This is a very well-researched and well-written monograph on how the Shiءa of South Lebanon negotiated a Lebanese Shiءi identity for themselves amid two dominant ideologies—Libanism and Arabism—in both of which Shiءa were marginalized. The book covers the events of Jabal ءAmil—a geographic and cultural entity with a Shiءi majority—from the collapse of Ottoman rule in the Levant in 1918 to the independence of Lebanon from the French Mandate, in 1943. It offers a reading of the history and politics of national aspirations, the efforts of integration into the newly created Lebanese state, and the disagreements among Southern Lebanese Shiءi political leaders and landowners, religious elites, and intellectuals.
The book is divided into two parts. The first part discusses the larger political changes that Shiءa faced during that period, especially caught between Faysal's national vision and opportunities offered to them by the French Mandate. The second part explains how these Shiءa reacted and adapted to new realities—for example, through creating and further developing schools and through producing a history of the community and circulating narratives of the newly created nation, through an influential press organ, al-ءIrfan.
Chapter 1 describes Jabal ءAmil's geography, the composition of the community, the regional economy, and its relations to Mount Lebanon by relying mainly on local and European travel accounts. Chapter 2 focuses on the intellectual and cultural milieu of Jabal ءAmil. It shows how three influential ءAmili Shiءi intellectuals, Shaykh Sulayman Dahir, Ahmad Rida, and Muhammad Jabir al-Safa, helped construct one dominant historical narrative of their community in the post-Ottoman era, one that situated ءAmili Shiءa in Sunni-dominated Arab nationalist discourse and as staunch enemies of the French Mandate. In Chapter 3, Chalabi challenges this historical narrative and presents the diversity of ءAmilis' interests, caught among aspirations for regional independence from both the French Mandate and Syria, annexation to Greater Syria, and integration into the Lebanese state.
Chapter 4 begins with the reality of 1920, the year of the creation of Grand Liban, when parts of Jabal ءAmil—despite the wishes of many of its inhabitants—became the province of South Lebanon, a marginalized region viewed only as an extension of Mount Lebanon. In this chapter, Chalabi explains how various Shiءa adapted to this transformation and reacted to the dominant Libanist national narrative, either by becoming members of leftist and secular parties or by participating in the state. In Chapter 5, the author shows how the community came to grips with being part of the Maronite-dominated Lebanese state, and developed tools, such as maṭlabiyya, the politics of demand, to integrate into Lebanese national life. By writing petitions and expressing their demands in publications, the ءAmili Shiءi elite secured rights from the French Mandate. These efforts were part of institutionalizing Shiءa as a separate community. In Chapter 6, the author explains, for example, how the creation of Shiءa-specific institutions strengthened the power of the Shiءi religious elite in Lebanon and served as means of integration into the Lebanese state. In Chapter 7, the final chapter, the author shows how Shiءi intellectuals, as part of their efforts to fit into this new nation, created a specifically South Lebanese Shiءi narrative, a history dominated by the community as a coherent unit bound to a specific geographical location, along the lines of the Maronite model.
Although the book generally achieves its goal of explaining the debates among ءAmili Shiءa and their strategies to create a space for themselves in the new Lebanon, it remains a study of ءAmili elites. The tobacco protest in Bint Jubayl in 1936, for instance, in which peasants played an important role, is discussed in only three pages. Finally, the author suggests that studies of Arab Shiءa have explained communities' histories above all in relation to links to Iran or Najaf (pp. 6–7). Although in the period between 1918 and 1943, which is the focus of this book, transnational ties to Iran perhaps did not play such a large role in identity production among Lebanese Shiءa (whereas ties to Najaf surely did), it certainly has been the case since the Iranian Revolution. However, the maintenance of transnational Shiءi ties does not necessarily imply that Lebanese Shiءa—as well as other Arab Shiءa—do not exercise any agency in producing their identities, nor does a focus on such ties exclude the possibility of studying the Lebanese Shiءi community as “an independent entity” defined above all through its relations with communities in the immediate neighborhood, as the author suggests (p. 7). Ties between Iranian and Lebanese Shiءa have indeed affected Shiءi intercommunal and intracommunal politics as well as Lebanese national life. This said, the book will be required reading for scholars generally interested in sectarian politics in the Middle East and scholars specifically interested in Lebanese Shiءi history and politics because the rich account it offers is also helpful for positioning Shiءi activism in Lebanon since the 1960s.
