What do you get when you accompany an eclectic assortment of Ghanaian musicians, including a virtuoso drummer well-known in jazz circles who also served as a government spy; a non-Rastafarian ‘Rastaman’ who holds great affinity for John Coltrane and Pan-African politics; a working-class drummer who comfortably performs Ga ritual musics, local popular styles, and jazz rhythms on his self-made ‘African Percussion Kit’; and, a group of bus and truck drivers who use squeeze-bulb horns to honor their departed colleagues, and nicknames (personal and vehicular) to proclaim their connection to the United States, on a reflective journey about jazz's status as a form of musical intimacy? If your guide is Steven Feld, you get a remarkable look into the uneven terrain of cosmopolitanism, the value of listening carefully to personal narratives, and the genealogies of power at play in a modern African city. Jazz Cosmopolitanism is a lively and important book, one that uses the vehicles of dialogue and sound to unearth the complex cultural and political dynamics that connect a group of urban Africans to the diaspora and wider world. It is a fun, invigorating, and worthwhile read.
As its title suggests, the book documents Feld's engagement with jazz cosmopolitanism in Accra over a five-year period (2005–10). But instead of presenting or analyzing its findings in a conventional fashion, the book employs a combination of memoir, ethnography, and storytelling, and privileges the subjective experiences of Feld's Accra interlocutors. The majority of the book consists of what Feld labels ‘encounter stories’ – potent vignettes of his and others’ intimacy and entanglement with the intertwined worlds of music, spirituality, and politics. In encouraging the reader to listen to and contemplate such tales – rather than the accompanying academic literature (which gets its appropriate due in the expansive endnotes) – he successfully conveys how cosmopolitanism is not merely an abstract domain of belonging, but an encounter with variety, irony, and unsettling contradictions. At the same time, he also gives the reader unparalleled access to how a cohort of little-known Ghanaian musicians navigate these complexities in ways that enable them to claim authority, remember past events, and impart knowledge to those around them.
The book's wide-ranging first chapter presents the characters who populate these encounter stories, discusses jazz's influence and importance within Accra's soundscape, and invokes the merits of conceptualizing cosmopolitanism through sound and ‘from below’. The next four chapters (‘choruses’) focus upon the exploits of individual musicians. The first covers the musical life of Kofi Ghanaba, an outspoken drummer who was a central figure not only in the history of Ghanaian highlife music, but also the politics of mid-twentieth century jazz, the commercialization of ‘African’ music, and the racial dynamics that underlined each. The second and third focus on Nii Noi Nortey and Nii Otoo Annan, musicians Feld first met during their attempt to record a tribute to John Coltrane's A Love Supreme. When read side-by-side, these chapters show how class fissures impact not only the musicians’ respective histories of musical absorption, but also their attempts to wade through cosmopolitanism's currents. The fourth chorus covers the por por ensemble of Accra's la Drivers Union and unveils how its members use names, sounds, and ritual and material symbols to claim influence within and beyond Accra. The book's robust conclusion offers up an additional set of intriguing stories (the most notable of which concern Ghana's 1957 independence), as well as reflections on musical intimacy, the interplay between local and transnational forces, and the limits of nationalist narratives.
As the book's opening pages note, Feld has produced a trilogy of DVDs and 11 CDs that feature the performances and conversations referenced in its pages. While Jazz Cosmopolitanism in Accra makes effective use of dialogue, image, and story to convey its conclusions, there are moments when having access to these multimedia accompaniments would provide an even richer experience. Watching the first film, for example, left this reader fully in awe of Ghanaba's personality, cosmopolitan ethos, and rendition of Handel's ‘Hallelujah’ chorus (discussed at length on pages 33–7 and 75–81). Such materials are by no means an indispensable accompaniment but I suspect that many will want to seek them out so that they can immerse themselves in the wonders that Feld has done us the favor of documenting. All told, Jazz Cosmopolitanism is a book that continues to resonate when finally put down. I highly recommend picking it up.
