Sir Hugh Clifford, governor of the Gold Coast Colony from 1912–19, was fortunate that his biographer, H. A. Gailey, was ‘in awe of the many abilities displayed by Clifford’ and considered him ‘to have been an example of the best Britain offered to govern her subject peoples’.Footnote 8 Elizabeth Wrangham covers only a relatively short span of Clifford's career, but also finds much to admire in this ‘humane’ and dynamic colonial governor (p. xxiv). Nevertheless, she argues for some ‘reappraisal’ of what she sees as Gailey's ‘uncritical judgment’ (p. xxiii). Most of Sir Clifford's governorship coincided with the economic disruptions of the First World War, which limited his ability to pursue his modernizing developmental policies for the colony. The high expectations that he had stimulated on his arrival in the Gold Coast were inevitably disappointed. Wrangham sees this period as ‘not merely the chronological halfway point in the colonial history of the Gold Coast … but represents a pivotal discontinuity … for in the long term the additional impact of the interwar depression and another world war increased frustration, undermined legitimacy, and led to the mass demand in the late 1940s not merely for reform, but for an independent African government’ (p. xxvi).
One can undoubtedly quibble over how seminal the First World War was in the development of Ghanaian nationalism. Had Sir Hugh Clifford's plans been realized they might well have accelerated the twentieth-century revolution of rising expectations and enhanced demands for more African advancement in the colony, rather than muting protest. More important is Wrangham's use of the Clifford governorship to challenge what Antony Hopkins has described as ‘the widespread adoption of stereotypes that reduce colonial policies and the colonial presence in general to acts of oppression … and imply that colonial subjects were helpless victims’ (pp. xii–xiii).
The author confronts the legacy of Walter Rodney, in the work of Rhoda Howard, who argued that the British aimed to keep colonies such as the Gold Coast within the capitalist periphery. In describing the development of the cocoa industry before the war, Wrangham goes to considerable lengths to show how unique it was. It is a well-known story of African initiative with minimal administrative involvement. She also tells, in some detail, the less well-known story of African initiative in road building to accommodate the light Ford trucks that were to revolutionize transport in the colony. Unlike the railroad construction that Governor Clifford felt was essential for developing the colony, but which languished during the war years, ‘the main network of “motorised” roads, built just before and then during the war, was constructed by Africans’ (pp. 151–2).
Nor did British officials always agree among themselves. For example, she shows that Governor Clifford was a staunch opponent of the residential segregation policy for European officials that the Colonial Office accepted as necessary to preserve European health in the mosquito-infested tropics. Wrangham is also willing to cross swords with those whom she sees as having taken untenable positions on less sweeping issues than the nature of colonial rule. She comes to the defense of the director of agriculture, W. S. D. Tudhope, who ‘might have been unrealistic in his belief that the government had the means to enforce regulations for the cocoa industry’, but contends that this was never a ‘sustained campaign’ against the cocoa industry, as G. B. Kay has suggested in Political Economy of Colonialism in Ghana 1900–1960.
Unfortunately, she does allow to stand, and indeed supports, the much-beloved stereotype, dear to academics of all stripes, of the ‘near complete failure on the part of colonial officials to understand the workings of the African societies they sought to administer’ (p. xiv). Undoubtedly colonial officials lacked the theoretical understanding of African societies that academic research has provided, but administrative contact with subject people provided them with invaluable insights into the functioning of these societies. Their understanding of African societies was far better than contemporary Africanists have been willing to concede.
In general, Wrangham's meticulous mining of both the primary and secondary sources puts her in a strong position to challenge the stereotypical theories she opposes by providing us with a detailed account of the difficulties the colony faced during the First World War. Her ‘empirical approach to achieve a wider knowledge of the financial and economic basis of imperialism as seen in one particular British African colony’ is something of a long overdue wind of change in the writing of colonial history. Perhaps in this course correction it is time to approach the history of some of the less glamourous governors. Sir Ransford Slater and Sir Shenton Thomas were probably too short-serving for such attention, but Sir Arnold Hodson, who followed the latter and served for about as long as Sir Hugh Clifford (1934–41) spanned a period in Ghana's colonial past that was undoubtedly more significant for the development of nationalism in the colony and that coincided with part of the highly disrupting period of the Second World War. Primary sources are more copious than for the First World War years, and would provide compelling evidence to test general theories and assumptions about the character of British colonial rule. Ironically, this remains the period in Ghanaian colonial history with the greatest lacunae.
It is unfortunate to end a review of such a commendable piece of scholarship on a sour note, but the index to this otherwise attractively presented monograph leaves much to be desired. All too often subject headings do not coincide with page references. On one occasion the reference is to a blank page!
