Jamie Elwick's aim in this important book is to characterize transformation in the life sciences in Britain in the period before the publication of Darwin's Origin of Species. It was a period that saw museums give way to zoos and aquaria, patronage displaced by meritocracy, and a whole research area overturned without having its central projects completed or even acknowledged. With that research area went a particular perspective on what it is to be a biological individual.
Elwick shows us all these changes interwoven as a shift in ‘styles of reasoning’. These styles he takes – in the manner of Ian Hacking and others – to be methodological approaches which determine the appropriate questions to be asked and the right ways to go about answering them. The earlier, overturned style that concerns Elwick is what he calls the ‘analytic:synthetic’ style. A synchronic approach, favouring the use of dead specimens for dissection, it involved the decomposing of a system into its simplest elements, with the whole then viewed as the sum of these elements. The later, overturning style he calls (after Whewell) the ‘palaetiological’ style. Here the focus was less on parts and more on origins, on the view that the best way to understand a system is to describe how it emerges dynamically from its starting point. This holistic perspective demanded the observation of living organisms through time.
At the beginning of Elwick's story, the biggest problem for British life scientists concerned the compound nature of organisms. If creatures are understood as aggregations of smaller living parts, then how is unity achieved? What gives rise to the apparent coherence of the soul? And why do some organisms have the ability to live and move after decapitation while others do not? The analytic style prompted researchers to vivisect and dissect organisms in order to investigate these questions. They noticed variation in the degree of unity across organisms, which led Richard Owen to formulate his fourfold classification of life, in which organisms were arranged according to their kind of nervous structure, and ordered according to nervous complexity, with humans at the peak and very simple organisms at the base. The increased ability of lower organisms to regenerate and survive fragmentation was thus explained as a result of their diminished unity.
When the German embryologist Karl Ernst von Baer's work was translated into English, embryonic development became a new focus of interest in Britain. The analysts noted that there was a mirroring of the chain of being in development, with embryos becoming increasingly complex and unified, their nervous centres coalescing into hierarchical structures. This idea of recapitulation came to characterize the analysts' view of development, metamorphosis and taxonomic movement. All three were seen as centripetal processes, in which many separate but similar elements coalesced and then differentiated, giving rise to unity and a division of labour.
However, Elwick also shows that around this time von Baer's work was influencing others in different ways. His studies motivated the emerging palaetiologists to focus on development as a very dynamic process, having a branching structure through time, with early developmental events viewed as much more important than later ones. Palaetiologists concentrated on finding the origin events and using them to define the whole developmental process. They too saw an analogy between development and taxonomy, but they viewed both centrifugally, having an essentially tree-like structure in which the process originates at a singular central point and emanates outwards in increasing complexity.
On Elwick's telling, the two styles eventually came to a head over the issue of reproduction. The analysts were trying to work out why simpler organisms are better at reproducing than higher ones – they have the ability to regenerate lost limbs and produce new individuals from fragments of themselves. One result was Owen's theory of spermatic force, in which sperm endows cells with a ‘fecundating principle’ which gets used up during reproduction. Simpler organisms use up less of this when replicating themselves, whereas higher organisms use so much that they require a new input of spermatic force each time they reproduce. Meanwhile, the palaetiologists, spearheaded by Thomas Huxley, were looking for the origin of the developmental process. Deciding that the origin was sexual fertilization, they were led to define an individual as whatever issues from sexual fertilization. Not only did they then reclassify all other forms of reproduction or replication as growth, but they redefined the entire view of organisms; for if cellular replication was growth, rather than genuine reproduction, then organisms were not compounds of smaller individuals at all, but simply individuals.
By the end of Elwick's story, most of the research questions from the beginning had become unaskable. The problem of unity dissolved because there ceased to be lots of individuals in need of unification. Owen's theory of spermatic force became defunct because reproduction occurred if and only if sperm fertilized ovum. This resolution by redefinition ultimately pushed out the analytic:synthetic paradigm. The new palaetiological style took over, but not because it was better at framing old questions or finding their answers. It simply ignored them. Not by inadvertence: Elwick claims that Huxley deliberately misinterpreted Owen, forging a new terminology in order to gain control over who could access the ranks of biologists. Social and economic factors apparently dominated and determined theory itself.
Although Elwick no more than hints that the palaetiologists ‘won’ in any lasting sense, it is interesting to note that there is a modern analogue to the debate over reproduction in which surprisingly little has changed. Those concerned to isolate the appropriate unit upon which to endow fitness measures sometimes say that an individual is simply the product of a zygote. But there is still no widespread agreement as to whether certain marine invertebrates should be understood as colonies or as individuals, or how to understand the long-term evolutionary consequences of asexual vegetative propagation. Those disagreeing about these issues now will be fascinated to discover in Elwick's book how central they once were and how politically complex was their disappearance before their time.
