The volume under review is the product of the 2006 meeting of the contributors — past and present — to the research project on ancient slavery carried out under the auspices of the commission for the history of antiquity at the ‘Akademie der Wissenschaften und der Literatur’ in Mainz. Founded in 1948 by the Tübingen ancient historian Joseph Vogt, the project has since become the most productive scholarly endeavour in the field of ancient slavery studies, producing primarily single-authored monographs on a range of individual aspects of ancient slavery. The present volume deviates from the path set by these previous studies published in the academy's own series Forschungen zur antiken Sklaverei by bringing together a number of short, article-length studies on a single topic by different contributors. As Heinen, chair of the project and editor of the series, explains in his introduction, this shift reflects the wish ‘die Forschungen zur antiken Sklaverei in den grösseren Kontext unfreier Arbeit und aktueller Problemlagen zu stellen’ (xi). More specifically the project aims to address themes and questions related to modern forms of slavery and its derivates, on this occasion those primarily relating to aspects of human trafficking, a topic where there is little universalizing analysis. The present volume is intended as a contribution towards filling this lacuna.
The volume kicks off with a report by Annette von Schmiedeberg, a senior prosecuting barrister who specializes in the legal dimension of the trafficking of women in modern Germany. It covers primarily in descriptive form aspects of the legal situation in Germany, the practical difficulties of disclosure and identification of trafficking and forced prostitution, and the problems of legal proof in the courtroom. Inge Kroppenburg, an academic lawyer, deals with the question of legal redress in Roman antiquity arising from internal, i.e. unwanted, slaving. She places legal developments in the larger context of socio-economic developments on the basis of plagium, arguing that the growing severity of legal sanctions from Republic to Empire reflects the declining availability (and hence growing worth) of slaves (in the market), leading to a (late antique) change in the type of legal redress. Despite the stress on Anglophone scholarship (in the historical part), there is a curious reluctance to engage with the debate on soft and hard law, and the relationship between law and life in ancient Rome. Plagium is also at the heart of Oliver Schipp's survey, concentrating on Late Antiquity, of the enslaving of free and other persons on the one hand and kidnapping, the raptus of a female, on the other (with the aim of marriage). He concludes the latter part by stressing the regular occurrence of discussions of Brautraub at state and church level, implying, without argument, the historical relevance of this practice. The overlaps between these three pieces could have provided grounds for comparative analysis. It would also have been interesting to see how Kroppenburg's interpretation of the increase in the severity of punishment as evidence for an increasing shortage in the slave supply (i.e. a general socio-economic trend) squares with Schipp's observation that the theft of young women, too, was increasingly heavily penalised: are we meant to suppose a shortage of (free) girls then — or is the relationship between law and life only sometimes direct? And if so, when?
Andrea Binsfeld addresses a related area with an account of the trade in female slaves which aims to clarify the extent to which such slaves were forced to prostitution. Binsfeld uses evidence from the ancient novel to illustrate the practice and to complement the picture left behind by the official documentary record of papyri from the same period. Without being able to relate a single one of the papyri to prostitution, she concludes that women were often enslaved and traded for the purpose of prostitution (or other occupations), thus providing a structural parallel to the forced sexual exploitation of women in the modern world of the type discussed by von Schmiedeberg. Given the overlap between the two essays, it is striking that there is only one tiny cross-reference, in the first footnote to von Schmiedeberg's paper: an opportunity missed to exemplify the volume's aim to bridge the gap between ancient and modern.
Fischer's chapter explores the contexts in which persons assumed to be slaves appear in some Linear B Tablets, stressing their wide range of occupations, including agricultural activities and religious duties, whilst foregrounding industrial production amongst both males and females. Solin offers a synthesis of his earlier work on slave names, updating the list of slave names produced by Martin Bang in 1910 (MDAI(R)). Whilst stressing the need for collection and interpretation of slave names as a means to understand the origins of Rome's servile population, Solin concludes his survey by stating that the sources do not allow any detailed or wide-reaching conclusions about slave origins.
Different to all these are the two studies by Karl-Wilhelm Welwei and Johannes Deissler who both delve into more than one world in their contributions. Welwei's chapter on slaving and forced mass deportations aims at a comparative study of four different cultures, ranging from the neo-Assyrian kingdom, Homeric Greece and early Rome, to Late Antiquity and pre-colonial West Africa. The attempt restricts itself to historical synthesis of the approaches to slaving and/or mass deportations in the four cultures, mainly derived from now dated secondary literature, unequal in scope and depth, and not surprisingly concluding that there were distinct differences between the reasons for, and practices and consequences of slaving and mass deportations in these four cultures. Deissler's contribution, on the other hand, asks to what extent the depiction of slave markets and slave sales in two pictures by the nineteenth-century painter Gérôme are truthful representations of Roman slave markets, aiming to demonstrate, again not surprisingly, that the gap between historical accuracy and artistic creativity is often a large one.
My main concern, however, is with the volume's overall aim. How does one get from the publication of half a dozen or so short studies of individual aspects of human trafficking in the ancient world, themselves not obviously related to each other or obviously enriched or influenced by either the modern contribution or the contributions of their colleagues, to an inclusive analysis of the topic? It is, of course, not rare in slavery studies to stage the joint or paired publication of ancient and modern studies on a single topic as a comparative contribution or, worse still, comparative history. For the latter, the work of ‘comparing’, however understood, surely cannot be left to the reader. Heinen's appeal to move towards an understanding of ancient slavery in a perspective of universal history — ‘(dem) universalhistorischen Kontext’ (3) — in order to avoid its study in an isolated, ancient context follows the wider historical interests of the project's founding father. And anyone familiar with Vogt's writings on the question of universal history could not possibly imagine that he thought the project's ultimate purpose to coincide with the project's immediate remit, i.e. the production of a string of individual studies of important aspects of ancient slavery. But it is equally difficult to assume that one of the most dedicated universal historians that Germany ever produced thought universal contextualization achievable through the publication of collections of what are primarily highly specialized short studies. The Mainz research project on ancient slavery needs to come up with substantially more if it wants to meet the challenge set by its founder.
