Handbooks of research have become standard reference books in many disciplines, including education and music education. The two handbooks of research on music teaching and learning (Colwell, Reference COLWELL1992; Colwell & Richardson, Reference COLWELL and RICHARDSON2002) provide a synthesis of research on a variety of topics and issues in music education and they are a valuable source for scholars and researchers internationally. Up to this point, research on teaching and learning in the various arts disciplines has not been presented in one publication, so allowing for cross-fertilisation of ideas, enrichment of modes of inquiry, and identification of common issues with implications for interdisciplinary research agendas. In her bold and visionary step forward in the International Handbook of Research in Arts Education, editor Liora Bresler set out to identify research agendas and issues across the arts and to define a new relationship among disciplines that are naturally related outside of the academy. In reviewing the two volumes, I will begin with some introductory comments, then provide brief descriptions of each section and end with some general observations of the significance of the Handbook. My own research interests drew me particularly to the sections on history, social and cultural issues, and spirituality, although I present an overview of all 13 sections.
A central theme that Bresler brings to the Handbook is the need to create a new dialogue that allows for and facilitates ‘softening the boundaries’ (Detels, 1999, cited on p. xvii) between the arts and enlarges the vision of the arts in education. Thus, the Handbook is a landmark publication and an important contribution to the literature in arts education as well as in each of the individual arts represented in the volumes – dance, drama, literature, media, music, and the visual arts. Bresler identifies two related functions of the Handbook – to synthesise existing scholarship in each arts discipline and help direct its future course; and second, to facilitate cross-fertilisation and communication among the arts and thus advance inquiry and scholarship (p. xix).
The Handbook has many unique characteristics and noteworthy accomplishments, among them commitment to international perspectives, inclusion of a comprehensive range of established and emerging topics and issues, diversity in the 116 authors who contribute to the work, attention to arts disciplines often underrepresented in the research endeavour such as drama and dance, location of topics in rich theoretical frameworks, and the artistic nature of the book's organisation. The Handbook is divided into two volumes, Part 1 and Part 2, and organised into 13 sections which address a broad range of major areas in arts education, some that are established in the research literature of at least some arts subjects – appreciation, assessment and evaluation, child culture, composition, creativity, curriculum, history, social and cultural issues, and technology, and others that represent emerging fields of inquiry – the body, museums and cultural centres, informal learning, and spirituality.
As a historian of music education, I came to the first section on History, edited by Gordon Cox, with particular curiosity and respect for the task. Examining the history of art education through mapping coordinates and drawing on Bourdieu's theory enriches possible ways to approach historical study across the arts. In his chapter on music education history, Cox expands traditional boundaries by looking at a variety of transmission contexts—family, church and school. The focus on social history in dance education again highlights the need to move beyond the school for a meaningful historical narrative of any art form. The call for ‘more histories written from different perspectives, with different methodologies and focus’ (Buck, p. 119) is a call that applies to historical research in all arts subjects in order to more fully describe the contributions of arts education to society.
Determining boundaries is identified by Susan Stinson, editor of Section 2 on Curriculum, as a challenge for all authors of her section, and of the Handbook in general. The international commentaries in this section (Africa, Lebanon, Hong Kong, Spain, Scandinavia, Jordan, Israel, New Zealand, Namibia, South Africa, Greece, Japan and Switzerland) were diverse and particularly revealing when considered in the context of the chapters and interludes written by authors primarily from Australia, Canada and the USA. This section would make an excellent set of readings for a course on curriculum development in any of the arts disciplines. One chapter is offered on arts integration and it could be argued that it deserves an entire section, pushing the boundaries, as the authors do in this one chapter, to challenge readers to move into new interdisciplinary terrain, both across the arts and with other related disciplines.
In Section 3 on Assessment and Evaluation, editors Regina Murphy and Magne Espeland identify ‘some of the main dilemmas posed in assessing and evaluating the arts in educational contexts’ (p. 337) as those involved in connecting the two concepts of assessment and evaluation, process and product, nonverbal activity and verbal expression, and what is assessed with learning in the art form. These dilemmas bring unity to the section and highlight the issues that teachers confront in assessing and evaluating the arts cross-culturally. Composition (Section 4) is treated separately from Creativity (Section 11), and summarised by editor Sarah McCarthey under three themes: use of metaphor, composing as a dialogue between the individual and the social, and composing as a process. Both interludes by Keith Swanwick and Michael Parsons focus on the use and power of metaphor, creating for the reader a dialogue with the content of the chapters.
In some arts education contexts, the term ‘Appreciation’ (Section 5) is seldom used in curriculum frameworks. Section editor Margaret Barrett presents the topic in a new light with expanded meanings, as ‘not restricted to the “merely contemplative” and the traditional roles of participation’, but as something that can also arise ‘through informed engagement with the arts as art-maker, as performer, and creator’ (p. 567). This is borne out in an exposition of dance literacy as part of ‘an intertwined panoply of literacies that help us know ourselves, negotiate our lives, and understand the world around us’ (p. 578); an approach to valuing music appreciation from philosophical, psychological and sociological perspectives; an approach to visual art appreciation that includes nature, empathy, ethics, artifacts of many kinds, or appreciation and lifelong engagement with art.
A section on Museums and Cultural Centres (Section 6), edited by Elizabeth Vallance, introduces new areas of exploration and inquiry and represents one of the unique contributions of the Handbook. In a sense, the section is a bridge to subsequent sections on Informal Learning (Section 7) and Child Culture (Section 8), edited by Minette Mans and Christine Marmé Thompson, respectively. In her magnificent planning of the chapter sequence, Bresler leads the reader from inside the school context out into other public and private institutional settings where the arts are transmitted, and then to informal contexts located in culture. Honouring the culture of the child receives deserved attention and deliberation. Given the scope of research on this topic, it is curious that more international commentaries were not included.
Section 9 on Social and Cultural Issues is timely and a welcome addition to the literature. The editors, Doug Risner and Tracie Costantino situate the chapters theoretically and conceptually in the expansive canvas of social and cultural theory. Beyond the issues one might expect in this section – intersections of the arts with gender, race, social class, and equity – the section contains an especially powerful exposition of ideas on conflict, war and peace in the arts and the challenges such realities bring to the teaching–learning context and also the meanings that can emerge from such engagement.
Kimberly Powell opens the prelude to Section 10 on The Body with, ‘The body in arts education – and education in general – has been largely still’ (p. 1083). She closes the prelude stating that ‘new conceptions of the body brought about through innovative research will significantly reshape arts curriculum and pedagogy’ (p. 1086). The authors in this section, including Powell herself, have expanded conceptions of the body in relation to the arts through their thoughtful, innovative contributions to the Handbook.
As editor for Section 11 on Creativity, Burnard writes in the prelude that authors are concerned with ‘understanding the complex processes of creativity, not measuring them’ (p. 1177). This noble aim is approached by rethinking the nature of creativity, rekindling debates about certain aspects of creativity, all with the goal of restoring the place of the arts in the curriculum based on an expanded appreciation of the role and value of creativity in the curriculum. Section 12 on Technology is led by Peter Webster who engages all elements of teaching and learning to advance the dialogue– knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values. He concludes that ‘questions about technology in arts have much to do with fundamentally good teaching’ (p. 1295). The interplay of ideas and knowledge between and among individual arts disciplines in this section is striking.
The final section on Spirituality is also striking – an unprecedented step by Bresler to move an area that has been gaining power in other disciplines such as general education from the periphery to the centre of arts education. This represents a fitting close to a handbook that seeks to expand boundaries and cross borders into heretofore unexplored spaces. Section editor Rita Irwin approaches the topic from the viewpoint of people ‘longing for more meaning in their lives and in their educational pursuits’ (p. 1401). By ‘plumbing the depths of being fully alive’ through an education of the soul, she argues that we can expand arts education ‘beyond the rational and analytic ways of understanding the world’ to embrace ‘intuitive and emotional ways of knowing’, conceived through mindful and spiritual presences in arts teaching and learning (p. 1401).
The final chapter of the Spirituality section and of the Handbook itself includes in its title the phrase ‘spiritual ecology’. I observed a spiritual ecology and sensed a strong aesthetic permeating the book, achieved in several ways: the artistic nature of the structure and organisation, with each section including a prelude, chapters, international commentaries, and interludes that often bring the reader into spaces that evoke deep spiritual resonances; Bresler's commitment to ‘the living presence of art’ (xix); and the visual images that set each section in motion. The book's organisation has the effect of creating a balance of perspective, a beauty of form, and a variety of communication media and literary forms. On the title pages of each section, visual artist Jana Mason created a set of black and white images around the theme of stone – stone circles, dolmen-like structures, and imaginative arrangements that are more abstract. Each reader will interpret these differently; for me, they evoked thoughts about the powerful and stable presence of the arts in life, their role in human culture from the beginning, the extraordinary beauty of ordinary things, and the need for solidarity among those who seek to advance the role of the arts in education. A reflective Interlude titled, ‘Astonished by a Stone: Art and the Eloquence of Matter,’ by David Abram (pp. 1137–42), serves as an engaging literary companion for these images; whether Bresler planned this piece in relation to the images is unknown, but it adds to the surprises that surface as one navigates this creative opus.
The interludes in themselves deserve separate commentary, as their distinguished authors move us to rethink the boundaries of the individual arts disciplines, to open up to the spaces in between them, beneath and across them, around them. It is there that Bresler wants the reader to go, to dwell in, and to be transformed by the musings, reflections, ruminations, and sometimes provocations of these author-artists. The intellectual weight of the volumes is humbling. I do not know of another publication that includes this combination of authors in conversation about arts education in the same forum – Jerome Bruner, Richard Colwell, Elliot Eisner, Maxine Greene, Bruno Nettl, Bennett Reimer, Robert Stake, and the many others whose names I would want to list if space allowed. In that sense, the Handbook is an historic document, bringing to life in an extraordinary manner a narrative of arts education that includes some of the most distinguished voices from the period spanning the late twentieth and early twenty-first century. And throughout these and other authors’ writings, the voice of John Dewey is a living presence as his gems of wisdom are interwoven in several conversations to inform dialogue across the softening boundaries of the arts disciplines.
In what Bresler calls a ‘huge mosaic’ of themes and topics from a range of artistic domains, what was omitted? Bresler addresses the decision to leave out teacher education, policy and research methodologies. Other topics that might have found a place in such a publication are special education, arts and therapy, and popular culture, although they surface in relation to topics in some sections. Most readers come to the handbook from one particular discipline and it is instructive to learn the focus and status of research in other arts areas.
In a project this ambitious and a vision this far-reaching, globally and intellectually, Bresler and her section editors and authors have given the arts professions and academies an astounding work of high artistic and intellectual merit. It is the professions’ responsibility to spread the word, to get volumes into the libraries of all arts and general education disciplines, to use sections of the Handbook as foundational reading for pre-service and in-service coursework, and to encourage the cross-fertilization of ideas that is made possible by the book's content. To ‘soften’ and expand the boundaries of each discipline and to create dialogue across disciplines may lead to expanded professional identities for arts educators and a new collective consciousness and commitment to arts education.
