After describing a community of female journalists and how they found one another, Alice Fahs produces an in-depth character-based study that has at its heart the representative story of Margherita Arlina Hamm, author of the column “Among the Newspaper Women” published in the New York Journalist:
Hamm is not remembered today as part of journalism history, much less the history of women. But in this neglect she is far from alone: we know little about most of the women who took up newspaper work at the turn of the century and created new public spaces for women in print. Instead, the history of newspaper women follows well-worn grooves: it highlights the daring of the pioneering and influential Nellie Bly (Elizabeth Jane Cochrane); it discusses the so-called sob sisters who covered the notorious 1907–8 trials of Harry K. Thaw for the murder of architect Stanford White. These were prominent women, to be sure. But in between we have missed an entire generation of female journalists and a richly networked public community (2).
Fahs adds what becomes more and more clear throughout Out on Assignment: Newspaper Women and the Making of Modern Public Space: “Many of the women who are the subjects of this book have been hiding in plain sight for over a century” (2).
In Out on Assignment and Women Writers and Journalists in the Nineteenth-Century South, Alice Fahs and Jonathan Daniel Wells have done themselves proud, producing scholarship about topics long overdue, researching primary and secondary sources with energy and insight, maintaining sensitivity to race and ethnicity as well as gender, and writing with skill and deep commitment to the narratives they bring to life. Their books are in a sense “first studies,” landmark works that will inspire other scholars and provide reliable texts for future research.
Author of The Imagined Civil War: Popular Literature of the North and South, 1861–1865 (2001), Fahs tells the stories of women seeking a journalistic career in urban America at the turn of the century. Individually and collectively, these women created a public voice by producing advice columns, essays in support of suffrage, interviews with celebrities, personal stories about “bachelor girls,” and sketches of urban life. Interspersed throughout the book, compressed narratives about particular women are effective because they are organized around compelling themes.
The beautifully designed and carefully edited Out on Assignment is divided into seven chapters: “Among the Newspaper Women,” which serves as a second introduction to the book and deals with the careers of white, middle-class women and the impact of the newspaper circulation wars on the workforce; “The Woman's Page,” which defines sections of newspapers dedicated to women as a “way of developing a woman's reading public, of connecting with other women in communities of conversation that sometimes had a national reach” (65); and “Human Interest,” which acknowledges that politics and foreign news did not draw all readers and that advice columns and information about daily events—some of them sensational—had their place.
Other chapters include “Bachelor Girls,” a phrase used to describe women dependent on their own salaries but in no hurry to marry—these women wanted “an apartment and suffrage” (161); “Adventure,” which describes women who engaged in daring deeds and stunts; “Work,” which introduces stories about city life, the economy, strikes, unions, and other topics; and “Travel,” which deals with women who covered politics and war and gained exposure to global issues and ways of life. A brief and pertinent epilogue, “Toward Suffrage,” summarizes the study and points to the future. Importantly, it addresses female reporters who promoted feminism, suffrage, and lives in the public sphere.
Out on Assignment has other strengths. Advertisements, announcements, drawings, photographs of women, and reproductions of newspaper pages are interspersed throughout. In addition, Fahs notes that stories by women allowed experimentation with style, which contributed to the differences between hard news and soft news—between news gathering and feature writing—as they are understood today. Fahs provides examples of these stylistic experiments.
Conflicts about the nature of news for and by women are a part of newspaper history. According to Fahs, editors who might at one time have preferred that all women remain in the home began to realize the importance of providing wide-ranging topics for consumption by an increasingly literate and news-hungry public. In many cases, tiresome and limited news about home and hearth became the entryway for women into a newspaper world dominated by William Randolph Hearst, Adolph Ochs, Joseph Pulitzer, and others.
Women's pages and features for women readers were, therefore, a double-edged sword; they allowed female reporters a place in a male-dominated industry but limited many of them by creating another kind of prison. To no one's surprise, women disagreed then and now about whether or not newspapers limit or liberate them. As recently as 1990, when newspaper subscriptions began to slide, the Chicago Tribune created “Womanews,” a prototype that sought to define and dispense news of particular interest to women. Eventually, “Womanews” became part of another section called “Tempo,” but in time it disappeared entirely. Although this experiment falls outside of the timeframe in Fahs's study, it points to a continuing concern about whether news of particular appeal to women appears on the front pages of American newspapers.
Of special interest are the reasons women left newspapers after struggling so valiantly to join their staffs. In part, according to Fahs, women often “left newspaper work as they discovered that they had no chance of advancement, that the work was unsatisfying or too grueling over the long term, or that they could not make ends meet when they had to scratch out a living by the published column inch” (9).
However, many women remained deeply devoted to their careers, sometimes risking their lives to maintain their places in the news industry. Even balloon ascensions could be dangerous work. Newspaper woman Lottie Germaine was injured when, researching a story, she fell from a balloon. To add insult to injury, she lost her job with the New York World during her convalescence.
Author of numerous books including The Origins of the Southern Middle Class, 1820–1861 (2004), Jonathan Daniel Wells tackles issues similar to those in Out on Assignment concerning women in journalism and literature. Women Writers and Journalists in the Nineteenth-Century South is divided into three parts (“Foundations,” “Women Journalists and Writers in the Old South,” and “Women Journalists and Writers in the New South”). Each part is divided into several chapters: “Reading, Literary Magazines, and the Debate over Gender Equality,” “Education, Gender, and Community in the Nineteenth-Century South,” “Periodicals and Literary Culture,” “Female Authors and Magazine Writing,” “Antebellum Women Editors and Journalists,” “New South Periodicals and a New Literary Culture,” “Writing a New South for Women,” and “Postwar Women and Professional Journalism.”
The sprawling book begins with a quotation from William Faulkner's Absalom, Absalom! about the ways southern ladies too often became ghosts. Wells's goal is to turn these ghosts back into “real, flesh-and-blood historical actors” (1), not the social constructions they too often became. Schooled in historical and literary criticism, Wells explores the “incredibly rich, diverse, and fascinating worlds of white and black women's work in journalism” (2) and other genres between 1820 and 1900.
The primary strength of this ambitious book is its reliance on stories that encourage interest in learning more about forgotten women in a particular region during a particular time period. Here are a few examples:
Sarah Cooper handwrote her own literary magazine.
Rebecca Hicks asked in an editorial in her magazine The Kaleidoscope why men are assumed to be superior intellectually.
Nannie Grant and Paulina Warinner created four different magazines, The Ark, The Lone Star, The Casket, and The Wreath, which contained handwritten advertisements, biographies, editorials, poems, and stories.
Kate C. Wakelee wrote poetry during the Civil War but was often overlooked because of her quiet modesty. Another private woman, Mary E. Lee, taught herself French, German, and Italian and left behind poems, short stories, and translations.
Susan Petigru King exhorted the “horrors and sacrifice” (87) that marriage requires of women.
Mary Barney took on President Andrew Jackson.
Anne Newport Royall advocated for women's rights, attacked religious fundamentalism, defended Native Americans, and began a journalism career when she was in her fifties.
And Mary Edwards Bryan edited magazines and newspapers and wrote fiction and poetry during a “literary life that spanned nearly six decades” (144).
Women Writers and Journalists in the Nineteenth-Century South has been commended for being the “first study to focus on white and black women journalists and writers both before and after the Civil War” and the “first book to examine black and white women editing and writing for magazines and newspapers in the nineteenth-century South.” It is difficult to confirm these claims, but there is no doubt that Wells has gone deeper than previous scholars in uncovering lost tales about extant and surviving magazines and newspapers in the South and the women who created and sustained them. It is also true that scholars have focused more on the literature of the American South than on periodicals, which contain advice columns, literary reviews, poetry, political news, and short fiction, making them widely popular in their day.
Certainly, Wells challenges the notion of the southern belle and identifies some of the journalism that would help to lead to widespread demands for gender and racial equality at the turn of the century. Women served as correspondents, editors, and reporters and began to demand political and social rights for all.
Fahs and Wells are successful for precisely the same reason: Both authors conduct painstaking research and focus on individual stories of frustration and triumph, weaving those stories into a discussion of the themes that unite them. Many of the women whose lives Fahs and Wells illuminate existed in the shadows; others loudly took the stage, making it clear they had something to say and contributing publicly to social and political change in urban centers and the American South, respectively. Whoever the women were and however they chose to contribute to their communities, Fahs and Wells have resurrected stories few people know.
