For all the accolades given to him, Max Weber wrote little. Sure, the monumental Max Weber Gesamtausgabe (MWG) has already churned out over thirty volumes of articles, lecture notes, journalistic pieces, and letters, and still more is yet to come. But he did not produce a single scholarly monograph in his lifetime, and even the opera he left behind are by and large fragmentary. Even his most widely read work, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, was originally published as a two-part article and later incorporated as a chapter in his Gesammelte Aufsätze zur Religionssoziologie (Collected works in the sociology of religion). Economy and Society, his alleged magnum opus, was a collection of largely unpublished articles edited posthumously by his widow, Marianne, under thematic rubric that cannot be conclusively verified as Weber's own even after its recent release as a MWG volume. Weber has nothing comparable to Leviathan, Das Kapital, or De la démocratie en Amerique.
Against this relatively thin and disorganized written legacy, it might come as a surprise that, whether for or against, no one has disputed Weber's place in the pantheon of modern political and social thought. Where does this Olympian reputation come from, and why does such a universal perception endure as long as it does? To put it in Weberian terms, how has Weber's charisma, as a personality as well as a scholar, been routinized without evaporating into thin air? Joshua Derman's notable book is the latest attempt to answer this question. Thus the book's subtitle—From Charisma to Canonization.
This book is based on Derman's Princeton dissertation in history and published under the auspices of the esteemed Ideas in Context series of Cambridge University Press. True to this background, the book is deeply steeped in the political, cultural, and intellectual history of the twentieth century and pays close attention to the ways in which some of Weber's major concepts were used, abused, and/or misused by his contemporary and posthumous readers in Germany and America. This means that Derman is less concerned with offering a fresh interpretation of Weber's ideas as such than with narrating a richly illustrated history of Weber's reception. Along the way, Derman has unearthed many an interesting episode and colorful figures including such usual suspects as Karl Jaspers, Carl Schmitt, and Talcott Parsons as well as a host of largely forgotten names (mostly, those of Nazi intellectuals). In so doing, he draws not only from academic studies by and about Weber, but also relies on obituaries, memoirs, private letters, and newspaper articles. At one point, he even tells us how and why charisma, Weber's trademark concept, became a trade jargon among American journalists in the turbulent 1960s (212–15). For anyone keen on Weber memorabilia, this is the book to read.
For those interested more in Weber's thought per se, too, the book has much to offer, especially when it plugs Weber back into the German political and intellectual milieu during the Weimar and Nazi eras. Weber's valorization of value freedom or neutrality (Wertfreiheit) in the face of the plethora of incommensurable subjective values in modern culture is frequently seen as his main contribution to the methodology of the human and social sciences. As chapter 2 (“Max Weber and Value Freedom”) demonstrates, however, its implication was never unambiguous even to his contemporaries and protégés in Germany. Many, such as Gutav Radbruch, believed it to be a qualified endorsement of value pluralism and an agnostic, even existential, kind of liberalism, whereas some of the Nazi apologists took it as an impassioned critique of liberal anomie and political impotence in need of overcoming by the “objective” order as propagated by their ilk. According to Derman, what united these opposite interpretations was their admiration for “the intensity and exacting ethos of [Weber's] value freedom” (79). In other words, it was the universally perceived charisma of Weber's personality and his ideas that kept his legacy alive across the board in Germany.
In chapter 3 (“The Meaning of Modern Capitalism”), too, Derman successfully restores the German background surrounding the reception of the so-called “Protestant ethic thesis,” in which he points to, among others, the Wilhelmine context of Kulturkampf (against Catholics) that persisted into the Weimar era in an attenuated form. This chapter also puts Weber's seemingly value-neutral definition of the state—as merely a subspecies of bureaucratic Betrieb (enterprise)—against the Germanic tradition of moral and cultural exaltation of the state, thereby highlighting the rhetorical nature of Weber's postulation. Although these arguments are well made, however, they are not entirely original. Neither are chapters 5 (“Max Weber's Sociologies”) and 6 (“Charismatic Rulership”). For they retell the story, albeit ably, of how Parsons and other Americans misused Weber's categories to create sociology as a coherent discipline, which was not his intention at all, and how charisma as a leadership quality was used and abused in Hitler's Germany.
A more original contribution may be found in chapter 4 (“Skepticism and Faith”). One of the central perplexities that confronts any serious student of Weber's political ideas is the seeming oscillation between the assertion of the subjective foundation of political faith and a call for unflinching commitment to a political cause, which together constitute a unique brand of sober political realism in Weber. In this chapter, different ways that have been suggested to resolve this “antinomy” (à la Wolfgang Mommsen) are schematized into three groups—namely, cold (e.g., Siegfried Kracauer), temperate (e.g., Karl Löwith), and hot antiutopianism (e.g., Jaspers). With this typology, Derman neatly captures the full array of possible exegeses, which run the whole gamut from a nihilistic-stoic renunciation to an unconditional commitment to individual autonomy in Weber's political thought. As a side note, Derman's summary of Jaspers's and Löwith's existentialist reading of Weber is done with exceptional clarity and economy, making it arguably the most persuasive one available in the English language.
Derman's book is at its best when it draws from German sources to illustrate the history of Weber's reception. We now have a much richer picture of Weber's various, even conflicting, legacies in Germany. In comparison, the American scene pales. Some of Derman's observations are remarkably insightful. For example, commenting on the interdisciplinary culture in American academia, he says: “American social scientists were attempting to reconstitute Weber's polymathic abilities through institutionalized cooperation rather than imitation” (224–25). Still, the book's survey of the American landscape lacks the systematic or thick description that it deserves. This imbalance is noteworthy because the book's self-professed aim is to tell a “transatlantic” story. For the story on the American side, one might do well to read Lawrence Scaff's Max Weber in America (Princeton University Press, 2011) in conjunction with this book.
All in all, Derman has made a fine contribution to Weber studies when it comes to understanding the reason for Weber's long life after life. For this book helps us recognize, once again, that Weber's charisma survived routinization precisely because it could not be reified despite canonization.
