One of the negative effects of the 9/11 terrorist attacks was the sudden appearance of self-proclaimed experts on Wahhabism and Saudi Arabia. The field became so politicized that even some of the most qualified academics ended up falling in the trap of condemning or defending Wahhabism as if it were an ossified school of thought that has not developed since the days of its founder.
David Commins in The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia does exactly the opposite. Instead of focusing on the contemporary period (he spends only five pages on Bin Laden, which makes this a book worth reading!) or pursuing a topic-oriented approach (as in DeLong-Bas's Wahhabi Islam), Commins traces the development of Wahhabi thought amid the sociopolitical developments affecting Arabia and the region. The author's mastery of the primary and secondary sources, partly the result of an extended research trip to Saudi Arabia, is reflected in his informed account. The result is a solid scholarly overview of the history and doctrines of Wahhabism and Saudi Arabia from the days of Ibn ʿAbd al-Wahhab to the present.
The book covers the main periods in the history of Wahhabism and Saudi Arabia and shows how the Wahhabi mission and institution developed in reaction to regional and global movements. The historical narrative is enlivened by profiles of major intellectual figures and a discussion of some of their writings and ideas, such as Ibn ʿAbd al-Wahhab's seminal treatise The Book of God's Unity (Chapter 1) and al-Alusi's The History of Najd (Chapter 5).
These profiles form a continuous thread throughout the book especially when it comes to the argument concerning the authors' legal position on interaction with idolaters, that is to say, non-Wahhabis. The issue comes to the forefront in the epistles written by Sulayman b. ʿAbdallah b. Muhammad (d. 1818) during the war with Muhammad ʿAli when he states that it is only permissible for a believer to travel to the land of the idolaters if “one can openly practice one's religion” and “refrain from befriending the idolaters” (p. 33). Otherwise he would become one of them (Chapter 1).
At a later stage, Ibn ʿAtiq, writing during the Egyptian occupation, stressed that whoever chose to live under idolatrous rule without openly declaring his faith was either a sinner for practicing his faith in hiding or an infidel for allying himself with the idolaters (Chapter 2). Commins picks up the thread by showing how the same debate was at the heart of the clash between Ibn Saʿud and the Ikhwan, who accused him of establishing diplomatic relations with the British and Egyptians (Chapter 3).
It is unfortunate that there are no similar profiles in the sections devoted to the modern era. A description of the works and thought of major figures such as Muhammad b. Ibrahim b. ʿAbd al-Latif (d. 1969), Ibn Baz (d. 1999), or Ibn ʿUthaymin (d. 2001) would have been very useful because these scholars have not yet received adequate scholarly attention.
The last two chapters are devoted to the relationship between Wahhabism and revivalist movements and the effect of the latter on the mission's hegemony in Saudi Arabia in the last two decades. Commins argues convincingly that, although sharing a common worldview with Qutbists, Wahhabi clerics are doctrinally and methodologically opposed to the religiously untrained revivalist thinkers.
The 1979 seizure of Mecca's al-Haram mosque by Juhayman al-ʿUtaybi's millenarian group and the coinciding Shiʿi uprisings in the eastern province ultimately fomented movements of protest in the kingdom against the Saudi dynasty and its clerics that took the form of internal attempts at reform (the Sahwa shaykhs) or outright jihadist actions (al-Qaʿida).
Commins's emphasis on the close relationship between the Wahhabi establishment and the ruling dynasty since the inception of the first Saudi state is essential to understanding the kingdom's stance on political, social, and religious reform in the wake of 9/11 and its foreign policy in the Muslim world.
This approach overshadows, however, another critical issue regarding the changing nature of Wahhabi identity and allegiance, particularly after 1979. It seems that for Commins the Wahhabis are mainly the followers of the pro-Saudi religious establishment, but the others are just “the Sahwa shaykhs” or the revivalists. I find it hard to believe that Salman al-ʿAwda and Safar al-Hawali are less Wahhabi than Ibn Baz or Ibn ʿUthaymin just because they champion a reformist agenda. Don't they all ascribe to the same doctrinal, legal, and moralistic school of thought? Thus, is present-day Wahhabism limited to the state-sponsored religious institution, or is it a movement that transcends the pact between Ibn ʿAbd al-Wahhab and Ibn Saʿud? Where do we place the non-Saudi graduates from Medina's Islamic University who are spreading Wahhabi thought in their home countries? These are essential questions that still need to be addressed. The omission, however, does not lessen the importance of Commins's contribution to the study of Wahhabism and Saudi Arabia.
The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia is an accessible study targeted at a broad, educated readership. The author systematically provides clarifications and explanations of technical terms (and some are pretty basic) to ease the reader's way through a book rich in personal names (especially in Chapter 2). Although it might not be the smoothest reading assignment for an introductory undergraduate course, I strongly recommend the first chapter on Ibn ʿAbd al-Wahhab and the first Saudi state for an upper-level introduction to Islam. Commins has written a masterful account of the political and religious history of Saudi Arabia that deserves to be read by all those who are interested in the subject.
