Following their triumph with the newly published seventh edition of Scott-Brown, I was fascinated to see a flyer from Hodder Arnold for what is now the 25th, silver jubilee edition of that hardy perennial Bailey and Love's Short Practice of Surgery. A review in the specialist Journal of Laryngology & Otology might be more relevant than is at first apparent.
The book does of course have an ENT section, which is considerably expanded when compared with my disintegrating copy used in preparation for MBBS in 1976. It continues to be the standard undergraduate textbook, and we must remember that, for so many, this will be their only exposure to our speciality, or at least until they are suddenly thrown out into general practice. It is far more advanced than I recall and, so, will be invaluable to our trainees facing higher surgical exams, notably the UK MRCS. I had thought that it would be a useful ENT departmental purchase, but it turns out to be remarkably affordable for any individual trainee. At the time of review, the discounted price of £82.50 is simply amazing value and surely only possible in a textbook with lifetime sales in excess of one million (see website: www.baileyandlove.com).
The head and neck makes up 130 of a total of over 1400 pages, but there is much else directly relevant to us. The thyroid belongs to others to judge by the layout, but I hear the howls from the West Midlands already. The oesophagus makes up a personal favourite chapter, also found elsewhere. The opening chapter on the head and neck is curiously entitled ‘elective’ neurosurgery, as it then nicely covers frontal sinus induced anterior cranial fossa abscess, a similar subdural empyema and a posterior fossa haemorrhage, all far from routine waiting list material! The eye chapter, in practice, concentrates far more on the orbit, and, as a result, there is almost more here for the otolaryngologist than the ophthalmologist, e.g. ethmoidal osteomas, dysthyroid eye disease and blow-out fracture. The nose and sinus chapter, from Rob Ruckley, opens with an illustration of a nasal fracture in what looks suspiciously like a self-portrait. The ear chapter similarly features, amongst excellent pictures, a view of the author Grant Bates, straining to demonstrate use of the Otovent. The resulting unforgettable image had this reviewer laughing aloud. I doubt that undergraduates will spot that the blisters of Ramsay Hunt syndrome are on the wrong pinna, but they might wonder if that is actually a bilateral acoustic neuroma in the MRI beneath. David Howard and Valerie Lund provide a very well illustrated chapter on the pharynx, larynx and neck and we must hope the lesson gets through; seek the ENT primary tumour before excising that suspected ‘branchial cyst’. Chapters on cleft lip and palate, oesophageal cancer and salivary gland disorders show just how skilled our maxillofacial colleagues are in documenting and photographing their triumphs. These are of Peter Bull standard and nearly as bloodless.
It was good to see that the traditional peptic ulcer operations of the 60s and 70s are not completely redundant since the discovery of H pylori threatened many a flourishing academic surgical unit. I was sure that one of the best medical illustrations of all time could not still survive the editor's cuts, three decades on, but no, there it still is. That chap in the trilby is still splayed astride an upturned manhole cover, evoking all our sympathy as we cringe for him.
Sections on endoscopic surgery, transplantation, imaging that once seemed the stuff of science fiction, sports medicine and disaster surgery all show how this book reflects the changes in surgical practice and our teaching over the decades. Truly inspiring, if making one feel that some time has passed since medical school days. This is superb value and a great revision for us all.
