Colish's book is a study of the four treatises of Ambrose of Milan on the patriarchs Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and Joseph. Scholarly interest in these texts has often focused rather narrowly on Quellenforschung, and the assessment of how creative or otherwise Ambrose's exegesis of Genesis is in view of his Jewish and Christian archetypes (especially Philo and Origen). Such appraisals have varied widely, with Ambrose emerging as everything from dexterous artist to inept plagiarist. Where exegetical sources have been less in the frame, particular attention has been paid to Ambrose's philosophical ideas and what they imply about his intellectual sophistication and his overall attitude towards the saeculum. How Platonist, how Stoic is Ambrose, and what does the conceptual fabric of his moralising suggest about the cultural stance of Latin Christianity in the late fourth century? What is very frequently missing in such approaches is the effort to situate Ambrose's thought in the particularities of his social context in the northern Italy of the 380s. Colish is concerned to make good this deficiency by asking specifically what the life-setting of the patriarchal treatises indicates about Ambrose's strategies as a pastor.
The heart of Colish's case is that Ambrose's treatments of the patriarchs were intended in the first instance for Milanese competentes, catechumens who were taking the final steps of initiation into the church. She maintains that Ambrose's expositions derive from Lenten sermons delivered to these people, instructing them on the ethical entailments of baptism and the significance of the new identity they were about to assume. By appealing to the examples of the patriarchs in particular, Ambrose exhorts his addressees to appreciate that they are being incorporated into an ancient lineage stretching all the way back to Abraham – henceforth they are to be Romans with new maiores and a new fatherland in spiritual Israel. His counsel of moderation assumes an anthropology and an account of the passions that is a creative synthesis of a wide range of influences – biblical, Stoic and Aristotelian – and certainly not a simplistic clothing of Platonist or Neoplatonist ideas in Christian garb. Soul and body alike are involved in the business of virtue, sharing in certain temptations while differing in others. In setting out the principles by which fallen yet graced humanity may deal with these dangers, and illustrating such commitment in the lives of the biblical heroes, Ambrose presents his catechumens with a very practical image of self-control. While his moral standards are high, he calls here not for extremes of asceticism or detachment from society but for a rational application of biblical principles in daily life, sustained all the while only by divine enabling and by the fellowship of the church. The virtues of this calling are indeed radical by worldly standards, but they can be pursued in the midst of social and political responsibilities rather than in abstraction from them.
Colish's discussion is predictably well informed on the intellectual legacies with which Ambrose operates. In delineating Ambrose's portrayal of the passions and his attitude towards the body, she acknowledges both his obvious debts to philosophy and his genuine immersion in scripture. As one would expect from a distinguished scholar, there is none of the facile oversimplification of cultural capital that has so bedevilled the understanding of patristic authors. While treating the four texts as a group (Cassiodorus and at least some of Ambrose's manuscript traditions) Colish pays due attention to their individual characteristics. De Abraham contains a less developed anthropology than De Isaac or De Jacob (especially book 1), and De Ioseph tends to celebrate its subject's excellences as a narrative that is compelling in its own right (Joseph the clear type of Christ) rather than as one that needs to be punctuated with so many explicit injunctions to flee immorality or practise temperance.
The weak point of the book, however, is this: Colish does not devote anything like enough space to the defence of the claim that the patriarchal treatises have to belong in origin where she assumes they do; as a result, she considerably overstates the extent to which the vision that Ambrose offers can possibly be called an ‘ethics for the common man’. The inference that these texts derive from sermons delivered in a catechetical context may very well be sound, but Colish simply adopts it from the late nineteenth-century editor, Karl Schenkl (p. 9), and thereafter assumes a very high degree of specificity as to the identity of Ambrose's addressees, with extremely little explicit justification in the texts themselves. Scholars do of course know quite a lot more these days than was once the case about the social dynamics of ancient congregations, but great care is necessary in extrapolating specific patterns from one context to another, and Colish offers almost no argument in support of claims that are basic to her whole thesis. Nor is there any consideration of whether or not reworked published homilies necessarily envisage just the same sort of constituency as their original audiences. A large part of Colish's case hangs upon the contention that the patriarchal treatises offer an ethics that is aimed at lay people rather than clergy or ascetics, but she does not ask whether intended readerships may be far more fluid than that. Despite what she assumes, there is no reason to suppose that a text such as De officiis, which is of course designed for clerics in particular, does not anticipate a lay reception as well; it is similarly precarious to assume that the patriarchs (who are of course expounded very widely indeed in Ambrose's corpus as a whole) are held up in this case for the benefit of ‘ordinary’ initiates as distinct from other believers.
And who were these initiates? Adult converts from paganism, we are told, from a variety of backgrounds, but including (not least, it seems) male heads of households, ‘men who played varied roles in civic as well as domestic and economic life’; they were likely to have been ‘relatively wealthy’ and ‘well educated’ (p. 17). To say, without further ado, that what such people receive is an ethics for the ‘common man’, and that Ambrose thus scores ‘a first, in patristic literature’ (p. 157), begs very large questions about the nature of late Roman society, its conceptions of status, wealth and class, and how meaningful it is to employ the appeal of egalitarian practicality in a social context that was considerably more complex than these designations may suggest. Ambrose's morality was indeed intended to be practised; the identities of the hearers and readers he had in mind require further study.
