Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-15T14:46:34.038Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Drag force in granular shear flows: regimes, scaling laws and implications for segregation

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 September 2022

Lu Jing
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA
Julio M. Ottino
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USADepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USANorthwestern Institute on Complex Systems (NICO), Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA
Paul B. Umbanhowar
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA
Richard M. Lueptow*
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USADepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USANorthwestern Institute on Complex Systems (NICO), Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: r-lueptow@northwestern.edu

Abstract

The drag force on a spherical intruder in dense granular shear flows is studied using discrete element method simulations. Three regimes of the intruder dynamics are observed depending on the magnitude of the drag force (or the corresponding intruder velocity) and the flow inertial number: a fluctuation-dominated regime for small drag forces; a viscous regime for intermediate drag forces; and an inertial (cavity formation) regime for large drag forces. The transition from the viscous regime (linear force-velocity relation) to the inertial regime (quadratic force-velocity relation) depends further on the inertial number. Despite these distinct intruder dynamics, we find a quantitative similarity between the intruder drag in granular shear flows and the Stokesian drag on a sphere in a viscous fluid for intruder Reynolds numbers spanning five orders of magnitude. Beyond this first-order description, a modified Stokes drag model is developed that accounts for the secondary dependence of the drag coefficient on the inertial number and the intruder size and density ratios. When the drag model is coupled with a segregation force model for intruders in dense granular flows, it is possible to predict the velocity of gravity-driven segregation of an intruder particle in shear flow simulations.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Simulation set-up and schematic trajectory of an intruder particle (not to scale). The inset shows a sinking intruder (red) and its contacting (blue) and non-contacting (grey) neighbouring particles in a small section of the flow. (b,c) Rheological data measured in the flow for $10\leqslant z/d \leqslant 20$ for various simulations. Square and circle symbols represent $P_0=100$ Pa and $1000$ Pa, respectively, and the colour from blue to red indicates increasing $I$ (see text for range of $\dot \gamma _0$). Solid curves in (b) and (c) are described by $\mu (I)=0.36+0.55/(0.73/I+1)$ and $\phi (I)=0.59-0.14I$, respectively.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Examples of (a–d) intruder vertical position versus time $t$ and (e–h) corresponding flow fields around the intruder (in the intruder reference frame) for various drag forces $F_d$ (see labels in the figure; note the differing horizontal time scales). The flow conditions are $P_0=1000$ Pa and $\dot \gamma _0=10$ s$^{-1}$ ($I=0.08$), and the intruder properties are $R=1$ and $R_\rho =1$. Grey areas in (a–d) indicate the measurement window where the intruder velocity (slope) and local flow fields are evaluated (see §§ 2.2 and 3.1 for details). The white contours of local packing density $\phi '$ in (e–h) have an interval of $0.1$ and the outermost contour is for $\phi '=0.5$. For clarity, the velocity vectors are presented at a coarser resolution than the $\phi '$ fields and the arrows in (e–h) have different scales; the scale of $w_i$ can be roughly inferred from figure 3.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Drag force results for intruders equal in size and density to the surrounding bed particles ($R=1$ and $R_\rho =1$). (a) Intruder velocity $w_i/(\dot \gamma _0d_i)$ and (b) nearby packing density $\phi '_n/\phi$ versus drag force $F_d/(P_0d_i^2)$ for $P_0=1000$ Pa and $\dot \gamma _0=10$ s$^{-1}$ ($I=0.08$). The shaded red area in the inset of (b) indicates the region where $\phi '_n$ is evaluated. Panels (c,d) are the same as (a,b) but for all flow conditions (same symbols as in figure 1). Panel (e) is the same as (c) except that $w_i$ is non-dimensionalized by $\sqrt {P_0/\rho }$ instead of $\dot \gamma _0d_i$. Grey shaded areas in (b–e) indicate the approximate conditions ($F_d/(P_0d_i^2)\gtrsim 5$) where cavity formation is significant ($\phi '_n/\phi \lesssim 0.9$).

Figure 3

Figure 4.Drag coefficient $C_d$ versus intruder Reynolds number $Re_i$ for $R=1$ and $R_\rho =1$. Data are recast from figure 3(c) with the same symbols. The solid, dashed, dotted and dot–dash curves represent relations $C_d=24/Re_i$, $C_d=8/Re_i$, $C_d=24/Re_i(1+3Re_i/16)$ and $C_d=24/Re_i+6/(1+\sqrt {Re_i})+0.4$, respectively (see text).

Figure 4

Figure 5.Effects of larger size ratio ($R=4$ and $R_\rho =1$, blue symbols, panels (a,b)) and larger density ratio ($R=1$ and $R_\rho =10$, red symbols, panels (c,d)) on (a,c) $w_i/(\dot \gamma _0d_i)$ versus $F_d/(P_0d_i^2)$ and (b,d) $\phi '_n/\phi$ versus $F_d/(P_0d_i^2)$ results. Light, medium and dark colours correspond to $I=\{0.004,0.16,0.64\}$, respectively, and grey crosses are $R=1$ and $R_\rho =1$ data reproduced from figure 3(b,d) for comparison. Insets in (b,d) at $F_d/(P_0d_i^2)=10$ and $I=0.64$ demonstrate the near-intruder flow fields using the same colour map as figure 2(e–h). Grey shaded areas match those in figure 3(b–e).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Results for $R=4$ (blue symbols) and $R_\rho =10$ (red symbols) in terms of $C_d$ versus $Re_i$; data recast from figure 5(a,c). Grey crosses are reproduced from figure 4 for reference, while the solid, dashed, dotted and dot–dash curves are the same as those in figure 4.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Dependence of $c$ on $I$, $R$ and $R_\rho$. (a) Plot of $c$ versus $I$ (with $R_\rho =1$) for $R=1$ (squares) and $R=4$ (circles). The dotted line indicates a previous result of $c=1.73$ for $R=1$ (Duan et al.2020). (b) Plot of $c$ versus $R$ (with $R_\rho =1$) and (c) $c$ versus $R_\rho$ (with $R=1$) for $I=\{0.008,0.16,0.32,0.64\}$, where symbols with light to dark shading indicate increasing $I$ and the dotted vertical lines indicate $R=1$ and $R_\rho =1$, respectively. In (a–c), the solid curves with colours matching the corresponding symbols are based on the empirical fit (3.2), which is developed in Appendix B. (d) Measured value of $c$ from simulations versus $c$ according to (3.2) for all conditions in (a–c) and additional conditions of $(R,R_\rho )=(2,5)$ and $(R,R_\rho )=(2,10)$ for $I=\{0.008,0.16,0.32,0.64\}$ (green symbols). The dashed diagonal line indicates perfect prediction.

Figure 7

Figure 8.(a) Solid curves (left-hand axis) are $c=c(R)$ for $R_\rho =4$ and $I_{loc}=\{0.005,0.1,0.2,0.4\}$ (see text) according to the empirical fit (3.2); colours from blue to red indicate increasing $I$. The dotted curve (right-hand axis) is $f(R)=[1-1.43\exp (-R/0.92)][1+3.55\exp (-R/2.94)]$, which is independent of $I$ (Jing et al.2020). (b) Simulation results of $w_i/(\dot \gamma _0d)$ versus $R$ (circles) for gravity-induced sedimentation of heavy intruders in uniform shear flows (see text) and the corresponding predictions (curves) of model (4.2); colours from blue to red match those in (a). Error bars in (b) represent the standard error of $w_i$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Summary of $C_d$ versus $Re_i$ data for all ($I$, $R$, $R_\rho$) conditions explored in this paper, including over $1000$ simulations with $0.01\leqslant F_d/(P_0d_i^2)\leqslant 100$, $10^{-3}\lesssim I \lesssim 1$, $0.6\leqslant R \leqslant 5$ and $1\leqslant R_\rho \leqslant 20$. Symbol colours match those in figure 7, and the solid, dashed, dotted and dot–dash model curves are identical to those in figures 4 and 6.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Effects of $\tilde {K}_s$ on (a) $\sqrt {T}/(\dot \gamma _0 d)$, (b) $\chi /\chi _0$, (c) $\mu$ and (d) $\phi$ versus $I$. Filled circles with light to dark shading are velocity-controlled flows with $\tilde {K}_s=\{0.01,0.05,0.1,0.5,1\}$, while red crosses are uncontrolled, simple shear flows ($\tilde {K}_s=0$). The dotted lines in (a,b) indicate, respectively, a slope of $-0.25$ and a perfect linear velocity profile ($\chi /\chi _0=1$), while the dotted curves in (c,d) are empirical fits identical to the curves in figure 1(b,c). The flow properties $T$, $\mu$, and $\phi$ are averaged in a $10d$-thick layer in the middle of the flow, while the shape factor $\chi$ is computed considering the entire velocity profile between the lower and upper bounding walls.

Figure 10

Figure 11.(a) Identical to figure 9 except that only the data associated with $0.1\leqslant F_d/(P_0d_i^2)\leqslant 5$ are included (approximately $800$ simulations). (b,c) Data recast from (a), where the solid red curves are described by (C1) and (C3) with $\kappa =0.17$ and $\kappa '=0.17$, respectively. The dashed red curve in (b) has a slope of $-7/4$ and passes approximately through the $R=4$ data (grey circles).

Jing et al. Supplementary Movie 1

Vertical position of an intruder particle vs. time (left panel) and the corresponding animation (right panel) showing the intruder (red) and its contacting (blue) and non-contacting (grey) neighboring bed particles in an annular region around the intruder. The intruder has the same size and density as the bed particles ($R=1$ and $R_\rho=1$). The flow conditions are $P_0=1000\ \textrm{Pa}$ and $\dot\gamma_0=10\ \textrm{s}^{-1}$ ($I=0.08$), and the drag force (or, equivalently, the external driving force) is $F_d/P_0d_i^2=0.05$. Note the significant fluctuations and intermittency of the intruder position due to particle collisions at this small driving force.

Download Jing et al. Supplementary Movie 1(Video)
Video 1.8 MB

Jing et al. Supplementary Movie 2

Same as movie 1 except that $F_d/P_0d_i^2=5$. Note that cavity formation occurs in the wake of the red intruder particle and that the contacts (with blue bed particles) are concentrated at the leading edge of the intruder.

Download Jing et al. Supplementary Movie 2(Video)
Video 2.2 MB

Jing et al. Supplementary Movie 3

Same as movie 2 except that $R=4$ and that the flow conditions are $P_0=1000\ \textrm{Pa}$ and $\dot\gamma_0=20\ \textrm{s}^{-1}$ ($I=0.16$).

Download Jing et al. Supplementary Movie 3(Video)
Video 4.4 MB