Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T02:26:24.255Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Observation-infused simulations of high-speed boundary-layer transition

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 April 2021

David A. Buchta
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA
Tamer A. Zaki*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: t.zaki@jhu.edu

Abstract

High-speed boundary-layer transition is extremely sensitive to the free-stream disturbances which are often uncertain. This uncertainty compromises predictions of models and simulations. To enhance the fidelity of simulations, we directly infuse them with available observations. Our methodology is general and can be adopted with any simulation tool, and is herein demonstrated using direct numerical simulations. An ensemble variational (EnVar) optimization is performed, whereby we determine the upstream flow that optimally reproduces the observations. The cost functional accounts for our relative confidence in the model and the observations, and judicious choice of the ensemble members improves convergence and reduces the prediction uncertainty. We demonstrate our observation-infused predictions for boundary-layer transition at Mach 4.5. Without prior knowledge of the free-stream condition, and using only observations of wall pressure at isolated locations from an independent computation (true flow), all of the relevant inflow disturbances are identified. We then evaluate the entire flow field, beyond the original limited wall observations, and interpret simulations consistently with data and vice versa. Our predicted flow compares favourably to the true ‘unknown’ state, and discrepancies are analysed in detail. We also examine the impact of weighting of observations. Improved convergence of the inverse problem and accuracy of the inflow amplitudes and phases are demonstrated, and are explained by aid of a simple example from two-dimensional unstable, chaotic convection.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Flow configuration for a transitional high-speed boundary layer on a flat plate. Cutout shows the locations of discrete wall-pressure probes.

Figure 1

Algorithm 1Observation-infused EnVar technique

Figure 2

Table 1.Simulation and data acquisition parameters.

Figure 3

Table 2.Distribution of modal energy.

Figure 4

Figure 2.(a) Sample wall-pressure signals from the precursor DNS, extracted at $z=20.8$ and $\sqrt {Re_x}=\{2000, 2105, 2567, 2650\}$. Horizontal lines indicate $p'=0$. (b) Detail of the shaded region in (a); the acquisition frequency is shown by symbols. (c) Detail of sensor positions: large symbols correspond to traces shown in (a) and small symbols are remaining sensors.

Figure 5

Figure 3.(a) Pressure spectra from the 64 sensors placed on the adiabatic wall $2000\leq \sqrt {Re_x}\leq 2650$. Three modes with the largest amplitudes at $\sqrt {Re_x}=2000$ are identified. (b) Possible inflow conditions using least-squares fit of amplitudes of those three modes at the first two sensor rows. (c) Wall-pressure prediction from DNS using the inflow conditions $E0$ and $E1$.

Figure 6

Figure 4.(a) Intensity of wall-pressure fluctuations. (b) The normalized cost function; vertical dashed lines identify iterations where $\varSigma _c$ was inflated.

Figure 7

Figure 5.Wall-pressure spectra averaged in $z$: (a) first row $\sqrt {Re_x}=2000$, (b) fourth row $\sqrt {Re_x}=2300$ and (c) seventh row $\sqrt {Re_x}=2570$. For reference, the $F^{-1}$ and $F^{-5}$ sloped lines indicate spectral roll off in equilibrium boundary-layer turbulence (Bull 1996).

Figure 8

Figure 6.Visualization of streamwise velocity from DNS of (a) $E0$, (b) $E1$, (c) EnVar optimized inflow after 14 iterations and (d) true inflow condition.

Figure 9

Figure 7.Downstream dependence of the mean skin-friction coefficient.

Figure 10

Figure 8.Wall-pressure errors for inflow conditions estimated from (solid) successive EnVar iterations $i=\{0,2,6,10,14\}$, as well as exponential modal growth models (dash–dotted) $E0$ and (dashed) $E1$.

Figure 11

Figure 9.Instantaneous errors in EnVar-estimated flow relative to the truth. Contours show spanwise average errors in (a,b) pressure and (c,d) full state vector. Overlaid curves represent the position of $\delta _{99}(x)$ for the (solid) truth and (dashed) EnVar prediction.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Streamwise development of wall-pressure spectra for (a) $E0$, (b) $E1$ and (c) EnVar optimized framework at iteration $i=14$. Observations (symbols); truth (solid); model prediction (dashed).

Figure 13

Figure 11.(a,b) Amplitudes of inflow instabilities: (a) EnVar, (b) truth. Marked values in (a) are the percent errors in the amplitude and phase relative to the true inflow. (c,d) Streamwise development of the wall-pressure spectra: (solid) truth; (dashed) EnVar-predicted flow after 14 iterations.

Figure 14

Figure 12.(a) Example of streamwise Gaussian weighting. (b) For each streamwise placement of the Gaussian weighting, $x_w = x_i$ for $i=\{1,2,\ldots ,8\}$, the $\kappa$, $\lambda _{{max}}$ and $\lambda _{{min}}$ of $\mathcal {H}$ are reported, normalized by their values for uniform weighting. Shaded symbols mark the optimal value for each criterion, and panel (c) shows the corresponding weighting.

Figure 15

Figure 13.(a) Progression of the 2-norm of $\varSigma _{\boldsymbol {c}}$ with EnVar iteration, $i\leq 5$ and (b) amplitude of key modes. Marked values in (b) are the relative uncertainty $(\sigma _{f,m} / c_{f,m}, \sigma _{f,m} / {\rm \pi})\times 100$ for the amplitude and phases.

Figure 16

Figure 14.(a) Comparison of the normalized cost function when observations are weighted to minimize the maximum eigenvalue of $\mathcal {H}$ vs uniform weighting. (b) Reduction of error in the wall pressure when observations are weighted (thick), relative to the uniform weighting results (thin lines reproduced from figure 8).

Figure 17

Figure 15.Isosurface of instantaneous streamwise velocity $u=0.58$ at the end of the observation time horizon $t=T_a$, from (a) favourably weighted EnVar optimization ($i=5$) and (b) the true state. In (c) the two isosurfaces are overlaid.

Figure 18

Figure 16.Accuracy of the cost-functional gradient computed using the EnVar approach in the transitional boundary layer. (a) Uniform weighting of observations $\boldsymbol {W}_{s}=\boldsymbol {I}$ (EnVar iteration $i=14$); (b) weighted observations $\boldsymbol {W}_{s}~|~\lambda _{{max}}$ (iteration $i=5$).

Figure 19

Figure 17.(a) Instantaneous temperature (colour) and velocity (arrows). (b) True phase-space trajectory (thick grey), observation locations (small symbols) and initial condition (large symbol). (c) Time evolution of $Y$: observations (symbols), truth (thick grey) and Gaussian weighting strategy (blue/grey).

Figure 20

Figure 18.(a,b) The estimated time evolution of $Y$ after one hundred EnVar iterations. Shaded intervals identify the extents of the observation time horizons, $\boldsymbol {m}=[Y(5),Y(6),\ldots ,Y(t_f)]^{\mathrm {T}}$. (a) Target observation horizon $t_f=20$; (b) shorter test horizon $t_f=10$. (c,d) Convergence history of the normalized cost function.

Figure 21

Figure 19.(a) Effect of discarding observations on the shape of the cost function, evaluated in the gradient direction, at the initial EnVar iteration. Full observation horizon $t_f=20$; truncated horizon $t_f=10$. (b) The 2-norm of the covariance matrix of the control vector as a function of EnVar iterations. (c) Errors in the gradient of the cost functional evaluated using EnVar vs step size $\alpha$ in the gradient direction. Symbols: errors relative to finite difference $\epsilon _{{{EV}}}$, at various levels of ensemble covariance $\varSigma _{\boldsymbol {c}}=\sigma _c\boldsymbol {I}$. See Appendix A for definitions of $\epsilon _1$ and $\epsilon _p$.

Figure 22

Figure 20.(a) For each temporal placement of the Gaussian weighting, $t_w = t_i$ for $i=[5,6,\ldots ,20]$, the $\kappa$, $\lambda _{{max}}$ and $\lambda _{{min}}$ of $\mathcal {H}$ are reported, normalized by their values for uniform weighting. Shaded symbols mark the optimal value for each criterion, and panel (b) shows the corresponding weighting.

Figure 23

Figure 21.(a) Comparison of normalized cost functional during EnVar optimizations that adopt different sensor-weighting ($\boldsymbol {W}_{s}$) schemes. (b–d) Cost functional in the gradient direction vs the step size for the first five iterations. Parameters: (b) $\boldsymbol {W}_{s}=\boldsymbol {I}$; (c) $\boldsymbol {W}_{s}~|~\lambda _{min}$; (d) $\boldsymbol {W}_{s}|\lambda _{max}$.

Figure 24

Figure 22.Accuracy of the gradient of the cost function evaluated using EnVar vs the step size in the optimal direction. Results are shown for EnVar iterations $i\leq 4$. Parameters: (a) $\boldsymbol {W}_{s}=\boldsymbol {I}$, (b) $\boldsymbol {W}_{s}|\lambda _{min}$ and (c) $\boldsymbol {W}_{s}|\lambda _{max}$.

Figure 25

Figure 23.(a) The time evolution of $Y$ estimated using EnVar with weighted observations to guard against worst-case Hessian curvature, control-vector covariance inflation every five iterations and stopping criteria $\mathcal {J}/\mathcal {J}_0 \leq 10^{-11}$. (b) Normalized 2-norm of the control-vector covariance matrix; symbols mark iterations when covariance inflation is applied.