If the poor will always be among us, then Robert Henke's study cannot fail but be timely. Our contemporary political discourse takes up the themes and tropes Henke explores in this book, as evidenced in Ronald Reagan's infamous description of welfare queens driving Cadillacs as well as in Ben Carson's more recent assertion that poverty is a state of mind. As Henke's comparative study of Italian and Shakespearean performance demonstrates, such depictions of poverty as con job or self-willed performance have antecedents in sixteenth- and seventeenth-century accounts of the poor.
In Poverty and Charity in Early Modern Theater and Performance, Henke presents five case studies of early modern theatrical attempts, first, to represent poverty and its attendant features and, second, to reflect on adequate responses to that poverty. In his first case study, Henke discusses King Lear, reading Edgar's performance of Poor Tom in light of English and continental beggar catalogs and rogue handbooks, such as Speculum cerretanorum, Liber vagatorum, and Thomas Harman's Caveat for Common Cursetors, as well as fourteenth- and fifteenth-century German municipal registers. One of the main problems with these texts, Henke contends, is that the very descriptions they articulate render poverty in fundamentally theatrical terms: by detailing beggars’ appearances and actions, these catalogs advised how to perform beggary as well as how to see through such performances. As Edgar demonstrates in his performance of Poor Tom, poverty becomes a self-reflexive role rather than an experienced state of material deprivation.
Likewise, charitable relief becomes theatrical. By relieving the poor through the donation of alms, the donor interacted theatrically with the beggar. Both performed roles in this exchange, in relation to each other as well as to any public audience. The dramatic conflict of the interaction, Henke argues, lies in the donor's uncertainty of the beggar's need. Such encounters thus unfolded in self-reflexive and forensic terms, with both parties gauging the persuasiveness and sincerity of the performance.
Henke studies these interactions in a corpus of cheap, printed Italian pamphlets in which he identifies themes of poverty and hunger but also, and more important, a discourse of performative begging. Henke offers a valuable survey of these texts, cataloging a number of ways in which they depict poverty, ranging from the conventional (the poor as lazy, the poor as not actually poor) to the “‘reverse beggar’ theme” (66) in which poverty results from a reversal of fortune stemming from gluttonous living.
These pamphlets offered two solutions to the problem of poverty's theatricality. First, the acts they describe were not in fact performances at all: the pamphlet peddlers and piazza singers were, after all, poor and hungry. This makes their performance of poverty ironic in the sense that the peddlers’ destitution can be alleviated only by the performance of a clichéd or stereotypical suffering that reinforces the purported theatrical nature of poverty. Second, Henke locates these performances in the context of widespread famine and notes that their audiences also suffered from hunger and hardship. Henke intriguingly—but too fleetingly—identifies this interaction as a “community of suffering” (68) potentially capable of restoring a social and embodied referent to the theatrical representation of poverty.
In the next two case studies, Henke traces poverty's theatricality in Ruzante's plays and the commedia dell'arte. Henke understands Ruzante's plays as attempts to transform aristocratic prejudice against the poor into sympathetic judgment by emphasizing the embodied experiences of his characters’ hunger and poverty rather than treating them as satirical figures. The commedia dell'arte developed the representations of penury that it inherited (from the piazza singers as well as from Ruzante) primarily in the form of modular gags based on tropes about the poor that Henke identified in earlier Italian plays. Henke demonstrates that poverty remained a significant theme of the commedia dell'arte; yet even as he surveys a wide range of texts, his approach tends to be descriptive, and his conclusions would benefit from a synthesis of his material.
In the book's concluding case study, Henke returns to Shakespeare, surveying the depiction of poverty in several plays and offering compelling analyses of them. Turning to Henry VI, Part 2, Henke valuably traces the forensic revelation of Simpcox's beggary as a moneymaking ruse. Against this, Henke contrasts the Lord's transformation of Sly the beggar to Sly the lord in The Taming of the Shrew, arguing that both plays demonstrate the performative quality of poverty and escape from it. Throughout this final chapter, Henke notes similarities between Shakespeare and the Italian plays discussed earlier in the book.
Henke's case studies are illuminating in themselves, but a synthesis of their conclusions is largely left to the reader. Beyond the shared influence of the beggar catalog tradition, it is not clear how the Italian context informs the Shakespearean one, or vice versa. Yet Henke's very profitable approach to the history of Italian performance of poverty suggests that relevant questions regarding English theatre history could be explored valuably as well.
