Covering Spain, New Spain and New Granada, Fatal Love examines spousal homicide and its adjudication at the end of the colonial era. In this multi-site study, Victor M. Uribe-Uran not only meticulously tracks trends in these conflicts across time and space, but points to a change in public and institutional conceptions of punishment within the Spanish Empire that diverges from the trajectory Michel Foucault put forward for France.
The book begins with a thorough overview of the expansive corpus of legal texts – from the medieval Siete Partidas up to nineteenth-century law codes – that informed litigants, lawyers and judges. Uribe-Uran then moves to examine how subaltern groups fared within the criminal courts of the Spanish Atlantic through a breakdown of spousal homicide cases in New Spain. Relying on the seminal work of William Taylor, Uribe-Uran draws important contrasts between homicides in general and those among spouses, paying attention to time, place, method and identities of the culprit. After addressing trends within the sample, the author notes the high indigenous representation, the way the courts perceived these perpetrators, and the questions this raises for understanding gender and ethnicity in court cases.
Chapter 3 points out the discriminatory attributes of the legal system in the Spanish Atlantic. Rather than that local practice diverged from law and tradition, Uribe-Uran argues that biases along gender, ethnic and other lines flowed from a longer legal tradition. Much of the chapter highlights ways the severity of spousal homicide could be softened. Due to a defendant's status as a menor, as in the case of Indians, or because their inebriated state left them without their full faculties, the courts provided leniency at times for those who killed their spouses. The book then transitions away from Mexico to a case study of Bourbon Spain. These Iberian cases again confirm that social practice diverged far from the stereotypes of passive, submissive, weak women and macho men committing vengeance killings to defend their honour.
Though the book opens by speculating on the broader theories around the transition to ‘civilised’ punishment, Chapter 5 focuses mainly on the absence of punishment, with much of the chapter dedicated to how criminals might avoid it altogether. The practice of sanctuary (asilo), whereby criminals could seek refuge in church, provided spousal murderers with a means to draw out legal proceedings and sometimes even escape retribution. Uribe-Uran traces this process back to Constantine and up through the medieval era, and demonstrates its continued use even into the nineteenth century on both sides of the Atlantic. We also find that those convicted of spousal homicide and sentenced could have their punishments reduced or eliminated through a number of pardon programmes.
The book then turns to its case study of New Granada, addressing what the chapter title refers to as ‘Dangerous Women’. After a robust description of the local context, Uribe-Uran points to trends in this locale, giving significant attention to the higher concentration of women as spousal killers. The ultimate contribution of this chapter, however, is to reassess the extent to which domesticity for women remained the norm in colonial society. Records reveal the high frequency of conflicts that arose from public interactions outside the home, which for Uribe-Uran demonstrates the myth of the domestic woman archetype. This reader wonders, however, what the author's explanation is for such extra-domestic activity resulting in such severe social and legal disruption.
The text shifts back to a discussion centred on change over time. Rather than moving away from a focus on the body and spectacle, Spanish punishment remained concerned with the corporeal and its public reach, even if the practices themselves softened. While also tracing the application of torture and the death penalty, the most persuasive examples come in the new application of arrastramiento (dragging the culprit through the streets) and encubamiento (sealing the culprit alive in a leather bag with a monkey, a cockerel, a snake and a dog). Close attention to trends in punishment also demonstrates the way indigenous litigants were most likely to avoid the full brunt of imperial justice, while other subalterns were likely to see the harshest of penalties. Moving into the Independence era, Uribe-Uran notes the codification of new forms of punishment that clearly build on Enlightenment ideals growing increasingly popular at the time. But the pre-Independence history presented throughout the book shows that such changes – in practice, if not etched in the legal corpus – predate liberal reforms and are drawn from more localised values.
The book provides plenty for both the ‘trees’ and the ‘forest’ reader. Detailed case studies throughout the middle of the book take the reader as close to the archive as possible. Nearly every variable within the cases is described and charted. Indeed, any scholar planning to visit these collections must consult this book first. The Preface and latter chapters allow for a longer look at the history of the Spanish Atlantic and its subtle changes that include, but are not limited to, the trying and punishing of spousal killers.
Tangential to the important contributions to our understanding of domestic violence, the law and the late empire, the book deserves praise also for its vast bibliography. Chapter 1, in particular, would be a vital introduction to scholars new to early modern Spanish and canon law, but seasoned scholars are also likely to be directed to unexplored legal sources within the endnotes. The inclusion of the original Spanish and the English translation of most quotations from the cases makes this evidence intelligible for outside readers, and transparent and rich for Spanish/Latin American specialists, allowing this work to reach a wide audience.
