The US inhabited territories and the District of Columbia (DC) have unique representation in the US Congress: they have no representation in the Senate and their delegates in the House of Representatives cannot vote on the floor. This article describes the congressional role of these delegates and addresses how they can be incorporated into courses on the US Congress and legislative behavior. Including these delegates in lesson plans and lectures presents new ways for students to think about Congress as a representative institution, about the presence and consequence of coalition building among representatives, and about how power is delegated and dispersed within the House of Representatives.
DC and the US territories are represented in the US Congress not by traditional members but rather by House delegates who cannot vote on the floor (neither when the House is organized into the Committee of the Whole nor when it operates as the House of Representatives) and not at all in the Senate. Their citizens experience a unique form of representation not often discussed in undergraduate courses on the US Congress; this article raises different opportunities to do so. Including these delegates in classroom lectures and discussions has three important benefits for students: (1) to make them aware of the United States as an empire and highlight legislators not often discussed in political science or historical accounts; (2) to engage them not only in the practical details of procedure but also in their meaning for how power is exercised within and by Congress; and (3) to help them understand how political scientists think about and tackle research questions as they consider the relationships among rules, procedures, representation, and power.
The article provides background on the delegates, including the history of the position and their status within Congress, followed by recommendations for incorporating the delegates and the territories they represent into a course about the US Congress. Little empirical work has been done on the delegates’ activities. Rather than act as a hindrance, this circumstance provides opportunities to engage in student-driven learning and to foster critical thinking about Congress as an institution and its members.
WHO ARE THE DELEGATES?
The office of territorial delegate to Congress originates with agents sent from the British colonies to London as far back as the seventeenth century. These agents were responsible primarily for improving communication and obtaining parliamentary approval (or delay) of colonial legislation. After the North American colonies obtained independence, the office of territorial delegate appeared in the report accompanying the 1784 Northwest Ordinance. The different incarnations of the Northwest Ordinance all provided that territorial citizens were economic equals to residents of officially admitted states and they extended US constitutional rights and civil liberties to the territories. The 1784 provision allowed states (or territories) to seat nonvoting delegates in Congress until the states were admitted into the Union (Sparrow Reference Sparrow2006; Taylor Reference Taylor1987). Unlike the colonial agents, these delegates represented their respective territories’ legislatures and citizens, and they often worked in opposition to governors and other federal appointees in their district.
James White of the Southwest Territory—acknowledged as the first official territorial delegate—set many precedents for a delegate’s role. In particular, except for voting, White received the same privileges and compensation as members of Congress and generally abstained from debate unless it directly concerned the Southwest Territory. Congress also established procedures to seat territorial delegates in the House of Representatives during this period, over the objections of Federalists who believed that White should be seated in the Senate. Other major precedents for delegate behavior were a result of Missouri’s delegation, which worked to “obtain” legislation to solve problems of territorial government or land disputes and spent much of their time writing letters to federal departments (Taylor Reference Taylor1987; Tice Reference Tice1968). Today, the US House seats delegates from the District of Columbia, American Samoa, Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI), Guam, Puerto Rico, and US Virgin Islands. With the exception of DC, these areas represent US territorial expansion after the Spanish–American War.
Today, the US House seats delegates from the District of Columbia, American Samoa, Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI), Guam, Puerto Rico, and US Virgin Islands. With the exception of DC, these areas represent US territorial expansion after the Spanish–American War.
The US House of Representatives maintains two distinct procedures for voting on the chamber floor: first, the Committee of the Whole, in which the House as a body considers amendments to a bill; and, second, after this process, members again resolve themselves into the House of Representatives to vote on bill passage. In keeping with the Northwest Ordinance’s precedent, the contemporary delegates who represent the US territories cannot vote in either configuration (hereafter combined and referred to as “floor votes” or “voting on the chamber floor”). The delegates have been granted voting rights on the chamber floor twice in recent history: in 1993 (which ended in 1995) and 2007 (which ended in 2011). In both instances, the voting privileges extended only to votes taken in the Committee of the Whole. If the vote margin were less than the number of voting delegates (wherein any of the delegates’ votes may have changed the outcome), the Committee of the Whole would recast its votes without including the delegates.
The majority of literature about the US insular territories concerns their citizens’ legal and constitutional status and appears primarily in law reviews and sociological texts. Political science research on how these citizens are represented in Congress and the territorial delegates’ legislative behavior is generally sparse. The best—perhaps only—extant article on island delegates in Congress is Holtzman’s Reference Holtzman1986 “Empire and Representation.” In that article, Holtzman described how territorial representation evolved from the Northwest Ordinance and how Congress created the contemporary system of representation for the island areas, and it also considered how delegates represent their constituents. Holtzman (Reference Holtzman1986, 271) wrote that “their representatives have, at the level of the committees of the House, become fully integrated in the Congress, equal decision makers with the representatives of the states.” In other areas, however, Holtzman likened the delegates and resident commissioner to foreign diplomats. Indeed, the official Rules of the House of Representatives refers throughout to “Members, Delegates, or the Resident Commissioner,” which emphasizes that the latter two groups are not considered House members (Davis Reference Davis2015; US House of Representatives 2015).
TEACHING THE DELEGATES
The lack of a robust literature on these delegates and their behavior presents a challenge for incorporating them into a course on the US Congress. However, it also represents an opportunity to foster in-class discussion and to develop and engage students’ critical thinking about different aspects of congressional life, the institution’s role in US politics, and how citizens of the territories are represented at the federal level. The best approach to incorporating the delegates into a course about Congress, therefore, may be to pose questions to students about the delegates, what we might expect given their unique status, and what their status means for representation. The remainder of this section organizes potential questions into different points of emphasis within a course on the US Congress.
Elections
When discussing congressional elections, a traditional course on Congress might emphasize candidate recruitment and quality, the incumbent advantage, and how members communicate with their constituents. Important to all of these concepts is the idea that constituents often evaluate legislators’ tenure based on their voting record (Arnold Reference Arnold1990). Without this voting record on which to rely, how should constituents evaluate incumbents? How do challengers make their case to replace those incumbents? The two parties have polarized in recent decades, with members of Congress voting along party lines to a greater degree (Theriault Reference Theriault2008). This trend suggests that members of Congress are relying more on partisan cues and less on the “personal vote” to interact with their constituents (Cox and McCubbins Reference Cox and McCubbins1993). Does the personal vote thrive when legislators cannot rely on party heuristics to drive their reelection? How might those dynamics operate in an era in which official earmarks are now banned and traditional distributive politics have become mired in congressional dysfunction and a static budgetary process?
Rules and the Legislative Process
A course unit on congressional rules and procedures often moves through the legislative process from bill introduction to final enactment, with discussion about the rules governing floor debate and voting. The delegates’ experience and inability to cast floor votes can be a way to introduce students to broader questions about what roll-call voting represents and the interplay between congressional rules and representation. Recent work on congressional agenda setting highlights the fact that voting need not be the only outlet for congressional responsiveness and effectiveness (Sulkin Reference Sulkin2005; Volden and Wiseman Reference Volden and Wiseman2014). The delegates still can introduce and cosponsor legislation and be active on committees; several have chaired subcommittees. Yet, the House rules establishing the structure and limits of all of these activities typically are adopted by roll-call vote. What does it mean that the delegates cannot vote to adopt the rules that govern their activity? How might that affect the way that they conduct their business, and how should we think about congressional rules and procedures in that context?
The delegates also may neither sponsor nor sign discharge petitions, which allow a majority of House members to call for a bill to be removed from consideration and debated on the floor. Delegate Madeleine Bordallo (D-Guam) introduced a resolution in 2004 that would grant this privilege, cosponsored by other delegates, but it was not acted on. DC and the US territories are made even more distinct in their lack of Senate representation. Their House delegates therefore lack key allies in advancing measures through the legislative process. These facts can facilitate thought exercises for students either individually or in groups: Which strategies would they use to convince someone to pass their bill without being able to engage in logrolling? Who would they look to as legislative partners?
DC and the US territories are made even more distinct in their lack of Senate representation. Their House delegates therefore lack key allies in advancing measures through the legislative process.
Representation and Policy
When discussing congressional representation, a course on the US Congress typically addresses how the institution responds to citizen preferences for public policy through delegate-versus-trustee models of constituent–legislator relationships and descriptive-versus-substantive representation of different groups in Congress. The differences in how DC and the US territories are represented in Congress manifest in public policy. The federal laws governing the territories often differ from those governing the 50 states, either because of the territories’ unique political status or because Congress specifically carves out statutory exceptions.
Minimum-wage policy is an interesting example of this phenomenon and highlights many of the dynamics among congressional rules, representation, and democratic accountability. A significant percentage of residents in the territories live below the US poverty line. Although the federal government sets a minimum wage, “prevailing wage” rates often are set locally by different industries and trade associations. The minimum wage set under the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA) and its subsequent amending acts generally applies to the island territories. However, a 1956 amendment to the FLSA allowed Special Industry Committees to make recommendations for setting wages below the federal minimum in certain industries in these territories (a practice previously instituted for Puerto Rico and the US Virgin Islands in 1940). When the Northern Mariana Islands became a Commonwealth in association with the United States in the mid-1970s, it was allowed to retain local control over wage policy as well as immigration laws (Whittaker Reference Whittaker2008).
In 2007, the Democratic majorities in Congress enacted a supplemental appropriations bill for that fiscal year. Among other provisions, the bill provided for incremental increases in the federal minimum wage and included American Samoa and the CNMI, each of which has higher percentages of workers paid the minimum wage than any of the 50 states but local minimum wages below the federal rate. Most of the territorial delegates openly supported increasing the minimum wage in the CNMI. Every delegate joined with 218 other Democrats to cosponsor the bill, with the exception of Republican Resident Commissioner Luis Fortuño of Puerto Rico.
At Congress’s request, the US Government Accountability Office (GAO) reported on the effect of the enacted wage-rate increase and any future increases in American Samoa and the CNMI, finding that employers in both island areas cut worker benefits and began to close their businesses. In their responses to the GAO’s findings, local American Samoa officials urged the federal government to terminate all scheduled minimum-wage increases there. Whereas employers in the CNMI attributed reduced worker hours and benefits, hiring freezes, and layoffs to the tsunami and Fukushima nuclear-plant disaster in Japan—which depressed travel to the area—rather than to the US minimum-wage increase, the CNMI government challenged those responses and emphasized the role of the minimum-wage increase (US GAO 2011). Five months after the first GAO report, Congress cleared legislation that halted the scheduled 2010 and 2011 minimum-wage increases.
Although disagreements between local officials and members of Congress are not new, the delegates’ unique status introduces additional questions about who represents the territories’ citizens in Congress. Because the territory and DC delegates cannot vote on the House floor, they had more limited opportunities to directly express their constituents’ opinions about legislation that directly affected the territorial economies. As with the adoption of House rules, the delegates were excluded from key policy decisions that affected them and their constituents. A discussion question for students about this episode might be: How should constituents in American Samoa and the Northern Mariana Islands evaluate not only the resulting policy output and their effects on the local economy but also their elected delegates’ role in the process that produced those results?
Congress and Power in the American Political System
The minimum-wage example encourages students to think about not only individual legislators’ roles within Congress but also the institution’s broader role and use of power in the US political system. Congressional power often is discussed in the classroom with regard to the institution’s relationship to the other branches as set out in the Constitution, and to the states as developed over years of policy making and legal precedent. Incorporating US territories and their delegates expands on this topic and encourages students to think about Congress’s power within the American political system in different respects. Recent years have seen several high-profile examples of Congress acting (or not acting) in ways that affect the power dynamic between the US federal government and its dependencies, including issues of home rule and fiscal autonomy.
The District of Columbia must obtain congressional approval for its budget. In 2013, DC voters approved the DC Budget Autonomy Act, which amended the city’s home-rule charter to state that the budget would be considered approved if Congress did not act on it within 30 days of it being submitted. The DC Superior Court later upheld that legislation. In May 2016, the House of Representatives voted to approve a bill that would overturn that action and included similar language in an appropriations bill believed more likely to receive Senate approval. This example raises several questions for students to consider: How should Congress deal with DC’s budget and spending? Should DC voters be allowed to impose restrictions on Congress’s ability to carry out its constitutional responsibility over federal spending?
After months of debate, Congress passed and President Obama signed legislation to rescue Puerto Rico from its massive debt obligations. Although the law represents a bipartisan accomplishment, some Democrats still disagreed with the creation of a new congressionally appointed board with authority to restructure the island’s finances. Puerto Rico–born Representative Nydia Velazquez (D-NY) argued that “If the control board takes the people’s power away, it will just be viewed as another colonial power grab by the government” (Lane Reference Lane2016). In the classroom, students might consider questions such as: What responsibility does Congress have to relieve US territories’ debts? Who should oversee completion of that task?
Issues of congressional power over citizens of DC and the territories need not even be so prominent. When the Republicans gained a majority of House seats after the 1994 elections, they eliminated the District of Columbia Committee and shifted its responsibilities to the Government Oversight and Reform Committee. Shuffling committee jurisdictions in this way affects the level of attention that DC-related issues receive in Congress, which in turn reflects a shift in access to the broader congressional agenda. Students might consider questions such as: Should Congress create a committee (or committees) specifically devoted to issues facing DC and the territories, as it has for small-business issues and American Indian affairs? More broadly, how do committee jurisdictions influence the power and agenda access that different groups receive in Congress?
CONCLUSION
The unique legal status of DC and the US territories is reflected in their congressional representation. The territories elect nonvoting delegates; but political science has not seriously considered these delegates’ roles and behaviors in the past 30 years. The lack of concrete answers on how these delegates conduct their affairs creates an opportunity to incorporate them into an undergraduate course on the US Congress by posing questions to students. This creates an environment of mutual discovery as a way to learn the “nuts and bolts” of congressional procedure and to think more broadly about the institution and its role and function within American politics and public policy.
