Much like their earlier work on local grassroots democracy (Rebecca Abers) and environmental activism (Margaret Keck), this book provides a rich, historically grounded account of the development of a distinctive type of politics in Brazil—in this case, the institutional politics around water management. But also as in their earlier work, Abers and Keck manage to successfully inflect this context-sensitive account with much more general theoretical importance. While the very concept of “water management” sounds technical, they illuminate the high politics of water in Brazil and reveal how the control of water becomes a complex and innovative arena for the negotiation of state–society relations. Exploring the creation and development of river basin committees, Practical Authority helps us understand both the limits and the possibilities for participatory forums of policymaking and implementation.
The book begins with the authors’ announcement of their sense of surprise as they learned to decipher the complexity of Brazilian water politics. While landmark legislation envisioned a new integrative form of water management that would give a new role to civil society, neither the legislation nor subsequent state policy provided guidance or support to implement this new vision. Abers and Keck were originally interested in the ways in which the river basin committees authorized by the law would function as participatory forums. To their surprise, a more fundamental and interesting issue was why, in the first place, these committees evolved in such different directions. In some cases, the committees never got off the ground; in others, they took off, only to become moribund later; still others developed gradually, building momentum through time.
As their investigation deepened, the authors focused on the institution-building process in these river basin committees and how it interacted with the wider political environment. The central concept that they develop to interpret this process is what they call “practical authority.” In the relative vacuum of formal authority, river basin committees had to create a legitimate claim to govern. Abers and Keck find that successful committees did this by developing a capacity and reputation for problem solving, by building relational social capital between different groups, and by avoiding political contestation during their formative period. These committees achieved practical authority when they became recognized as having a legitimate and rightful role in making water resource decisions. This kind of institution building depended on creative and skilled leadership, as well as active experimentation, and was ultimately an ongoing process and a contingent achievement. Changing politics, leadership succession, or the decline of problem-solving capacity could lead to a reversal of fortune and the loss of practical authority.
As Abers and Keck explain, Brazil’s particular path of democratization turned it into a crucible of experimentation with participatory modes of democracy. They began their research intrigued with the participatory potential of river basin committees, and their research does indeed demonstrate that a wide variety of groups—including local, state, and federal agencies, environmental groups, universities, and business interests—participate in the most active river basin committees. However, their view of these committees as vehicles of civic engagement was tempered by the nature of the political process they encountered. “Greater numbers of participants,” they write, “do not necessarily make a policy more democratic, either in the sense of who decides or who benefits” (p. 196). While clearly expanding the number of groups engaged in water policy, the river basin committees have not functioned particularly well as representative bodies. Instead, they appear to represent the groups who have invested in building the committees as institutions.
I would like to have learned more about the limits of the river basin committees as participatory and representative bodies. From their discussion, I infer that these bodies function more like what might be called “policy networks” than they do like the participatory fora conjured up by Porto Alegre’s famous experiment in participatory budgeting. Yet the authors have clearly made the choice here that what river basin management tells us about everyday politics and institution building is more interesting than what it tells us about democracy. For Abers and Keck, the institutional and political evolution that they trace speaks fundamentally to wider debates concerning how we conceptualize institutional change.
The authors begin their analysis by describing the setting in which institutional change occurs, which they characterize as one of institutional entanglement. Brazil, they observe, has become a “complex network of overlapping institutions and contradictory political traditions” (p. 20). This entanglement produces a complex ecology of both constraint and opportunity. As partially described here, successful political action and institutional change in this ecology require the construction of practical authority. To achieve this, political actors must navigate what they call routes through entanglement (p. 23)—basically, strategic pathways allowing groups of political actors to combine and mobilize support and resources for a particular political project.
Abers and Keck describe two strategic pathways that river basin actors utilized to successfully create practical authority. The first was to “find spaces of action in the interstices of contending power structures, where they can build capabilities and recognition at a small scale” (p. 23). To do this, river basin actors engaged in experimentation to address concrete water management problems. These experiments were small in scale and, hence, avoided political contestation. Critically, however, the early results of these experiments reinforced collective action and produced capacity and experience. This mode of action can gradually attract wider participation and can lead to a more ambitious agenda. However, this strategy depends on what they call a “politics of perseverance” (p. 143)—the perseverance to slowly accumulate capacity and experience.
A second strategic pathway is to exploit the wider institutional ecology for support. They identify three mechanisms that river basin actors used to do this—bricolage, hedging, and scale shifting. River basin actors had to be, in the first place, bricoleurs—that is, they had to creatively appropriate resources from their environment that were not expressly designed for the purposes of river basin management. They also engaged in risk hedging by simultaneously working through multiple institutional channels and pushing their agenda forward wherever they could. And, as necessary, these actors also shifted scales of action. If blocked on one institutional level, they shifted their attention and energy to another level. What bricolage, hedging, and scale shifting have in common is that they enable actors to creatively turn entanglement into a resource.
The overall pattern of institution building might be described as emergent. Practical authority emerges over time through an accumulation of capacity and recognition built by means of positive feedbacks from successful small-scale experimentation. This authority is then scaled up by exploiting the opportunities that emerge through the skillful and creative exploration of the wider ecology. As noted in many places throughout the book, there is nothing deterministic about emergent institution building. It is characterized by upsets and reversals and complex temporality. By showing us how to study this process of dynamic institutional change, the book breaks new ground. It has wide implications for comparative politics, institutionalism, and policy studies.
