Economic history is an underdeveloped discipline in Middle Eastern historiography. Within our field, economic history articles are not published often, and books on economic history are rare. It is true that certain topics have been better explored than others, as Maya Shatzmiller's contribution to this roundtable on medieval economic history shows. Previous scholarship on Ottoman economic history has focused on land tenure, fiscal practices and institutions, artisanal production and organization (almost exclusively in urban areas), economic and charitable functions of awqāf, and, especially for the 19th century, questions relevant to Ottoman incorporation into the capitalist world system. There also exist studies on urban and rural markets, regional and long-distance trade networks, and economic activities of specific individuals (primarily government officials and provincial notables), although these tend to be descriptive. But there are very limited numbers of studies on standards of living; levels, accumulation, and distribution of wealth; productivity in agricultural production and manufacture; demography (especially for the 17th and 18th centuries); credit relations and financial institutions; and economic development. As in the literature on medieval Islamic contexts, sophisticated quantitative research is particularly rare, which makes empirically based comparisons among different parts of the region and with other parts of the world very difficult.Footnote 1
A main reason for the problem is the scarcity of historical sources, especially for the premodern period.Footnote 2 In addition, one wonders if there is a general suspicion in the field toward economic and quantified research. To demonstrate this tendency, let us read what Zouhair Ghazzal wrote about Establet and Pascual's quantitative analysis of Damascene estate inventories in a book review for IJMES:
Having bypassed the textual analysis of individual documents, Establet and Pascual create an enormous problem of contextualization of all their material: each fact is first torn from its original source document (the “context”), then assigned as a variable to a database field, and finally associated within a broader statistical pattern or regularity. In such an approach, it is the broader statistical regularity rather than the document itself that creates the context for the fact.Footnote 3
According to Ghazzal, the main problem with Establet and Pascual's efforts to quantitatively analyze estate inventories is that this methodology is innately unsuitable for the sources.
Establet and Pascual confront each document with an a priori agenda and with categories that did not emerge from a questioning of probate records. Thus, for example, tarikāt records were obviously not drafted by judges and their scribes in order to keep track of currency fluctuations, or the age of deceased individuals, or their sex and occupation for that matter. Our two historians decide on an a priori basis and in a line of reasoning exterior to the documents themselves that such questions and statistical categories are essential for an understanding of these societies [emphasis in original].Footnote 4
In Ghazzal's view, the documents themselves should determine the nature and methods of historical inquiry. Research that focuses on topics “external” to documents or uses them in ways for which they were not intended often assumes too much and/or ignores a multitude of historical factors by focusing on a few select variables.Footnote 5 Yet a historian who truly deserves that label should know how to read the documents properly, and in their suitable contexts, and should take upon him/herself the responsibility of defending them against what he considers to be reductionist and misleading readings.Footnote 6
Economic analysis of estate inventories, a popular research orientation in Western history writing, is relatively scarce and rudimentary in our field, despite the fact that these sources are available in large numbers for many Ottoman milieus. I suspect that the prevalence of attitudes reflected in Ghazzal's opinion of Establet and Pascual's work is partially responsible for this dearth of scholarship,Footnote 7 not only on estate inventories but also on other sources that could be quantifiable and/or used for the purposes of social sciences type of research.Footnote 8 Historians tend to be what their sources force them to be. The fact that the work of Ottomanists is usually based on state-produced, legal, and bureaucratic documentation not only leads them to produce state-centric narrativesFootnote 9 but also compels them to become, first and foremost, legal and bureaucratic specialists with corresponding skills and sensitivities. Thus, the call by a legal specialist to read estate inventories primarily as legal documents is reflective of the dominant attitude in the field. Granted, the opportunity cost for a historian to acquire the skills associated with social sciences can be considerable. Nevertheless, as long as Middle East historians remain aloof to tools and approaches developed for social sciences (and as long as economists with genuine historical concerns lack the skills to conduct primary historical research), we should assume that the legalistic and bureaucratic tendencies will remain hegemonic.
The previous observations do not directly engage Ghazzal's claims relating to appropriate forms of historical analysis, claims that promote a debilitating, historicist orientation.Footnote 10 Even if we agree to ascribe an original intent to historical documents (a big if), then this position assumes that the “contexts” of the documents are fully recoverable by those who possess the skills and dedication to uncover them. This assumption overlooks the reality that we rarely possess the ability to claim that our readings of the sources are thorough and our interpretations of their meaning are authentic. Can Ghazzal guarantee that a primarily (if not exclusively) fiqh-based approach to estate inventories provides an accurate understanding of their historical meaning? What about temporal and spatial variations in the legal concepts that Ghazzal might be unaware of? What about the role of customary practices that are not found in classical or contemporary fiqh works? What about other invisible (social, political) factors that might have influenced the court's division of estates? Critical literary theorists and post-Geertzian anthropologists (among others) have long demonstrated how idiosyncratic and often arbitrary one's attempts to attribute meaning to the traces of past and present realities are, whether one is an expert in his/her area of research or not. It is time that we take them seriously.
All readings are provisional; they are all tentative; and they are all subjectively construed. And while they could all be improved, no reading is inherently wrong (although it might be factually so). Thus, the objective of historical research should not be to aspire to represent the Truth of the past but to produce falsifiable propositions by using available sources, which should be put under scrutiny by future researchers and be either (provisionally) confirmed or rejected. In fact, the realization of the limitations of our endeavor could actually be productive. If we agree that there can be no single authorized reading of the documents and that the value of our contributions is not based on their supposed Truth values but on their ability to further existing conversations on specific topics, then we can take liberties in interpreting our documents, allow ourselves to test novel (or daring?) categories of analysis that are not immediately justified by our sources, and experiment in applying relevant methods commonly used for other source bases in different fields. Given the limited number and nature of our sources, what we need is not so much to respect those sources as to exploit them to answer questions that we deem important.
For example, and to return to the disagreement on the historical uses and abuses of estate inventories, given how little we know on class differences, wealth levels, inequality, and long-term economic development patterns in many Middle Eastern contexts, we cannot afford to disregard these documents as possible sources of economic information simply because they were produced for different purposes or they have problems as a source base. If, say, we use estate values as proxies for individual wealth levels, even though the inventories do not list all sources of wealth, then these should be seen as compromises necessary to generate testable hypotheses on topics about which we have little direct information. Instead of dismissing such attempts as illegitimate, a constructive yet critical treatment of them would entail a discussion of how the specific aspects of these documents impact our results and the ways in which the researcher might be able to compensate for these influences in his or her findings.
