The 400-odd towns of Roman North Africa present a bewildering and massive dataset, ranging from a few walls and a single inscription that somehow identifies the site as a full-fledged town, to the imposing ruins of sites like Volubilis, Thamugadi, and Sufetula. Their publication is naturally spotty: those we know best were subject to massive clearances during the early 20th c. that stripped their stratigraphy and left them to decay, with, at best, a plan and, of course, a full catalog of their inscriptions. In this rather daunting panorama, the town of Thugga (modern Dougga) has been comparatively well served. Together with its territory, it has benefited in the last 20 years from the attention of a very distinguished array of archaeologists: Samir Aounallah, Aïcha Ben Abed, Jean-Claude Golvin, Mustapha Khanoussi, Louis Maurin, Stefan Ritter, Sophie Saint-Amans, and Philipp von Rummel have carried out excavations, Mariette de Vos Raaijmakers a remarkable survey.Footnote 1
The volume by S. Aounallah and J.-C. Golvin is the second in a joint project of the University of Bordeaux and the Institut national du patrimoine (INP) that started in 1999, and it aims at nothing less than the full publication of all of the religious buildings of the town, together with a re-examination of their epigraphy. The project was carried out with students and staff from the INP, with the express aim of training them in documentation and publication. Limited soundings were undertaken to resolve questions of dating and stratigraphy. The first volume covered the sanctuaries of Pluto, of the Victories of Caracalla, and of Caelestis;Footnote 2 this one covers most of the rest. The formula is straightforward: the presentation of each monument, or group of monuments, begins with the history of research and any archival material, and then presents the evidence. This is impeccably done: there are photographs and drawings of all the architectural elements, detailed plans, and reconstructions of the façades of the monuments. Any associated epigraphic material is addressed with rigor by Aounallah, giving new or revised readings for many of them and illuminating discussion.
Where the research breaks new ground is a definitive reappraisal of the forum and its Numidian predecessor. Referred to (perhaps exaggeratedly) as an agora, the square is reconstructed with a possible temple to the east, directly underneath that to Tiberius, a monument to Masinissa similar in design, though not in size, to that at Simitthus, and a large courtyard temple with three cellae in the southeast corner, flanked by a smaller one beside it to the west. The new pagus of Roman citizens that was settled on the pre-Roman town made short work of this arrangement, transforming the space into a Roman forum. A temple of Tiberius as Caesar was built over its possible predecessor to the west (the principal argument for this is the fact that the later temple is skewed to the new square, which can only be explained by a respect for the orientation of its predecessor). The forum was raised by 60 cm, the monument to Masinissa was destroyed, and an arch was erected over its south end. Its north end is reconstructed as a small temple. An inscription which appears to have come from the arch shows that a Roman citizen and member of the pagus, L. Postumius Chius, was responsible for the works.Footnote 3 The temple in the southeast corner was rebuilt with an apse to the south, and an altar to Augustus was placed in the center of its courtyard. The small temple next to it was, perhaps, rededicated to Saturn. The transformation was thus complete, and all monuments that might have recalled the Numidian kingship or pantheon were eliminated. The colonists of the pagus thus asserted their dominance over the indigenous civitas. This demonstration is a tour de force, shedding a new and harsher light on the happy unity of pagus and civitas that seems to emerge from subsequent inscriptions.
The publication then moves to the subsequent history of the forum, and from there to individual temples in the town, each treated with the same thorough presentation of the evidence. This is a model for anyone analyzing ancient buildings, and we can only regret that Golvin did not give us more of his normally splendid reconstructions. The conclusions summarize the results, concentrating on the development of the religious architecture over time, without much effort to tell us what it all means.
The task of interpretation is taken up by P. Scheding's (S.'s) handsome book.Footnote 4 Here he takes a discrete cluster of the African towns, including Thugga, and subjects them to a full analysis, supporting his claim that the area in which they fall, the pertica of Carthage, constitutes a “micro-region,” sufficiently coherent in both its topography and history to have created a particular form of urbanism. The micro-region itself was politically dependent on Carthage into the 3rd c. BCE, and contained no subsidiary central place: instead, it was an extraordinarily dense, polycentric system. S. argues that the peculiar social conditions of these little peregrine towns resulted in very specific architectural manifestations, common to the region and rarely found outside it.
Deriving from a dissertation, the book starts in a traditional way, with an examination of the history and geography of the region bounded by the Mejerda and Miliana rivers to the north and south, by the fossa regia (the territory of Sicca Veneria) to the west, and by the substantial territories of the Julian colony at Uthina and the veteran colony of Thuburbo Minus to the east. The area is crossed by the Hadrianic trunk road from Carthage to Theveste. Most of the numerous towns had origins as pre-Roman villages or estate centers, which is clear from their names and their regular placement on hilltops, as well as the frequency of suffetes in their governments. Often described as “civitates,” eight – that we know of – received deductions of Roman colonists grouped as a pagus whose land grants came from the village territory, and who were inserted into the pre-existing settlements, presumably creating some radical displacements. The original inhabitants of the civitas had simply to put up with the newcomers. These, as Roman citizens with ties to the capital at Carthage, clearly had the upper hand. The case that we know best, because of its plentiful epigraphy and extensive excavation, is again that of Thugga. S. sets his chronological limits with the Severan period; indeed, he examines the region as a fait accompli in that period, which seems to represent the culmination for the processes that he identifies in its formation.
The section on the economy of the area is clear and concise. Dense as the local towns were, they often bordered on the substantial territories of imperial estates. For these we have multiple boundary stones, as well as the surviving fragments of the Lex Manciana and related documents.Footnote 5 The estates were run by a hierarchy of administrators: the imperial procurator at Carthage, and below him freedmen procurators of the various regiones such as that of Thugga, who let the estates to conductores on five-year leases, and finally the coloni themselves, whose rent was paid in kind. This system provided the opportunity for various sorts of conflict, as the inscriptions show, and allowed space for mediation, particularly in the appointment of conductores. In contrast to the imperial estates, however, the estates of local landowners were very modest: de Vos's survey seems to show that some of the best-known families possessed only 20-odd ha.Footnote 6 Although the cities of the micro-region were certainly agriculturally based, it is hard to imagine that agriculture was the only source for the wealth of the elites, and S. underlines the importance of their relationships with the management of the imperial estates, as well as with resources such as quarries. He contrasts the tight imbrication of these properties with the larger estates to the south of the region, which, following Gsell, he identifies on very slim evidence as slave-run.Footnote 7
The author then introduces the chief protagonists of his analysis – the towns of Thugga, Thuburbo Maius, Thignica, Uchi Maius, and Musti – which he analyzes in depth, although less well-known towns are brought into the discussion. None of these is particularly large: the average size of the 18 towns where an estimate is possible is only 25 ha. In a first overview, he situates the type-sites in their topography and general plans, evoking their major buildings with stunning photographs as well as plans, some of which are derived from Aounallah and Golvin. He makes the point, to which he will come back a number of times, that they are extraordinarily short of major thoroughfares; there are none of the porticoed streets we associate with towns like Carthage, Thamugadi, or Volubilis, and indeed few streets that could be traversed with carriages, as the hilly territory means that most streets are punctuated by stairs. Even the larger streets are progressively narrowed by buildings that impinge on their pavements. Plazas, too, are missing, although each town has a forum, and that of Thugga was doubled by the Square of the Windrose on the other side of the Capitoline temple. Arches and fountains mark focal points in the urban armature, but there are no civic basilicas, and of the curias previously identified only that of Thuburbo Maius is plausible.Footnote 8 Baths, theaters, and amphitheaters are common, the last particularly so, with nine in the study area.
But what these towns do have in abundance are temples. There were 12 of these at Thuburbo Maius and at least 25 at Thugga, while 3 of the very few buildings known from Musti are temples. Although these come in various sizes and shapes, a very common plan sets the cella or cellae to the rear of a temenos. They are walled off from the street and accessed by a modest door: this is the so-called Romano-African plan, which has been linked to Punic prototypes.Footnote 9 The porticoed courtyard of the temenos itself was beautifully decorated, often with flowerbeds, mosaics, and low barriers that channeled and directed traffic toward the temple at the end, which was generally set on a podium in the Roman style. There were, of course, some temples that imposed themselves on the surrounding landscape, like the spectacular temple of the two goddesses Caelestis at Thugga, set at the back of a semicircular, columned exedra on a high terrace, which dominates the surrounding territory and could be seen from the main trunk road. S. makes a visual comparison with the Traianeum at Pergamon, but we can also think of the great Italic temples like that at Palestrina. Only in one case, the temple of Saturn at Thugga, was the porticoed courtyard set behind the temple, allowing the great columned temple building to impose itself from the top of the hill. The marbles and, particularly, statuary that decorate the temple courtyards contrast strongly with the sober, plastered streets of the cityscapes, unembellished even by the columned doorways of private houses.
To make the point that there is nothing normal about this arrangement, S. then moves to three major towns outside the micro-region: Bulla Regia, Cuicul, and Mactar. Each of these could be classed as a central place, with territories far larger than the towns of the micro-region. Bulla Regia has at least four public squares. Temples faced onto them, or onto the main streets, presenting their imposing façades directly to the gaze of the citizens passing through them. Façades like that of the baths of Julia Memmia also enlivened the main streets. At Cuicul a second large square developed just outside the original gate into the town, dominated eventually by the massive temple of Septimius Severus, the portico of which sits, impressively, on its lofty podium. The Cardo Maximus, a porticoed, processional street led along the spur from the south, passing the imposing façade of the baths, the plan of which recalls that of the Antonine baths at Carthage. Yet Cuicul was no larger than 24 ha, slightly smaller than Thugga. The difference, for S., lies in its economic role, as a central marketplace and redistribution center for a much larger territory. This is underlined by the presence of horrea in the center of town – there are no horrea in the micro-region. There are horrea at Mactar as well, and there is no doubt that the town would have played a similar role, as the central location of the Pagus Thuscae et Gunzuzi. Unlike at Thugga, its pre-Roman square, a sort of agora, was preserved, and was eventually doubled by the “Roman” forum. Façades and public porticoes presented elaborate carvings, particularly in the lively soffits with animal scenes. Unlike the architectural decoration in the micro-region, which was entirely dependent on Carthage (S. quotes Pensabene's dismissal of their “monotonous sameness”), Mactar's is fresh and creative, clearly employing its own band of architects and artisans.
Following a convincing exposition of the unified character of the cityscapes of the polycentric micro-region and its difference from the regional hierarchies outside it, S. goes on to explain this. Here, he leans heavily on the centrality of Carthage and its dominant role in its hinterland. Just as the office of the procurator was the central point of reference for the imperial estates, so Carthage was for the Roman citizens who lived in the small towns and even, eventually, for the indigenous families who aspired to citizenship. The roster of the public benefactors who donated the temples is impressive. Six of them were decurions in Carthage, one a duumvir, one an aedile, and the rest priests.
The family of the Gabinii of Thugga is the most remarkable. Not only may we follow them through seven generations, but they were responsible for four major buildings: the Temple of Concordia, Liber Pater, Frugifer, and Neptune; the portico of the forum; the Temple of the Victories of Caracalla; and the temple of the two Caelestes. And all this with a little farm on 20 ha of land! S. finds a clue to their success in the dedication of a statue to A. Gabinius Datus the elder, the first Gabinius we know of, by conductores of the region of Thugga, suggesting that he was involved in some transactions with the administration of the imperial estates.Footnote 10 What exactly those were is unclear, but one can imagine that he facilitated the appointment of the conductores, intervened with the existing coloni, or even served as procurator of the Regio Thuggensis. He might have been involved with the local quarries as well.
The case of the Pullaienii of Uchi Maius is more complicated: not only did they have an estate, the Praedia Pullaienorum, which sported its own aqueduct, but they also produced lamps and other pottery for export into the whole of the western Mediterranean. In 126 CE, Sex. Pullaienus Florus was praefectus iure dicundo at Carthage, and at least two of his descendants achieved senatorial rank. Not surprisingly, he was honored not only in his hometown but also in neighboring Thugga and Thubursicum Bure. We are dealing here, then, with a regional elite who maintained communication with their hometowns but strived for admittance into the elite of the capital.
For S. the family temples formed essential nodes in their networks. They acted as museums for elaborate displays of family pride, with statues of ancestors side by side with those of emperors, shining in their imperial light. The courtyards could also provide spaces in which to host banquets for local associations – magistri, coloni, and so on – to which it was possible to invite one's peers. The euergetic inscriptions regularly mention these banquets. Even when the family was in residence in Carthage, the annual banquets would have kept its memory alive. This semi-private nature of the temples contrasts with those of the more prominent towns, where their altars and their façades along the processional streets brought them into direct contact with the ordinary townsfolk. We must thus see the landscape of the pertica as a network, both of the individuals and of the buildings that represented them. The network provided mutual support for its members, as well as an arena for competition and a launch for advancement elsewhere.
After making this convincing argument, the book concludes with a catalog of the 24 towns in the micro-region, most of them complemented by elegant plans at the identical scale of 1:3,000. I wish that a similar policy had been followed inside the volume, where using identical, rational scales for comparison of buildings has been sacrificed for a symmetrical layout. There is no index, although directories of inscriptions, texts, people, and places without page references suggests that something went missing, but this is the only major flaw in an otherwise fine and convincing volume.
In an article that appeared slightly later, but too early for her to have been aware of S.'s work, Monica Hellström came to similar, if slightly different, conclusions.Footnote 11 Starting from the epigraphy, and without addressing the physical remains, she remarks on the bulge that the multiple dedications of these temples creates if we look at the statistics for all of African building activity over time, as well as the fact that the elites who created them only rarely signed any other form of building. Baths, theaters, and amphitheaters remain largely anonymous. An exception would appear to be the theater at Thugga, paid for by P. Marcius Quadratus and decorated with statues of his family, but the presence of a dedication to Ceres Prataria found in its ruins suggests that this, too, was a religious foundation.Footnote 12 If the local people presumably knew who paid for these secular monuments, we do not. Furthermore, we see in this area very little collective action: the city councils did not tend to put up buildings (a point also made by S.). She concludes that the temples, with their family statues, enabled the aspirational elites to perform for Carthage, showing off their local power to achieve it in the capital. The late grants of municipal status to these towns finally cut them off from Carthage and coincided with the end of the generous spate of temple building, confirming that the two were related. The local elites could no longer aspire to positions in the capital. H. notes that this boom in municipal promotions constituted a significant loss of power for Carthage.
Both authors, then, explain the forms of the cityscapes in the micro-region in terms of what H. calls the “geography of ambition,” their relationship to Carthage. Both are largely right, although I tend to accept S.'s rather broader analysis of the regional networks over a simpler view of performance for Carthaginian prestige. It is hard to see how the Carthaginian elite knew what was happening in the countryside unless, of course, they were invited to the family dinner parties. There is, however, an aspect to these buildings which both S. and H. tend to set aside, and that is their sacred character. It is a bit surprising to find temples analyzed only as prestige monuments, museums, and clubhouses. While S. is certainly correct in pointing to the luxury of the gardens in, for example, the courtyard of the temple at Dar Lacheb at Thugga, one should note that a lucus or sacred grove was an important religious component of a sanctuary.Footnote 13 The beds here are usually walled off by low barriers, perhaps not only to avoid trampling the shrubs or trees but also to keep the little lucus inviolate. The courtyard that contains the lucus is dominated by the aedes, often raised on a high podium, with a stair running down into the center of the court. Is it too obvious to say that the primary role of the sanctuaries must have been as religious structures?
Further, although many of the donors had gained the flaminate of their city, what we know of the deities to whom they dedicated their temples reveals a hodgepodge of gods. It appears that the donors’ relationship to these was deeply personal. We will never know what Concordia, Liber Pater, Frugifer, and Neptune meant to A. Gabinius Datus and his sons, or what Fortuna, Venus Concordia, and Mercury Augustus meant to Q. Maedius Severus and his daughter, but it seems hard to believe that they were simply chosen at random, rather than being ancestral or at least personal cults. On the other hand, imperial cult buildings are correspondingly few: of these, aside from the initial dedications of a temple to Caesar, the temple to the deified Victories of Caracalla at Thugga is the only one that panders directly to the imperial house (although almost all mention the reigning emperor in their dedications). The fact that each of these buildings displays an inscribed dedication by its donor, usually on the architraves of the porticoes in front of the temples, and that subsequent additions are similarly signed, suggests that they were advertising their benefactions not only for their fellow citizens but also for the gods themselves. Why else would we find the discrepancy between the dedications of sacred and secular buildings that H.'s work underlines?
Finally, the position of the temples is not unimportant. At Thugga and at Thuburbo Maius the temples of Mercury are central, and closely related to the markets; they played a role in sanctifying the transactions that took place there.Footnote 14 The courtyard temples are imbricated into the residential areas at Thugga, the deities participating in the daily life of the town, and, at Thugga's theater or temple B1 even in theatrical performances, like those in front of the Magna Mater in Rome.Footnote 15 Farther out, Thugga is ringed by a fortification of suburban sanctuaries: Juno Regina, and the terraced sanctuaries of the two Caelestes and Saturn, both open to the countryside rather than hidden within a temenos, no matter how luxurious. Only the second temple of Minerva, above the town, preserves a courtyard in the Romano-African fashion, although on a very grand scale.
Peter Brown writes that
The age of the Antonines is the last period of Mediterranean history before the Middle Ages when a “model of parity” and a stress on the community as a whole could be given full-blooded expression in terms of the ceremonies of the traditional religion … The benefactor gave over wealth to the gods who, as invisible and immortal, stood for all that could be shared by the community.Footnote 16
These “beneficent deities,” according to Macrobius of Mactar, “possessed their forum,” to the general approval of the populace. (Aug. Ep. 16). Thugga, with its shrines large and small, seems to have been equally possessed. The smell of the smoke from the multiple altars will have played a real role in its cityscape. This is not to deny the role of ambition, competition, and self-representation in the construction of the temples, but to remind us that their principal function was as sacra.
