question – certainly for performers. If our quartet players were to construct their narration of Mozart's ‘logic’ from the basis of Schoenberg's motivic annotations, enjoining in playful interaction across the ensemble, then they would surely want to note the fact that Mozart presents motif A according to a different concept: the opening minim is forte, and the remainder of the motif piano. Moreover, the slurring (probably here also indicating bowing) is such that the crotchet – piano – at the end of bar 1 is contained within the first slur, rather than initiating a piano group of crotchets in response to the forte minim. The effect of this dynamic notation is, as any historically informed string player will tell you, quite normal for Mozart's time, especially in Vienna (where this quartet was completed in January 1785), because Tourte bows were not in wide circulation at that date, and most Classical bows (without the hatchet-shaped tip) still had relatively less power at the point. On a down bow, therefore, the tone would naturally fade in intensity. What Mozart's piano might mean to the player is that in bar 2 the up-bow stroke should consciously aim not to increase in intensity (volume) as it reaches the more powerful heel once more. The characterization of motif A is therefore of a rather special kind, and for its expression a particular technical realization is needed. And here is the gulf between Schoenberg's concept of the score as ‘perfectly represented on the printed page’ and the reality of musical expression. What the members of that imaginary ‘audience fortunate enough to be able to read music in print’ could not grasp from their scores is the performer's embodied knowledge of how a particular phrase might be (not ‘must be’) characterized in the process of bringing it to life. Schoenberg's formulation misses the essential quality of vitality that those pesky performers bring to the party. Consequential upon this fixation on the conceptual ‘work’ conveyed by a score is the ritual of the concert and the expected roles of its sundry participants variously representing and assimilating that musical ‘work’, rather like visitors to a shrine experiencing the manifestation of that contained within it. In an alternative scenario, we might imagine, as Christopher Small put it, ‘no such thing as a musical work, [but] only the activities of singing, playing, listening’.Footnote 15 Small regarded classical concerts in the Western tradition as embodying ‘a kind of society that does not allow for mutual participation of all peoples because it is based upon works, not interactions […]. Performance does not exist in order to present musical works, but rather, musical works exist in order to give performers something to perform.’Footnote 16 The sociability of music-making is one of its most highly desirable (and oft-forgotten) attributes, one that musicology has steadily begun to address (and long may that continue). Klorman's Mozart's Music of Friends is a prominent and very welcome landmark in this progress.
