A promising toddler has her development devastated by the side effects of an inoculation. An eleven-year-old lures a younger child into its confidence, then callously murders him. Childhood sexual precocity is all around. Meanwhile schools, supposed guardians of children's wellbeing, are so focused on test results that they discourage the less able from their rolls and drum the competent full of mechanical learning. Mothers are alarmed by these lamentable features of childhood, and all too aware that it is their own errors in parenting that may most harm their children's chances, even perhaps in utero. To cater to their concerns, parenting guides from the stern to the supportive proliferate.
All these features of childhood, familiar from the present day, feature in Sally Shuttleworth's superb study of child psychology in the nineteenth century. The parallels are often uncanny, and just as in contemporary discourse the ‘normal’ child is largely displaced from cultural sight by the morbid of mind and behaviour. The mind of the child that we encounter in this book is rarely an ordinary (or happy) one, and enjoyable mental activities constantly threaten to verge upon the pathological.
Shuttleworth's study begins at the tail end of the Romantic period when the child was innately innocent and best raised by allowing him to exercise his freedom. Insanity, which depended upon there being a will or a morality to traduce, was a category error in the child. As night terrors and other morbidities of mind were gradually admitted to child psychology during the early nineteenth century, it was often the nurse or other irruptions from lower-class life that took the blame: causes that were educational or moral in nature. Slowly, a medical framework came to replace a Christian one; lying resulted in a terrifying physical prognosis rather than the fires of hell.
A turning point came in 1860 when James Crichton Browne published his essay ‘Psychical diseases of early life’, which confidently identified morbidity in the young mind – even prenatally – and asserted its hereditary, not learned, nature. Shuttleworth makes the point that despite the post-Origin date of Crichton Browne's essay, it was not Darwinian in nature and capped off an alternate ancestry of discussion about innate and heritable insanity. To me, this was the more interesting half of the book; tackling the period after Darwin got properly into the psychologists' theories, the author passes into a more familiar terrain of savages, femininity and animality in relation to the mind of the child. (George Romanes's confident ascription of mental parity between a seven-week-old child and a mollusc is a particular high point, though not necessarily any sillier than the 2007 evolutionary psychology paper that concluded that girls like pink because they need to be better at hunting for berries.)
Just as Darwin is taken down a peg or two in relation to his scientific priority in child psychology, so too Freud. Shuttleworth finds earlier discussions of childhood sexuality, and connects up the long-term fear of masturbation with other concerns that linked childhood studies throughout the nineteenth century. Precocity, that sexually loaded description, leaked into discussions of learning, social intercourse, physical activity and fantasy. Put together, these themes make up a rich and representative account of the problematic features of Victorian childhood. The professionalization and objectivization of child psychology is a fascinating sub-plot to Shuttleworth's book: the ways in which men made children (even babies!) a respectable area of study. Or, in other terms, how to look in the cradle without stooping.
This is one of those books that makes so much sense that one cannot believe it has not been written before, so skilfully does it put together some of the best-known children of nineteenth-century fiction with then contemporary theories of childhood and the mind. From the point of view of literature and science studies, this book is noteworthy as it provides a rare and concrete example of literature shaping science; Victorian psychiatrists often plundered novels for their archetypes and case studies. Although Shuttleworth's heart seems to be with Charlotte Brontë and George Eliot, it was the historicized readings of The Turn of the Screw and What Maisie Knew that I found especially revealing. Shuttleworth also brings her sensitive literary critic's ear to scientific descriptions, deftly revealing their hidden meanings. She is to be praised for this history of the all-too-fragile mind of the child: a psychological morbidity that was defined by the state of childhood and – as it still often seems to be today – vice versa. ‘Insanity is hereditary’, as the old car sticker ran; ‘I got it from my kids’.
