This concise, lucid and thoroughly researched book closely examines the 1991 film Falling Down, in which Michael Douglas plays a laid-off defence worker who embarks on a crime spree as he travels across Los Angeles. Davies informs us that the film belongs to a 1990s cycle of “talkies” that “set out to provoke discussion among audiences” (118) and the book appears in Palgrave Macmillan's Controversies series. The specific controversy here stems from the film's conscious reference to contemporaneous “media events” of urban violence, including the case of “vigilante killer” Bernhard Goetz and the killing of Latasha Harlins by Soon Ja Du (83), and a more general channeling of “white paranoia,” especially as this came to a head around the time of the Los Angeles riots in April and May 1992. The film's incendiary nature, Davies tells us, stems from its complex relations with this divided and violent cultural context.
The introductory section consists of a clear and useful (interpretative) plot summary and an engaging account of the collaboration between the key players involved in the film's production. Davies notes that Douglas appeared in a number of “talkies” in the 1990s, including Basic Instinct and Disclosure, and became “a kind of Rorschach test” for divisive popular issues (27). In collaboration with screenwriter Ebbe Roe Smith and director Joel Schumacher, Douglas sought to bring his star persona to bear on the character of William “D-Fens” Foster, seeking ways to stay true to the screenplay's raw depiction of Foster's white rage while also eliciting audience sympathy (25–26). This section of the book neatly indicates how the different visions and close collaboration of the production team generated a complex, multifaceted film replete with ambiguity around its central character, with Douglas's performance “drawing audiences in, then alienating them, only to draw them in again” (51).
Davies shows how, upon release, the film provided a litmus test for a range of political perspectives, each traced via meticulous work on the film's reception. Davies notes,
On the one hand, from socially liberal and leftist perspectives, the [film's depiction of Los Angeles] provided a kind of test case of the effects of Reaganite Republicans’ national policies of cutting taxes and government spending. On the other hand, from a right-wing perspective, the breakdown of aspects of civil society in Falling Down's Los Angeles could be attributed to large-scale immigration and policies of multiculturalism. (42)
But Davies argues that these either/or readings are inevitably reductive and traces logical flaws in the arguments of both sides, as well as detailing a range of opinions that offer insight into the “provocation, ambiguity, and incoherence” at the heart of the film (57).
Davies states that the film displays a “surplus of signification around violence, whiteness, masculinity, and sexuality” (101), and a key strength of the book is the careful textual analysis of key scenes, performances and mise en scène. This analysis clearly conveys how the film portrays Los Angeles as “a balkanised, territorialised place fractured along lines of ethnicity, class, and gender” (39), and evidences the claim that the “film marks a pivotal moment in the trajectory of identity representation in American cinema” (119).
A central preoccupation of both film and book is the cultural phenonomenon of the “angry white male.” Davies demonstrates how audiences and critics were torn in their sense of identification with D-Fens and their hostility or sympathy towards his attitudes to racial and gendered difference. To make sense of this, Davies places the film in relation to wider cycles of films that precede and relate to this perceived crisis in white masculinity. This section of the book is exemplary, bringing to bear critical literature from varied disciplines – film studies, American studies, gender studies, the study of whiteness, and so on – in order to position the film in relation to this broad cultural context. The book is particularly strong in its exploration of the privileged relationship between Anglo-American and African American male characters and points of view, at the expense of others.
By these means, Davies demonstrates that the film is indeed controversial, but also complex, ambiguous and multifaceted. Davies endorses Sharon Willis's view that the film is “a kind of ideological centrifuge with respect to multicultural society; that is, it scatters all differences around the central force field emanating from the white middle-class family man, as if differences could only be positioned in relation to him and his radically individual identity” (Willis quoted at 75). However, in addition to Willis's ultimately condemnatory reading, Davies seeks some potential in the film's resistance to a singular preferred reading, noting,
In the popular controversy and in much academic criticism, [Falling Down] has been interpreted negatively, either as a nightmare vision of multiculturalism, shorthand for a nation divided into special interest groups, and/or one suffering for its lack of traditional (patriarchal, white) values. Such readings position Falling Down as a rejection of and withdrawal from multiculturalism. Yet the ending's lack of resolution may also point towards the need, not to abandon the project, but to perfect it. (114)
Ranging far beyond simply a close analysis of Falling Down, Davies's book provides significant insight into the formation and maturation of the culture wars, especially as these relate to white masculinity, and is excellent for gaining orientation to post-1980s political fallout; the 1990s are a notoriously difficult decade to get a handle on, culturally and politically speaking, and this book helps a great deal.
