War is costly. This fact has sent millions to protest in the streets, has led to the downfall of dozens of regimes, has generated countless intergovernmental and nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) focused on promoting peace, and has led many young men and women to an early grave. Among many researchers focused on conflict, the assumption that war is costly not only guides our theoretical approach but also motivates our decision to study conflict as a lifelong pursuit. To this point, researchers have studied the costs of conflict largely in terms of economic decline, political consequences, reconstruction, and the fate of leaders (inter alia). Zaryab Iqbal's War and the Health of Nations takes a unique approach by studying the costs of conflict for individuals, focusing on “the manner in which violent conflict influences the degree of health and well-being enjoyed by a population” (p. 29).
Iqbal's theoretical approach fits squarely within the “human security” agenda. This multidisciplinary approach comes as a reaction to more conventional approaches, such as realism, which focus on state-level consequences of warfare, such as territorial sovereignty and the proliferation of nuclear weapons. Rather than focusing on the security of states, the human security agenda recognizes that “it is the security of populations … that makes the world more secure” (p. 5). By shifting the unit of analysis away from the state to the individual, Iqbal's goal is to explain the relationship between conflict and public health in order to place human security at the forefront of decision making at the global, regional, national, and local levels. This is done by focusing on five processes by which conflict impacts individual health, including direct casualties, the destruction of infrastructure, economic decline, resource diversion, and refugee flows. The outline of the book follows this format. The author begins with an excellent explanation of the human security agenda, coupled with a forceful argument of how and why it deserves careful scientific scrutiny. Subsequent chapters are geared toward providing empirical evidence of the five processes, including public health (Chapter 4), fertility rates, infant mortality and life expectancy (Chapter 5), infrastructure defined as immunization and telephone ownership, for example (Chapter 6), diversion of funds from health to the military (Chapter 7), and refugee flows (Chapter 8).
The strengths of this study are many. Foremost, the focus on the plight of wars for individuals accurately captures the concepts most scholars consider when they think of “costs,” and Iqbal's analyses provide the best work to date on the true costs of conflict in both the short and long terms. Second, the human security agenda is an area of study that is often neglected in both research and teaching. Her book clarifies the utility of this approach and provides excellent background reading on the subject. Third, the book alternates from large-n empirical evidence to qualitative examples, providing for compelling reading without the danger of getting bogged down with either. This approach makes the book accessible to a wide range of audiences.
Despite the strengths, the book has a handful of notable weaknesses. Rather than being the fault of the author's approach, however, these are mainly due to the unavailability of data and the paucity of theoretical work in this area. As such, they should be thought of less as weaknesses and more as opportunities for further advancement in the area. Beginning with the theory, there is little here that will strike the reader as particularly surprising. War is expected to harm human security, and this effect should strengthen as the duration and intensity of the war increase. This basic hypothesis leaves plenty of room for theoretical development. Future research might ask what types of civil conflicts (e.g., secessionist, sons of the soil, decolonization) are more costly than others, or how the costs of war differ among various interstate conflicts (e.g., hegemonic, proxy, limited). Work could also move toward a better understanding of the efforts of policymakers to focus on the human security agenda. How effective are efforts by NGOs to improve health in refugee camps, for example, and do state efforts to provide humanitarian aid effectively shelter individuals from the costs of warfare?
Regarding the empirical results, Iqbal faces difficulties in obtaining data for many states over a long period. The Health-Adjusted Life Expectancy (HALE) measure put out by the World Health Organization, for instance, is available only from 1999 to 2002. Given that conflicts are rare events, the lack of data clearly confounds efforts to test causal relationships. It is unsurprising that the author fails to find overwhelming support for several key hypotheses. Even in testing dependent variables with large samples, such as life expectancy and fertility rates, she frequently finds little evidence to support her hypotheses (often depending on what region is under study). The many instances of inconclusive results should be viewed not as a condemnation of the book, however, but as fruitful channels for further theoretical development and as evidence of the need for more data to better understand human security.
Ultimately, this book largely accomplishes what Iqbal set out to achieve. It shifts the focus to the individual, and provides compelling evidence that war is harmful in a number of key areas. The empirical results give policymakers sound evidence to guide their efforts to address the consequences of warfare, and I expect this community to benefit greatly from the book. Iqbal likewise provides researchers with a better understanding of the costs of conflict, which provides a basis for common assumptions in the literature. It is to be hoped that War and the Health of Nations will be a seminal piece in future studies of the costs of conflict within the human security agenda. There remain numerous paths for future theoretical and empirical development. As such, I expect it to be well read among scholars devoted to the study of conflict processes. Finally, this is an excellent example of how the rigorous quantitative approach can be blended with qualitative evidence to provide a book that is accessible on many levels. One should not hesitate to assign it for either an undergraduate or graduate course.
