“Now-a-days, the man who says that he knows the ravel of the inter-tribal complications across the Border is of much more use…” (Rudyard Kipling, Plain Tales from the Hills [New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1899], p. 323)
Christian Tripodi's Edge of Empire: The British Political Officer and Tribal Administration on the North-West Frontier, 1877–1947 is a straightforward account of the British administrative presence in what was known as the North-West Frontier (the modern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa). As Tripodi points out in his introduction, the players involved here—that is, the native groups inhabiting this area (in particular, the Pashtun, but also the Baluchi tribes), as well as the British political agents who governed the region—have long been represented in caricature: whereas the Pashtun and Baluchi are typically depicted as fiercely independent warriors, renowned equally for their rigorous conduct as for their barbarism, British political agents are invariably represented as wise, paternal bearers of civilization, but also as staunch adventurers “still tinged by the romantic nature of the task” (p. 5). Although Tripodi warns against blindly accepting these Kiplingesque characterizations, they are in Tripodi's account not entirely baseless, contributing significantly to his recounting of how a scant collection of British political agents maintained the interests of Empire in the vast reaches of the notoriously inhospitable North-West Frontier.
The focus of Tripodi's account is the figure of the British political agent. This is a departure from previous studies of this topic, which, as Tripodi notes, look primarily to “the tribes and their unrelenting resistance to external control” (p. 1). This focus on the cultural elite obviously stands apart from the modern trend that seeks out voices long buried in the subaltern world. The narrative of the Edge of Empire is framed largely by chronology: each chapter in the book (there are eight), with the exception of the first (“Who were the Politicals?”) is marked by its epoch—1877–92 (chapter 2); 1892–1900 (chapter 3); 1900–14 (chapter 4); 1914–24 (chapter 5); 1924–30 (chapter 6); 1930–39 (chapter 7); and 1939–47 (chapter 8)—and framed by discussions of how particular policies were implemented by the individual political agents standing along this timeline. Throughout, Tripodi attends to the larger contextual issues that rippled through the region (e.g., the longstanding threat by the Russians to occupy Afghanistan and the rising sense of Muslim identity during the Great War), as well as to those issues specific to the administration of the North-West Frontier (e.g., the 1897 Uprising, the economics of deploying of regular forces in the region, and the arguments for allotting self-rule to the native tribes).
Along with this linear narrative, Tripodi attends to the important conceptual issues underlying the British governance of this vast region. This is evident in his examination of the seminal figure of Sir Robert Sandeman, Agent to the Governor General of Baluchistan from 1877 until his death in 1892. Tripodi examines the practical elements of the “system” devised by Sandeman as an exemplar of British administration (that is, a system that maintained its control over a vast expanse and a fractious, indeed, often hostile population using just handful of agents while expending minimal funds), but does not lose sight of its essential duplicity; for, though it appeared to benefit the native inhabitants, as Tripodi points out this was not its essential design. In brief, the system depended upon what was in effect a fictitious system of native “self-rule”—one that supported and maintained a fair degree of tribal autonomy throughout the region, which, not unintentionally, ensured that no single force would rise up to overwhelm the British. To stave off uprisings, Sandeman's system gave at least some emphasis to creating positive social and economic programs such as access to medical supplies, creation of railroads, improvements in irrigation, and the opening of schools. But, in the end, as Tripodi argues, Sandeman's “system” was merely a means to maintain British interests: “Beyond anything else, Sandeman was an ardent imperialist and one who sought advantage for his country as well as himself at every given opportunity” (p. 60). As Tripodi's narrative reveals, this pattern—a veneer of support for native interests, but an underlying reality of expediency in maintaining British hegemony—was dominant through the period of British rule, though the actors and the issues changed over time.
Christian Tripodi's Edge of Empire is, throughout, a work of solid scholarship. Although the author tends to depict the main actors in somewhat stereotyped terms, given that the British administration of the North-West Frontier was, at its heart, a ruthless enterprise, Tripodi's depiction is perhaps not unwarranted. Larger questions—e.g., the legitimacy of the Empire itself—are not addressed.
