Kate Cooper's The Fall of the Roman Household is a complex, ambitious and stimulating study of the transformation of the ‘classical’ Roman family between the Roman Empire and the Middle Ages. The book is based on the close study of an interesting set of texts dealing with the Christian attitude of lay people between the end of the fourth century and the beginning of the sixth. It addresses the way the Roman household changed under the influence of Christianity, and the way the clerical discourse to lay people evolved in dealing with questions relevant to family, marriage and household.
The book is organized in five chapters clearly presented in the introduction (xiii–xiv). Ch. 1 presents a set of Latin texts which the author suggests form a corpus of works dealing with lay spirituality over the ‘long fifth century’: the Vita Genovefae, Commodian's Instructions, Jerome's Letter to Eustochium, Pelage's Ad Demetriadem, Ferrandus’ Letter to Reginus, the Passio Sebastiani, and last but not least Ad Gregoriam in Palatio presented as ‘an anonymous conduct manual addressed to a senatorial domina of the fifth or early sixth century’, of which a very useful English translation is included in the volume (239–83). This last text is actually central to the study, which sometimes turns into a study of the Ad Gregoriam, with complementary material based on other pieces of evidence. But more texts are put forward within the other chapters, and it is one of the great merits of the book that it draws attention to so many underrated, sometimes almost unknown texts, which are not only quoted in the long list of primary sources, but accurately studied. Ch. 2, ‘The obscurity of eloquence’, undertakes a broad examination of literary culture in the period ranging from the poetess Proba (second half of the fourth century) to Gregory the Great, focusing mainly on the beginning of the sixth century and what is called the ‘Ostrogothic renaissance’. Ch. 3, ‘Household and empire’, considers the way of life and the religious and moral values of what is repeatedly called the ‘senatorial laity’ (the emphasis here being on ‘senatorial’). Ch. 4, ‘Such trustful partnership’, focuses on letters of advice to married couples, and develops ideas about the Christian concept of marriage as opposed to the Roman traditional one; it is really the core of the study as presented in the Preface. The last chapter, ‘The invisible enemy’, broadens the view on Christian morals and spirituality to depict the ‘wider Christian vision of life as a spiritual battle’ (xv).
As it is, the book makes challenging reading. The reader is constantly invited to question his or her views on matters as important as the way lay people contributed to shaping ancient Christianity, or the changing role of élites in late Roman society, to say nothing of the question of marriage, on which C. makes a major contribution. The wealth of data presented, linked to a very wide and, for once, truly international bibliography, makes it an important addition to late antique studies. At the same time, the reader might find it difficult to follow the author in all her paths.
The main difficulty comes from chronology. The texts presented in ch. 1 are supposed to illustrate the ‘long fifth century’ (ix) but some cannot easily be dated to this period. The Vita Genovefae might have been ‘almost certainly written c.520’ (3), but the text we actually have was edited much later. Commodian's Instructions are included here, following Courcelle's hypothesis of a fifth-century date, but the traditional view of Commodian as a Christian author of the second half of the third century is dismissed with no convincing argument in a footnote (13). As for the Ad Gregoriam in Palatio, it is dated (6) to the late fifth to early sixth century, but more detailed information is given on pp. 44–5, stating that it belongs to ‘the period between Valentinian III (425–455) and Theodoric the Great (493–526) and probably (to) the reign of Theoderic’. The only positive argument, the mention both of an emperor and a king in the text, a situation which would only fit the reign of Theoderic, is not convincing. As a result, the chronological frame of the study might vary from the third to the very end of the sixth century. This is not a matter of fussy erudition. From the chronological setting depends the social definition of the ‘senatorial’ milieu which is the subject of a large part of the study. How different is a Proba, member of one of the greatest families of Rome at the height of its fame and wealth in the fourth century, from a Genovefa, land-holder in the small city of Nanterre and local celebrity in Paris in the fifth century? And where — in the middle or elsewhere — should Gregoria be placed? Genovefa might have ‘held the rank of clarissima femina’, but the rank itself is not enough to characterize a social group. The reader feels uncomfortable reading of ‘women at this level of society’ (74: but which level of what sort of society?), or of the ‘men of Gregoria's social sphere’ (88). Jumping from Vandal Africa to Imperial Rome, from Merovingian Gaul to Ostrogothic Italy, the study actually covers a wide range of different situations and fails to convince that a proper social sphere has been defined. It does not make it a less interesting read, but it prevents the reader from understanding it as an historical study of a coherent social group.
What remains is no little achievement. Beside the amazing amount of knowledge it displays and the impressive range of new ideas on various subjects, The Fall of the Roman Household deeply renews our understanding of the relations between clerics and lay people in Late Antiquity and of the birth and evolution of a Christian idea of marriage.
